Why can’t Austin implement rolling blackouts? Austin Energy, ERCOT want to avoid complete systemwide electric grid failure

A jogger runs up a nearly deserted Manor Road in Austin on Feb. 16, two days after a winter storm dropped six inches of snow in the area. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
A jogger runs up a nearly deserted Manor Road in Austin on Feb. 16, two days after a winter storm dropped six inches of snow in the area. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)

A jogger runs up a nearly deserted Manor Road in Austin on Feb. 16, two days after a winter storm dropped six inches of snow in the area. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)

There is still no end in sight for the millions of Texans who remain without power into the evening of Feb. 16. Austin Energy, which has cut power to more than 184,000 customers, or 36% of all its users, says those without electricity should be prepared to not have power through the night and possibly longer as the Electric Reliability Council of Texas wrestles with balancing supply and demand on the state's energy grid.

ERCOT's role is to act as a traffic manager for energy throughout most of Texas, ensuring that supply and demand match up. At times in the past, ERCOT has had to cut down demand to keep this balance, usually by directing local energy utilities to conduct rolling blackouts.

But in this storm, those blackouts have not been rolling. Many who have lost power have remained without it, because the demand constraints are so severe there is no way to rotate through customers, Austin Energy officials say.

Austin Energy, and many of its counterparts across the state such as CenterPoint Energy and Oncor, have to limit usage so severely in order to adhere to ERCOT's mandate that there is no more power they can cut off without affecting critical infrastructure such as hospitals, fire stations and emergency medical service stations.

"The amount of time that people have had to be out of service for electricity during a time of extreme cold is terrible. It is unacceptable," ERCOT president and CEO Bill Magness said Feb. 16.


Protecting the grid

Although it will be little consolation to those going 36 hours or more with no power, allowing energy use to continue unchecked would create an even more dire scenario than the state is experiencing right now, according to local and state officials.

Without blackouts, continued unchecked demand from Texans expending more energy than usual to heat their homes in the cold would overtake supply and create what Magness called "catastrophic impacts" that would take a long time to fully repair.

"If the demand were to continue to go up and the generating or capacity supply continued to come down, there would be a point when the whole system would go black," Austin Energy General Manager Jackie Sargent said. "That would take not just days to restore power but weeks, and even longer for some customers throughout the ERCOT footprint."

Sargent said Austin Energy is doing everything in its power to avoid cutting power to grids with critical infrastructure, but if the imbalance were to worsen and more energy providers were to become unable to produce, she said she could not fully rule out that step.

"I am hoping that won't happen but I don't want to create a false sense of security because there is the potential the entire grid would go down. If that were to occur, we would not be able to keep those circuits energized," Sargent said.

How did we get here?

Texas, and ERCOT, have dealt with spikes in energy demand before during weather events. In fact, before this storm Magness said the energy grid manager and state lawmakers had a plan to deal with the storm.

"I don’t think there was any underestimation of the seriousness of this storm," he said.

What was surprising to ERCOT was the significant amount of energy production that became unavailable the night of Feb. 14. Winterization efforts that were sufficient for storms in previous years were not enough this year, as wide-ranging issues from ice on wind turbines and solar panels to natural gas plants that could not operate due to the cold temperatures caused a significant shortage.

Dan Woodfin, ERCOT's senior director of system operations, said about 45,000 megawatts of energy generation are offline as of the afternoon of Feb. 16—about one-third of which is from wind turbines while two-thirds of the energy shortage is thermal generation such as gas, coal and nuclear plants.

For context, Woodfin said consumers without power account for about 15,000 megawatts of energy that would otherwise be provided—accounting for 2 million to 3 million Texans without service.

Sargent said the blackouts in Austin will only end when the weather conditions improve and those power generators return, increasing supply so that local utilities such as Austin Energy can safely increase demand without risking the failure of the entire grid.

If the utility company were to turn back on some of its grids that are off—say, by instituting rolling blackouts—it would risk making an already dangerous situation for local residents even more widespread and dire.

"If the load becomes more than the generation, the system will collapse. We're trying to maintain this margin and not go into a total system blackout," Sargent said.
By Jack Flagler
Jack is the editor of Community Impact Newspaper's Central Austin and Southwest Austin editions. He began his career as a sports reporter in Massachusetts and North Carolina before moving to Austin in 2018. He grew up in Maine and graduated from Boston University, but prefers tacos al pastor to lobster rolls. You can get in touch at [email protected]


MOST RECENT

Candlewood Suites Northwest Austin
Williamson County declines lawsuit against Austin over Candlewood Suites saga—for now

Williamson County did not hold a vote to file a lawsuit against the city of Austin over the contentious Candlewood Suites property in Northwest Austin.

Photo of Chez Nous in black and white
Chez Nous, downtown Austin's longstanding French bistro, permanently closes

The restaurant opened in 1982 after its owners moved to Texas from Paris.

Photo of Moderna vaccine vials on a table
50% of Travis County residents fully vaccinated against COVID-19

Travis County has reached a milestone in COVID-19 vaccinations.

Pedestrian crossing signals
Burnet Road sidewalk improvements near Q2 Stadium expected to finish by July

City crews are working on several projects along Burnet Road that will make the corridor safer for pedestrians and cyclists.

The Electric Reliability Council of Texas issued a call for Texans to conserve energy June 14. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
ERCOT asks Texans to conserve energy with generation outages 2.5 times higher than normal

"This is unusual for this early in the summer season," said Woody Rickerson, ERCOT vice president of grid planning and operations, in a news release.

The rezoning request for the Springdale Green Planned Unit Development passed Austin City Council 10-0 June 10. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Rezoning for East Austin's Springdale Green PUD plan passes in unanimous City Council vote

The PUD plan garnered some community resistance this spring due to concerns over how a height increase for the project's proposed office towers could affect development and resident displacement in surrounding neighborhoods.

Austin moved into its second phase of Proposition B ordinance enforcement June 13 and began working to move some campers around City Hall on June 14. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Police Department clears tents around City Hall

The city began issuing written warnings June 13 in its second phase of enforcing criminal penalties for camping in public.

UT Austin football stadium filled with fans
In Austin and the rest of the nation, the business of college sports is changing

If Gov. Greg Abbott signs SB 1325 into law, Texas will join a number of other U.S. states in allowing college athletes to profit off their names, images and likenesses.

Lingering symptoms, long-term impact of COVID-19 will take time to fully understand

Dr. Mary Katherine Theoktisto answers questions regarding the virus.

Salvation Pizza, opening in the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport June 16, is one of several new pizza options in the Austin area. (Courtesy Salvation Pizza)
Pie chart: See a map of 11 new, coming-soon pizza options in the Austin area

New spots include Above Ground Pizza opening in New Bruanfels after several permitting delays and Salvation Pizza feeding travelers at the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport

Austin City Council members finalized their spending plan for the federal stimulus dollars before adjourning for their summer recess that will stretch to late July. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin will dedicate $100M in federal stimulus funds to combating homelessness over two years

In one of their last detailed discussions before their summer break, council members secured funding for several of their individual priorities alongside homelessness allocations.