Tense land development code debate leaves Austin City Council members concerned over tenor of proceedings

Austin Mayor Steve Adler (center), flanked by Assistant City Manager Christopher Shorter and City Attorney Ann Morgan, listen to public testimony on the land development code rewrite Dec. 7. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Mayor Steve Adler (center), flanked by Assistant City Manager Christopher Shorter and City Attorney Ann Morgan, listen to public testimony on the land development code rewrite Dec. 7. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

Austin Mayor Steve Adler (center), flanked by Assistant City Manager Christopher Shorter and City Attorney Ann Morgan, listen to public testimony on the land development code rewrite Dec. 7. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

The second day of Austin City Council deliberation over the most recent draft of the city’s proposed overhaul to its land development code packed a punch.

Amid the hours of at times heated debate over specific aspects of the code on Feb. 12, some council members claimed they were being accused and treated unfairly, others remained tight-lipped throughout, the mayor linked one argument to climate change denial and there was talk of a “settlement” on the dais that could overhaul the overhaul in the name of consensus.

Austin has been working to rewrite its land code, the rules governing what can be built in the city and where since 2012. In August 2018, City Council had chosen to kill the existing 5-year effort due to the growing division amongst Austinites over the code’s direction. The effort rebooted in February 2019, but much of the division remains.

City Council is aiming to take its second of three votes on the land code by Feb. 13, with a plan of final approval in late March or early April. When council began deliberation on the second vote on Feb. 11, they were tasked with working through 80 changes brought forward by individual council members, ranging among topics such as minimum lot sizes, the intensity of housing in certain areas of town and parking requirements. Through two days they took care of 38 amendments, with the debate reaching a fever pitch several times.

Of the 25 votes City Council took on changes through Feb. 12—some of the amendments were postponed or withdrawn—nine passed unanimously. The remaining 16 proposed changes—nine passed, seven failed—were the products of a split dais. Of the 16 split votes, 11 found Council Members Kathie Tovo, Leslie Pool, Alison Alter and Ann Kitchen together as the minority voting bloc.


For much of the Feb. 12 meeting—City Council only debated for an hour on Feb. 11—it was the bloc of Alter, Tovo, Kitchen and Pool asking most of the questions and challenging staff and their colleagues to provide explanations for proposed changes. Other council members were notably terse in their responses, sometimes even passing on requests to further explain their perspective.

At one point, Tovo questioned staff on why they were proposing increased housing density along a central section of North Lamar Boulevard, an area of town long designated for such density. At another, Tovo asked Council Member Jimmy Flannigan to explain a change he proposed for reducing mandated building setbacks for some zones—a request he rejected, simply telling Tovo if she didn’t like the change she could just vote against it.

The growing tension reached a boiling point when Tovo proposed an amendment that would restrict properties in documented localized flooding areas from transition zone entitlements. Transition zones are zoning categories that allow moderate housing density, and typically fall between the less dense neighborhood interiors where single-family homes are located and the highly dense transportation corridors where one would find high-rises.

Mayor Steve Adler said he would not support the change, because he felt it linked greater housing density to increased flood risk when city staff and the city’s watershed experts have regularly said there is no link. Adler called it “unfortunate” that neighborhood residents are being made to believe by some in the community that there is a link. He then said the refusal to accept the science and explanation laid out by the city’s experts reminded him of climate change denial. Tovo took immediate issue, and told Adler the issue was “not as clear cut” as he described.

The tense exchange continued as Tovo brought forward an amendment to reduce the size of transition zones throughout the city, a topic that has remained a focal point throughout the multi-year process. Adler asked Tovo and Alter, who had a similar amendment later in the evening, if they would vote for the land development code as a whole if the transition zone reduction change was made. Adler said he would consider supporting the move if it meant reaching a broader consensus on the project.

Alter said for her and her constituents in West Austin, a way forward would have to include reducing transition zones. She said trust in elected officials and city staff among her constituents has eroded. She called the tenor of the day’s debate “indefensible” and said the way some of the council members were being treated was “inappropriate.”

Adler said everyone is responsible for eroded trust, emphasizing the difficulty of this process on each council member and their constituents. He said his question regarding transition zones still stood and called it “the settlement” and “the compromise” to get this land development code passed. Tovo said she would think about it.

Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza interjected toward the end and said the point of the land code rewrite process was to get more housing. She said the amount of housing the code could yield was the essential element of the code, not the size of transition zones. Staff said they would run an analysis on how much housing could be produced if Adler’s transition zone reduction deal was a reality.


MOST RECENT

Photo of three men drinking at a tiki bar
Ramen Tatsu-Ya readies new South Austin concept, plus more area business news

Tiki bar and restaurant Tiki Tatsu-Ya is set to open later this summer.

Minnesota-based Rockler Woodworking and Hardware will open a location in La Frontera in late September. (Brooke Sjoberg/Community Impact Newspaper)
Rockler Woodworking and Hardware coming to Round Rock

Minnesota-based Rockler Woodworking and Hardware is coming to La Frontera in Round Rock in late September.

The proposed Wild Ridge master-planned neighborhood northeast of downtown Dripping Springs would include 960 homes on 40- to 60-foot-wide lots. (Courtesy City of Dripping Springs)
Master-planned neighborhood in Dripping Springs to bring 960 homes, new roads

The proposed development by Meritage Homes would feature amenities such as a disc golf course.

Jasper Brown, interim chief of Austin Travis County EMS, proposed that the city add $1.2 million to its budget for EMS to prepare for mass shootings. (Maggie Quinlan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin council considers adding millions to budget for mass shooting response, mental health crises

A combined $8.5 million could fund clinicians' work along with training and ballistic vests in case of mass shootings

Q&A: Greg Smith, executive director of Fast Growth School Coalition

Greg Smith is the former superintendent of Clear Creek ISD and became executive director of Fast Growth School Coalition in December 2020. 

Photo of the Travis County sign
Travis County proposes tax rate for 2021-22 fiscal year, prepares for budget approval process

Due to increasing property values, the property tax rate is expected to be around $0.017 lower in the coming fiscal year.

Photo of school supples
Parents weigh in: What are your considerations heading into the 2021-22 school year?

Community Impact Newspaper seeks parent feedback as we prepare for our annual education edition.

Photo of the Austin Police Department
City of Austin certifies Save Austin Now's petition to increase police staffing, adding it to fall ballot

The measure would require two police officers for every 1,000 area residents, among other provisions.

Photo of a doctor with a pregnant woman
Austin health experts warn delta variant could pose higher risk for pregnant women

Maternal medicine doctors across Central Texas have seen increasing numbers of pregnant women coming to the hospital with breathing issues and pregnancy complications as a result of COVID-19.

Wayback Burgers makes cooked-to-order burgers and hand-dipped milkshakes. (Courtesy Wayback Burgers)
6 eateries open or coming to Cedar Park, Leander; Trudy's North Star reopens in Northwest Austin and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area, including Tiff's Treats opening in Hutto.

Trudy's Tex-Mex courtesy photo
Trudy’s North Star reopens with renovated restaurant, new menu

The restaurant underwent recent renovations to its dining rooms, exterior dining spaces and bar areas.

Road closure updates graphic
TxDOT to close I-35 main lanes in North Austin late Aug. 2 and 3

Southbound and northbound I-35 lanes will close late at night Aug. 2 and 3 as the state works on new flyovers.