Austin's land development code lawsuit returns to court in November

A lawsuit filed against city officials over the rollout of Austin's land development code rewrite has held up the revision for over a year. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
A lawsuit filed against city officials over the rollout of Austin's land development code rewrite has held up the revision for over a year. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)

A lawsuit filed against city officials over the rollout of Austin's land development code rewrite has held up the revision for over a year. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)

Austin's appeal to a court ruling over the city's contentious and long-delayed land development code rewrite is set to move forward later this fall.

Initiated in 2012, Austin's attempt to rethink city rules for land use has moved through various forms over the past decade. A years-long development code rewrite process, CodeNEXT, fizzled out in 2018 but was followed by a new version the next year. That eventually made it weeks away from a final City Council vote—before ending up the subject of the lawsuit that has held up movement since the early days of the pandemic.

A Travis County district court judge ruled against the city in that suit last spring, leading to City Council's vote to appeal the decision weeks later. And after a year and a half, oral arguments in the city's appeal are now set to be held virtually on the afternoon of Nov. 17 before a panel of justices of the Fourteenth Court of Appeals in Houston.

In the years since city officials first announced their intent to launch a land code overhaul, the process has proven controversial across town given its potential effects on local development, traffic, displacement, neighborhood character and resident property rights. City Council was also divided on the future of the rules governing what can be built throughout Austin as it moved toward its final vote in 2020.

With those issues at the forefront of the overall process, the lawsuit filed in late 2019 centered instead on the question of whether Austin residents could object to the proposed change before its final approval. The city argued they could not, in part given the comprehensive and citywide scope of the update. The plaintiffs—19 local property owners who named City Manager Spencer Cronk and City Council members as defendants in the suit—said Austin's claim had no legal foundation and that a code revision carries the same requirements as an individual zoning case.


State code holds that residents of any property up for a zoning change, or living within 200 feet of the property, must be notified before a public zoning hearing and have the chance to protest the change to a city's zoning commission—in Austin, the Planning Commission. If 20% or more of such neighborhood challenges are deemed valid, the threshold for City Council's vote to approve the rezoning is raised.

In its code revision process of 2019 and 2020, Austin did not notify all city residents when the proposed rewrite headed to the Planning Commission or allow for widespread challenges to the plan, sparking the opposition lawsuit. The city has said the state zoning rules related to hearing notices and resident protests do not apply to its sweeping code update, and that alerting everyone in Austin within 200 feet of every property set to be rezoned through the process would come with a high price tag.

Judge Jan Soifer ruled against Austin's arguments in March 2020 in Travis County district court. Her decision came just as deliberations over the code rewrite were headed toward a possible conclusion at City Hall, but were then put on the backburner given rising concerns related to COVID-19. The city appeal filed last April had since garnered amicus briefs from local groups in favor and opposed to Austin's position.

Both sides of the suit engaged in a written back-and-forth in June over a separate legal case, representing the most recent submissions related to the land code lawsuit, per state appeals court filings. The mid-November arguments were scheduled Sept. 23 and will be held via Zoom videoconference.
By Ben Thompson

Austin City Hall Reporter

Ben joined Community Impact Newspaper in January 2019 after graduating with a degree in journalism from Northeastern University in Boston. After spending more than two years covering in The Woodlands area, he moved to Austin in 2021 to cover City Hall and other news throughout the city.



MOST RECENT

Trustee Lynn Boswell speaks at an Oct. 14 information session of the Austin ISD board of trustees. (Maggie Quinlan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin ISD seeks firm to help redistricting process

As districts within AISD are redrawn, the board of trustees will get legal assistance from a firm it has not yet chosen.

The amended version of the planned development unit will now go to the Austin Planning Commission for review. (Rendering courtesy Austin Environmental Commission)
CI NATION ROUNDUP: Austin commission OKs development plan near Lady Bird Lake; shopping center coming to Porter and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Oct. 15.

Photo of Bird Bird Biscuit
Bird Bird Biscuit opens North Austin location

Bird Bird Biscuit is opening a second location in North Austin.

Kyle Center Street Trick-or-Treat will be held Oct. 23. (Courtesy city of Kyle)
20 fall activities to do across Central Texas; Grand Donuts coming to Georgetown and more top area news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from the Central Texas area.

Early voting starts Oct. 18. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Travis County early voting begins Oct. 18

There are 27 polling locations throughout the county.

This inaugural festival will feature events for families and their furry friends. (Courtsey/Puptopia Fest)
6 Central Austin October events

Six events ranging from a brewery festival to a family-friendly garden tour.


Josh LaRue said he grew up listening to music and loves to help people find new favorites. 
(Photos by Darcy Sprague/Community Impact Newspaper)
Breakaway Records offers Austines a place to buy, sell used records

The store remains a staple of the North Loop neighborhood.

The Smoking Joint is now open under the umbrella of Click Click Chew virtual food hall in Cypress. (Courtesy Kirsten Gilliam)
CI NATION ROUNDUP: More restaurant, retail space could be coming to north Frisco development; Locatelli’s owners launch virtual food hall in Cypress, and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Oct. 14.

Photo of a child receiving a shot
Austin Public Health prepares for possible expansion of COVID-19 vaccine to younger kids

The Food and Drug Administration is scheduled to consider authorizing Pfizer's vaccine for use in children ages 5-11 later this month.

A rendering is shown of a flexible space inside Panther Creek High School, which includes learning stairs and a collaboration board. The school's attendance zones are drawn to pull from Lone Star and Memorial high schools. (Courtesy Corgan)
CI NATION ROUNDUP: Frisco ISD proposes attendance zone modifications; concerns are voiced over Grogan's Mill Village Center vacancies, plus more top stories

Take a look at the top five trending stories across all of Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas as of Oct. 13.

200 Academy Drive could be redeveloped to bring live music and housing to the South River City neighborhood. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Planning commission OK's initial redevelopment plan for Austin Opera House revival

The project would bring a mixed-use development, including a 1,200-capacity venue and 120 new homes, to the South River City neighborhood.