Still in the dark on Georgetown’s energy situation? Here’s a primer

Georgetownu2019s energy contracts have the city buying more energy than needed to meet demand in present day.

Georgetownu2019s energy contracts have the city buying more energy than needed to meet demand in present day.

Georgetown electric customers are seeing a new increase on their bills this month as city officials attempt to reduce costs associated with city energy contracts.

This year, the city needs to avoid a similar situation to the $6.84 million shortfall in the amount of money that was expected to be left in the electric fund budget for Georgetown Utility Systems at the end of the city’s last fiscal year on Sept. 30.

Officials attributed the shortfall to price and demand volatility in Texas’ wholesale energy market and on the structure of the city’s renewable energy contracts.

The contracts have led to Georgetown buying more energy than the city actually needs in present day.

“Ideally, you want to be contracting for the exact amount of energy that we need here locally, but the reality of our fast-growing community and the dynamic of how energy demand fluctuates just makes that a challenge,” City Manager David Morgan told Georgetown City Council in January.

The power cost adjustment, or PCA, portion of customers’ bills increased Feb. 1 by $0.0135 per kilowatt-hour, setting the new rate at $0.0175 per kilowatt-hour until September.

Actual monthly increases for customers will depend on how much electricity they use, but city estimates show a customer using the citywide monthly average of 949 kWhs will pay $12.82 more than before.

Missed projections in the electric fund have become a trend in recent years.

Budgeted costs between 2016 and 2018 were a combined $26 million lower than what the city needed to meet its contract obligations and provide electric service to customers, according to the city.

Officials compensated in the past through PCA increases as well as delays on some planned energy-related construction projects and using debt to pay for more immediate projects ready to break ground.

The latest rate change follows a separate increase that began Jan. 1 of $4.80 to the base rate paid by electric customers. Increasing the monthly base rate, which is now $24.80 per residential customer, was necessary to cover growing operating costs for the city’s electric service, according to city officials.

The city announced Feb. 8 it issued two requests for proposals: one seeking a consultant to oversee its energy portfolio and another to review the city’s management of energy purchases. City officials set a Feb. 21 deadline for proposals to review the internal management of its energy contracts and a March 7 deadline for proposals to take over management of the city’s energy portfolio.

After proposals and bids are received, Georgetown City Council will decide selections.


New strategy


Morgan said the increase to the PCA in February would generate about $6 million and help avoid another year of cost overage.

“It is really needed to ensure the stability of the electric fund,” Morgan said.

Morgan said the city has initiated talks to renegotiate its renewable contracts, and officials are also looking for utility companies or third-party brokers that might buy portions of the excess energy Georgetown acquires.

“Market fundamentals have changed significantly since our contracts were originally proposed and originally executed,” said Jim Briggs, the city’s general manager of utilities.

The contracts include a 20-year, 144 megawatt-hour capacity deal with EDF Renewables' Spinning Spur 3 wind farm that began in 2015 and a 25-year, 150-mWh agreement with the Buckthorn solar plant, now owned by Clearway Energy, that began in 2018.

City officials say they are bound by the terms of the renewable contracts from releasing specific rates or other details, and the Texas Public Information Act allows exemptions of certain contract details.

According to information the city has made available, Georgetown spent about $52.5 million in 2018 to buy more than 1 billion kWh of energy through all of its contracts combined. Energy usage last year was about 679 million kWh, or a little more than 63 percent of the total amount purchased, according to the city.

Power and money Sources: city of Georgetown, Georgetown Utility Systems/Community Impact Newspaper[/caption]

Decision points


Prior to the most recent budget shortfall, Georgetown officials touted contracts with wind and solar power producers as both an eco-friendly move and a win for the city’s financial future.

Georgetown was lauded as the largest U.S. city to transition to “100 percent” renewable energy, a designation that in Texas is based on a comparison between the amount of power purchased by utilities through contracts with renewable producers and the amount of power utilities pull from the statewide electric grid.

While the new solar and wind contracts make up the bulk of Georgetown’s energy portfolio, smaller portions come from a nonrenewable natural gas power producer through a contract that expires in 2021 and an additional contract with a smaller solar producer that ends in 2028.
“Market fundamentals have changed significantly since our contracts were originally proposed and originally executed.”
— Jim Briggs, Georgetown's general manager of utilities.

Briggs said during a presentation to council members in January that the city’s goals when negotiations with renewable providers first started in 2013 included finding competitive pricing; locking in long-term stable energy rates; and mitigating risk from outside regulatory, legislative and financial forces. Officials also sought to find deals to manage the city’s energy needs at times of peak demand as well as future needs as Georgetown continued to see fast population and development growth, he said.

At the time, market forecasts from the Electric Reliability Council of Texas, which manages sales on the state’s wholesale market, expected increased demand and prices during summer months to continue until 2021, Briggs said.

That trend would have allowed Georgetown to sell its excess power at well above the rates the city pays through its contracts, but a series of disruptions in the energy market mainly caused by weather, including Hurricane Harvey in 2017, along with the unexpected addition of several power plants in 2018 whose operation had previously been delayed, kept energy prices low, and the previous projections proved false, Briggs said.

Briggs told council members that moving forward, the city will base its energy strategy on market activity during the previous years.

ERCOT’s forecasts showing increased demand in recent years has largely been driven by needs from increasing oil and gas extraction in West Texas, according to the agency.

“ERCOT’s ability to meet Texans’ growing power needs through the record-setting summer of 2018 was supported by the actions taken by power suppliers and consumers, and the policymakers who are committed to the success of the ERCOT market,” ERCOT CEO Bill Magness said in a statement in a Dec. 4 news release.

Covering losses


City Council approved a series of budget amendments in December to account for the most recent shortfall, including a $4 million reduction in a budget fund for capital improvements.

Revenue amendments included adjustments to account for changes to the PCA charge, eliminating anticipated bond proceeds and reassigning a portion of the money the city is due to receive from the Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayor’s Challenge.

Adjustments to budget expenses included reducing the annual transfer of money from the electric fund to the city budget’s general fund by $1.2 million, delaying several new hires, bond issuances and equipment purchases.

Editor's note: A version of this story appears on the cover of the February 2019 issue of Community Impact Newspaper's Georgetown edition. 


MOST RECENT

Minnesota-based Rockler Woodworking and Hardware will open a location in La Frontera in late September. (Brooke Sjoberg/Community Impact Newspaper)
Rockler Woodworking and Hardware coming to Round Rock

Minnesota-based Rockler Woodworking and Hardware is coming to La Frontera in Round Rock in late September.

The proposed Wild Ridge master-planned neighborhood northeast of downtown Dripping Springs would include 960 homes on 40- to 60-foot-wide lots. (Courtesy City of Dripping Springs)
Master-planned neighborhood in Dripping Springs to bring 960 homes, new roads

The proposed development by Meritage Homes would feature amenities such as a disc golf course.

Georgetown's contract with Capital Metro will expire at the end of September. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
GoGeo fixed-route bus service in Georgetown to end Oct. 1

Paratransit services offered for residents with disabilities will continue.

Q&A: Greg Smith, executive director of Fast Growth School Coalition

Greg Smith is the former superintendent of Clear Creek ISD and became executive director of Fast Growth School Coalition in December 2020. 

Williamson County Sheriff’s Office
Sheriff’s office requests pay increases during Williamson County budget process

The Williamson County Sheriff's Office said its officers are paid less than law enforcement officers in city departments countywide.

Williamson County courthouse
Williamson County proposes lower tax rate ahead of final budget vote Aug. 31

The tax rate will go to support a recommended $440.5 million total operating budget.

Photo of a doctor with a pregnant woman
Austin health experts warn delta variant could pose higher risk for pregnant women

Maternal medicine doctors across Central Texas have seen increasing numbers of pregnant women coming to the hospital with breathing issues and pregnancy complications as a result of COVID-19.

Wayback Burgers makes cooked-to-order burgers and hand-dipped milkshakes. (Courtesy Wayback Burgers)
6 eateries open or coming to Cedar Park, Leander; Trudy's North Star reopens in Northwest Austin and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area, including Tiff's Treats opening in Hutto.

student writing on paper
Texas Legislature allows parents to opt for students to repeat grade levels or courses

Senate Bill 1697 is effective for the 2021-22 school year.

Photo of medical professions in a hospital
Health officials warn ICU space is critically low as Travis County sees its 900th COVID-19 death

As the delta variant drives transmission rates up, local hospital systems warn that ICUs are strained.

At Blue Gecko, a Texas Taco comes with seasoned ground beef, lettuce, tomato, sour cream, cheese and bacon. (Courtesy Blue Gecko)
New taco spot opens in Four Points; roadwork for Austin's Zilker Eagle continues and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area, including news on when Lou Neff Road will open in Central Austin.

TheraWave Vibrant Wellness is located at 1616 Williams Drive, Ste. 107, Georgetown. (Courtesy TheraWave Vibrant Wellness)
TheraWave Vibrant Wellness now open in Georgetown

The business is focused on offering pulsed electro-magnetic frequency therapy.