Eanes ISD submits open records request to TCAD in response to appraisal dispute

The Eanes ISD board of trustees discussed the TCAD's decision not to appraise residential properties in 2020 during a Feb. 25 board meeting. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)
The Eanes ISD board of trustees discussed the TCAD's decision not to appraise residential properties in 2020 during a Feb. 25 board meeting. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)

The Eanes ISD board of trustees discussed the TCAD's decision not to appraise residential properties in 2020 during a Feb. 25 board meeting. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)

Following a Feb. 12 announcement from the Travis Central Appraisal District that it will not appraise residential properties this year, Eanes ISD is seeking more information regarding the TCAD’s reappraisal plans for 2020.



The TCAD’s statement was in response to the Austin Board of Realtors sending the district a cease-and-desist order in May, which prohibited the TCAD from using ABoR’s market data in the appraisal process.



According to that order, which Community Impact Newspaper obtained from the TCAD, ABoR will not license its database “for establishing property values for tax purposes” or “grant licenses to any participant, subscriber, or third party to sublicense the [database] for establishing property values for tax purposes.”



Without this data, TCAD Chief Appraiser Marya Crigler stated she will use last year’s property values for 2020.



“What the assessor has stated right now is that they believe with the data that they're using, there has been no change in the residential market values for this year,” EISD Superintendent Tom Leonard said March 5. “We [EISD] believe that is not correct.”



Though TCAD received the order in May, Leonard stated the district only learned of this subject in February and added local municipalities and school districts will receive less revenue as a result of the TCAD’s decision, negatively impacting teachers, first responders, students and other community members.



According to a March 4 email from EISD general counsel Allyson Collins, the district submitted an open records request in accordance with Texas Government Code Chapter 552 for a number of reports, sales information and data from TCAD.



The information requested includes a copy of any analysis or report prepared by or for TCAD, all real property sales information used for real property appraisals within EISD for 2020, and any documents or action related to the TCAD reappraisal plan for 2019 and 2020.



In the records request, EISD is seeking any analysis or report that would indicate stagnant market values in 2020 for the Westlake area.



Other entities have successfully conducted appraisals without the use of MLS data, two of those being the state comptroller’s office and Bexar County, Leonard said.



“I would like to see [Crigler] using some of the strategies [the state comptroller’s office and Bexar County] are using, which are accepted standards for appraisers,” Leonard said. “If [Crigler] is confident that is the case and she has the data to support it, which she said publicly, then we’d like to see that data.”



Most local taxing entities—such as cities, counties and community college districts—set their tax rates based on the total taxable value provided by their appraisal district.



If appraisal values do not change, these entities can still set the tax rate at whatever increases revenue by 3.5% year over year, the maximum allowed under a new state law.



But school districts have a different formula for calculating local property tax rates.



As a result, TCAD predicts the order will negatively impact school districts in Travis County.



Even if appraisal values remain the same, market values will likely continue to rise, creating a gap in the appraised value of homes and the price they would fetch on the open market.



Last year, the total taxable value of properties in Travis County was appraised at $275.06 billion, according to data obtained from TCAD. This amounted to a 11.37% increase from 2018, factoring in both increasing value for existing property and new construction.



It was also the ninth consecutive year that the appraisal roll increased.



When allocating funding to school districts, the state comptroller’s office conducts a biennial property value study to determine the accuracy of the local appraisal district’s work in determining the total taxable value.



Emma Freer contributed to this report.

By Amy Rae Dadamo
Amy Rae Dadamo is the reporter for Lake Travis-Westlake, where her work focuses on city government and education. Originally from New Jersey, Amy Rae relocated to Austin after graduating from Ramapo College of New Jersey in May 2019.


MOST RECENT

Public schools cannot require students, teachers, parents, and other staff members or visitors to wear masks after June 4, Gov. Greg Abbott declared in an executive order issued May 18. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Leander ISD 'highly recommends' masks; tax-free weekend tips and more Austin-area news

Read the latest business and education news from the Central Texas area.

Sinaloan seafood restaurant El Coco Pirata is now open in Northwest Austin. (Community Impact Newspaper)
New Mexican seafood spot El Coco Pirata now open in Northwest Austin

El Coco Pirata serves classic Sinaloan seafood dishes.

School supplies will be exempt from the 8.25% sales tax Aug. 6-8. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
What to know before the statewide tax-free weekend Aug. 6-8

Customers will not have to pay the standard 8.25% sales tax on select clothing, footwear, school supplies and backpacks under $100.

The city of West Lake Hills could move forward with a capital improvements bond for the Nov. 2 election. (Courtesy Pexels)
November bond election supported by West Lake Hills City Council

The bond package could total $25 million and would tackle the city's critical infrastructure needs.

Public schools cannot require students, teachers, parents, and other staff members or visitors to wear masks after June 4, Gov. Greg Abbott declared in an executive order issued May 18. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Leander ISD 'highly recommends' masks for students, staff

Leander ISD updated its COVID-19 protocols this week to include green, yellow and red transmission levels. The district is at its yellow level as of July 28.

Photo of the Sobering Center
Travis County moves forward with plans for mental health diversion program at Sobering Center

The program would divert people experiencing mental health crises away from jail and towards supportive services following low-level offenses.

Baylor Scott & White Pflugerville
Ascension, Baylor Scott & White to require all employees be fully vaccinated against coronavirus by fall

Ascension and Baylor Scott & White have announced all eligible employees must be vaccinated against COVID-19 in the coming months. 

Austin City Council will convene for a regular meeting July 29, its first since mid-June. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Hall notebook: Council to look at downtown safety, homelessness and budgeting in return from meetings break

The first regular council meeting since mid-June features a packed agenda and opportunity for resident feedback on Austin's proposed budget.

Photo of a hand holding a vaccine vial
As COVID-19 hospitalizations track upward, Austin Public Health renews call for vaccinations

APH also mirrors the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's latest guidance for vaccinated individuals to wear masks in some circumstances.

The request to table talks regarding designated campsites came one week after city staff detailed two properties that could be used for such an initiative. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Ellis, Harper-Madison call for halt to Austin's 'Band-Aid' sanctioned homeless encampment plans

The East and Southwest Austin representatives shared their thoughts on the process one week after city properties in their districts were tapped as workable encampment sites.

School starts Aug. 18 at Lake Travis ISD. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Lake Travis ISD releases early plans for 2021-22 school year on masks, virtual learning, vaccines

Lake Travis ISD Superintendent Paul Norton addressed plans for the 2021-22 school year in a July 27 letter to the community.