Nearly 40% of NBISD remote learners are failing at least one class, more than double the rate of in-school learners

New Braunfels ISD reported higher rates of class failure among remote students than among in-person students. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
New Braunfels ISD reported higher rates of class failure among remote students than among in-person students. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

New Braunfels ISD reported higher rates of class failure among remote students than among in-person students. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)

After the first nine-week grading period, New Braunfels ISD reported that 707 of the 3,490 remote learners across the district were failing three or more classes, and 375 had attendance issues.

At a Nov. 9 board of trustees meeting, Kara Bock, NBISD assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction, shared data with the board that was collected by campus principals and teachers.

When calculating the rate of students failing, principals tracked all classes for middle and high school students, including elective courses, and tracked only core classes for elementary students, Bock said.

The data showed that 39.06% of remote learners across all grade levels were failing at least one class as compared to 14.45% of in-person students who were failing at least one class.

According to the report, 10% of remote elementary students were failing three or more classes, 28% of remote middle school students were failing three or more classes and 32% of remote high school students were failing three or more classes.

Ahead of the Oct. 19 start of the second quarter, students were able to request to change their instruction environment, and the district announced that any remote learner who was not passing three core classes and had below 90% attendance would be required to return to campus.


More than 780 students were asked to return to campus due to class failures or attendance issues, including more than 290 high school students, according to district data.

“Principals and their teams worked very hard on identifying these kids and having conversations with the parents and the high school students on their performance,” Bock said.

However, after NBISD received approval for their plans, the Texas Education Agency announced that districts could not require students to return to campus, according to Superintendent Randy Moczygemba.

Moczygemba said that Texas Commissioner of Education Mike Morath later clarified that districts could require students to return to campus in the case of multiple class failure or attendance issues, but students would have the ability to appeal the requirement for medical reasons.

As a result of the discussions, not all students who were failing multiple classes or had attendance issues returned to campus, though 76.5% of students returned to campus for the second nine-weeks, up from 62% for the second nine-weeks.

Bock said that one of the key reasons for increased failure rates among remote learners is that some students are not engaging with the synchronous instruction or participating in virtual discussions.

“If they're not going to those synchronous times when the teachers are offering the actual instruction, and they're just trying to do it on their own, that could affect their comprehension of the materials,” Bock said. “If the kids aren’t participating, it is going to hurt them.”

Similar failure and attendance rates have been reported in surrounding counties, according to Board President Sherry Harrison.

The district plans to continue working with students and parents to ensure students are fully engaging with the material and will continue to require students not meeting district standards to return to campus or to work with administrators to develop a plan.

“When you don't come to class, you're missing out on the discussion, and you're missing out on the interaction,” Bock said. “The standards are just as high at home as they are in the classroom.”
By Lauren Canterberry
Lauren began covering New Braunfels for Community Impact Newspaper in 2019. Her reporting focuses on education, development, breaking news and community interest stories. Lauren is originally from South Carolina and is a graduate of the University of Georgia.


MOST RECENT

Wag-A-Bag is headquartered in Round Rock. (Megan Cardona/Community Impact Newspaper)
Wag-A-Bag to operate under new ownership, name; Austin, TxDOT at odds over I-35 overhaul; and more top Central Texas news

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Austin area.

Thai Racha will reopen in New Braunfels sometime in mid-May. (Lauren Canterberry/Community Impact Newspaper)
Thai Racha to reopen in New Braunfels under new ownership

The restaurant temporarily closed in April for cleaning and updates.

The Mayfair development will include a variety of housing, commercial and public space options. (Courtesy city of New Braunfels)
City of New Braunfels to host public information sessions about upcoming 1,880-acre development

The project is anticipated to include residential, commercial and public spaces.

Early voting runs from April 19-27, and election day is May 1. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Election day 2021: Bergquist, Minus win in unofficial final results for New Braunfels ISD board of trustees

Tim Hennessee, Courtney Biasatti, Eric Bergquist and Steve Minus have won their respective seats on the CISD or NBISD boards of trustees, according to unofficial final results.

The early voting period in Comal County concluded on April 27. (Lauren Canterberry/Community Impact Newspaper)
Unofficial final results show Bowers, Spradley to take seats on New Braunfels City Council

Incumbent Bowers and newcomer Spradley have won their races for City Council, according to unofficial final results.

The New Braunfels area is expected to get several inches of rain over the weekend, which could impact setup for the event. (Lauren Canterberry/Community Impact Newspaper)
Wet weather may impact Wein and Sanger Lite in New Braunfels

The New Braunfels area is expected to get several inches of rain over the weekend, which could impact setup for the event.

Chipotle Mexican Grill opened a new location featuring a drive-thru pickup Chipotlane in Round Rock. (Courtesy Chipotle Mexican Grill)
Chipotle opens in Round Rock; QuikTrip coming to Georgetown and more top news from Central Texas

Read the top business and community news from the past week from Central Texas.

Keith Lane has served as interim police chief since late 2020. (Ian Pribanic/Community Impact Newspaper)
New Braunfels selects new chief of police, ending monthslong search

Keith Lane has served as interim police chief since late 2020.