City of Austin, Travis County prepare for property tax revenue cap

Local officials stress the flexibility of an 8% rollback rate; while not always used, it can prove critical during recessions.nnSOURCES: City of Austin, Travis County/Community Impact Newspaper

Local officials stress the flexibility of an 8% rollback rate; while not always used, it can prove critical during recessions.nnSOURCES: City of Austin, Travis County/Community Impact Newspaper

Image description
Considering the cap
Image description
Take home savings
Image description
The biggest slice
In June, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signed into law a bill that will limit local governments from raising their property tax revenue more than 3.5% year-over-year—excluding new construction and debt obligations—without triggering an election.

Previously, local governments were able to raise property tax revenue up to 8%—known as the rollback rate—before voter approval was required.

“When you look at what the law actually does, it’s pretty simple,” said Jacob Asmussen, Central Texas bureau chief for conservative group Empower Texans. “If a local government wants to raise your taxes more than 3.5%, they have to ask you.”

But local officials said the cap, when it takes effect in fiscal year 2020-21, will provide little relief to property owners while causing major cuts at the city and county, whose largest expenses are public safety and the criminal justice system, respectively.

Both sides agree on one point, at least.

“The revenue cap ... changes everything,” said Deece Eckstein, intergovernmental relations officer for Travis County.

Impact to public safety


As in most cities, public safety is Austin’s largest expense. Police, fire and EMS made up nearly 70% of the city’s operating budget in fiscal year 2018-19.

Council members have also approved a series of additional investments.

In June 2018, they voted to build five new fire stations in underserved areas by 2023 at a total estimated cost of $86.4 million.

In November, council members approved a four-year $44.6 million contract between the city of Austin and the Austin Police Association, a labor union that represents Austin Police Department officers.

That same month, City Manager Spencer Cronk said he intended to incorporate APD Chief Brian Manley’s staffing plan—which recommends 123 new officer positions—into future budgets.

Funding for both the contract and the staffing plan, however, was based on an assumed rollback rate of at least 6%, per city staff.

“[The cap] will make it harder for us to hire additional police, fire and other personnel as the City continues to grow and tougher to absorb annual cost increases in wages, rents and insurance premiums,” a city spokesperson said via email.

City staff are working to balance the budget before the cap takes effect to account for these commitments, which may include revising labor agreements, the spokesperson said.

APA President Ken Casaday said he is not worried about the current contract.

“The city’s continuing to spend a massive amount of money on homeless issues and housing,” he said. “So we certainly don’t expect to see a lot of changes [to public safety funding].”

Both Casaday and Austin Firefighters Association President Bob Nicks said they are concerned about future spending, however.

“Sometimes people take public safety for granted,” Nicks said. “If things are going well, then that’s a big part of the budget, and we just cut it back.”

But cuts can prove dangerous when demand for public safety services is high, such as during a wildfire or the series of bombings that occurred in Austin last year.

“When you start cutting things out, you reduce your capacity to flex and multiply yourself when you have a bigger event,” Nicks said.

Loss of flexibility


Travis County is different from the city of Austin both in that it relies more heavily on property tax revenue—which made up 70.6% of its general fund in FY 2018-19, compared to 47.1% of the city’s—and it operates a smaller budget.

Over the last 30 years, the county’s median revenue growth rate has been 3.72%, which is fairly close to the new cap, Eckstein said.

But the county has approached the 8% rollback rate three times in that period—in 1993, 2000 and 2009—following recessions.

Economic downturns increase local government costs in two ways, Eckstein said. First, they typically correspond with a dip in new construction, which is a reliable source of new property tax revenue. Second, they increase demand for county services, such as utility assistance and—because crime tends to rise when the economy is bad—jails.

With the rollback rate at 8%, Travis County has been able to take a “just-in-time” approach to its budgets, Eckstein said, eschewing the need to build a large reserve because there is the option to raise revenue in times of crisis. “But that sort of flexibility is going to be gone now,” he said.

Choosing priorities


Travis County is mandated by the state—and the U.S. Constitution—to provide indigent defense.

Currently, the county contracts private attorneys to represent indigent clients, or those charged with crimes but unable to afford counsel.

In an effort to improve this system, the Travis County Commissioners Court approved a state grant proposal in May that, if awarded, will cover half the startup costs of a general public defender’s office. Austin is the largest U.S. city without one.

Although the cap includes a carve-out for some indigent defense spending, it does not include public defender’s offices.

Some commissioners have raised concerns about how the county will afford the new office in light of the cap, especially once the grant runs out and the county is responsible for funding it fully.

“We’d be challenged to implement [the office] over time without having some serious implications to other county programs,” Budget Director Travis Gatlin said.

Members of the work group tasked with developing the proposal said commissioners knew a 3.5% cap was likely when they voted to approve it.

“I don’t think the proposal that we’ve put forward was a kind of pie in the sky,” said Amanda Woog, chairperson of the work group and executive director of the Texas Fair Defense Project.

The cost of the proposed public defender’s office to the county is $26.9 million over four years. Comparatively, the county spent $233.2 million on its sheriff’s and prosecutor offices in FY 2018-19.

“It would be great if the conversation was less about how the county is going to come up with that money [for the office] and more about how the county can reduce its current over-reliance on incarceration and policing,” Woog said.

What’s ahead


The city and county are developing their budget proposals for FY 2019-20, the last year the rollback rate will be 8%. Short-term, the cap could cause higher taxes.

“The perverse effect of what the Legislature has done is it has sped up some of the investments we intended to make in a phased approach so that we can shove them in ... this year’s budget, knowing that we will be seriously curtailed in at least the next two budget cycles,” County Judge Sarah Eckhardt said at a Commissioners Court meeting June 18.

The Legislature reconvenes in 2021, but Eckstein said it is unlikely the cap will be reconsidered.

“There’s still going to be a little ideological, hardcore [group] out there that’s going to say, ‘Three-and-a-half [percent] wasn’t low enough. We should have gone for two-and-a-half.’”

View our other Real Estate Edition coverage. 
By Emma Freer
Emma Freer began covering Central Austin for Community Impact Newspaper in 2017. Her beat includes the Travis County Commissioners Court and local business news. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School in 2017.


MOST RECENT

Austin government, nonprofit and business leaders recently participated in a weeks-long summit centered on unsheltered homelessness in the city. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Plan to house 3,000 homeless individuals in Austin in the next three years would cost $515 million

The plan Austin City Council members discussed April 20 emerged from a weekslong community-wide summit on homelessness.

Photo of Zilker Park
Travis County establishes Civilian Conservation Corps to tackle climate, environmental projects

The program will create opportunities for residents to work on projects including wildfire prevention, solar energy promotion and park cleanups.

Residents march to the Texas Capitol in protests after the killing of George Floyd in May 2020. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Austin leaders react to Derek Chauvin guilty verdict

The former Minneapolis police officer was found guilty of second-degree murder, third-degree murder and manslaughter for the killing of George Floyd in May 2020.

Austin Public Health Director Stephanie Hayden-Howard speaks to reporters March 13 at the Delco Actiity Center in Northeast Austin. Residents can walk up to the Delco Center on April 22 and 23 and receive vaccines without an appointment. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Public Health will accept walk-up vaccinations at the Delco Activity Center starting April 22

APH will also leave its registration portal open throughout most of the week.

Early voting for Travis County's May 1 local elections opened April 19. In this file photo, voters line up ahead of the 2020 primary elections at Millennium Youth Entertainment Complex in East Austin. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
More than 8,000 Travis County voters cast ballots on first day of early voting

Early voting for the county's May 1 election began April 19 and will run through April 27.

The Delco Activity Center in Northeast Austin is one of the locations where residents can receive a COVID-19 vaccine. (Jack Flalger/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin vaccine updates: Demand slows as state begins marketing push

Appointments are beginning to go unfilled, and local health officials say demand has caught up to supply. All adults in the U.S. are now eligible to be vaccinated.

Blue Corn Harvest Leander is located at 11840 Hero Way W., Bldg. A, Leander. (Taylor Girtman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Blue Corn Harvest opens in Leander; park, pizzeria launches social club and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area.

Photo of two performers on an outdoor SXSW stage
South by Southwest sells ownership stake in company to Rolling Stone owner Penske Media Corp.

SXSW leadership called the sale a "lifeline" for the conference and festivals.

Photo of people receiving vaccines in a gym
Austin Public Health lengthens windows for vaccine appointment signups

Residents age 18 and up can now sign up for appointments with APH any time from Saturday to Tuesday morning.

Austin Anthem watch party
Crowds of fans converge on North Austin to watch inaugural Austin FC game

Breweries around Q2 Stadium in North Austin brought in large outdoor screens and new employees to host fans of Austin FC for the team's historic first match.

Austin Police Department
UPDATE: Loop 360 closed in both directions in Northwest Austin due to a shooting incident

Residents who live in the Arboretum area in Northwest Austin are advised to shelter in place.

Early voting for the May 1 election opens April 19 at a 7 a.m. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Early voting in Austin opens April 19: See what’s on the ballot, where to vote

City residents will be making decisions on eight propositions ranging from whether to adopt a strong mayor government system to whether to reinstate public camping bans.