Judge finds government liable for flooding property owners upstream of Addicks, Barker reservoirs after Hurricane Harvey

Addicks Reservoir is located north of I-10 in the Katy area. (Community Impact Staff)
Addicks Reservoir is located north of I-10 in the Katy area. (Community Impact staff)

Addicks Reservoir is located north of I-10 in the Katy area. (Community Impact staff)

A federal judge issued an opinion and order Dec. 17 related to the class action lawsuit in which property owners allege the Army Corps of Engineers unlawfully flooded thousands of properties upstream of the Addicks and Barker reservoirs after Hurricane Harvey.

Senior Judge Charles F. Lettow of the U.S. Court of Federal Claims denied the government’s February 2018 motion to dismiss the trial and concluded the Army Corps’ actions are liable, according to the opinion.

With the court, the parties involved must put a plan in place for addressing damages, according to the order and attorney Daniel Charest of Burns Charest LLP, one of the law firms representing the property owners.

Specifically, the lawsuit examined 13 test properties out of the thousands that flooded to determine whether the U.S. government was liable for taking private property without compensation to store impounded floodwaters from Hurricane Harvey, per the opinion.

All other upstream property cases were on hold while 13 test property cases were litigated at trial on the issue of the government’s liability, attorney Mary Conner of Irvine & Conner PLLC—the other law firm representing the property ownerssaid in May.


“The Army Corps allowed the west Houston homes to flood by not releasing water from the reservoirs downstream,” according to a press release from media relations firm Androvett Legal Media & Marketing Ltd. on behalf of Irvine & Conner and Burns Charest.

Neighborhoods upstream of the reservoirs include Cinco Ranch, Canyon Gate, Grand Lakes, Kelliwood, Lakes on Eldridge, Saddlebrook, Twin Lakes, and the subdivisions of Mayde and Bear creeks.

“[Not releasing the water] amounted to the ‘taking’ of their property under the Fifth Amendment ... [which] states that private property cannot be taken for public use without just compensation,” the release continued.

With Lettow’s order, property owners upstream of the reservoirs can seek certification as a class and may move the case to trial to determine damages to be paid by the government, per the release.

“Now that the court has determined that property owners should be compensated, the question now is for what and how much,” Charest said.

He said the parties will focus on determining the types of damages that can be compensated by the government. Charest was unable to provide a timeline and monetary figure for damages sought but said between 10,000-12,000 property owners are part of the lawsuit. There is a separate lawsuit related to properties flooded downstream of the reservoirs.

Community Impact Newspaper reached out to the defendant, the U.S. Department of Justice, which has not provided a comment as of 1 p.m. Dec. 18.

Lawsuit timeline

  • Sept. 15, 2017: Lawsuit filed

  • Spring 2018: Thirteen test cases selected for lawsuit

  • May 16, 2018: Court of Federal Claims has hearing on the defense’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit

  • May 6, 2019: 10-day trial held in Houston

  • Sept. 13, 2019: Court hears closing arguments in Washington, D.C.

  • Dec. 17, 2019, Court of Federal Claims issues opinion and order in favor of plaintiffs

By Jen Para
Jen joined Community Impact Newspaper in fall 2018 as the editor of the Katy edition. She covers education, transportation, local government, business and development in the Katy area.


MOST RECENT

About 550 students will show off their projects and animals throughout the first week of February. (Courtesy Cy-Fair ISD)
Here’s what to expect from Cy-Fair ISD’s 27th annual Livestock Show and Sale

About 550 students will show off their projects and animals throughout the first week of February.

Eleven days after officials across Harris County's criminal justice system met to discuss how to alleviate overcrowding at the county jail during the coronavirus pandemic, progress has been "excruciatingly slow," according to the Harris County Sheriff's Office. (Courtesy Brian Jackson/Adobe Stock)
Progress 'excruciatingly slow' on effort to address overcrowding at Harris County Jail

"I know it is keeping many of us awake at night, and it should. It absolutely should," said U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal, who is presiding over an ongoing lawsuit dealing with the county's felony bail practices.

Harris County continues to report more confirmed COVID-19 cases in the Cy-Fair area. (Community Impact staff)
2,610 new COVID-19 cases confirmed in Cy-Fair from Jan. 20-26

In the past seven days, 2,610 new cases have been confirmed locally, and eight Cy-Fair residents have died due to the virus.

Hungry Howie's Pizza's newest location is on West Road in the Cy-Fair area. (Courtesy Hungry Howie's Pizza)
Hungry Howie’s Pizza opens new location on West Road in Cy-Fair

Diners who register in advance can get a free junior pizza at today's pre-opening event.

Texas Medical Center offers coronavirus updates

More than 118,000 people have received their first shot.

Harris County Flood Control District is planning to submit preliminary flood plain maps to the Federal Emergency Management Agency in late 2021. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County's preliminary flood plain maps to be released in late 2021

The new flood insurance rates in Harris County could take effect in 2023 or 2024.

Cleaning products are stored in a Cy-Fair ISD campus custodian closet. (Courtesy Cy-Fair ISD)
378 new COVID-19 cases reported in Cy-Fair ISD schools Jan. 18-24

This is the highest number of cases confirmed in any given week since the start of the school year, up from 298 cases the previous week.

From left: Edward Leutsch, Nina Hermann and Rodney Alexander were among the first Houston Methodist Willowbrook Hospital patients to receive the COVID-19 vaccine. (Photos courtesy Houston Methodist Willowbrook Hospital)
Houston Methodist Willowbrook Hospital patients age 75 and older begin receiving vaccinations

Many of the patients eligible to get vaccinated in the past week said they have missed spending time with loved ones in person and were eager for this first dose.

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo announced the opening of a COVID-19 vaccine waitlist at a Jan. 25 press conference. (Screenshot courtesy Facebook)
Harris County to open waitlist for COVID-19 vaccines Jan. 26

Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo warned that vaccine supply remains "extremely limited," and it will still take time for those waitlisted to get an appointment.

Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 filed a counterclaim against Cypress Creek EMS on Jan. 22. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County ESD No. 11 issues counterclaim against Cypress Creek EMS for $20 million

According to the counterclaim, the district is suing Cypress Creek Emergency Medical Services for about $20 million in “missing and stolen taxpayer funds.”

Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 met Jan. 21 at its new administrative offices. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County Emergency Services District No. 11 lays groundwork for 911 dispatching plans

Cypress Creek EMS currently serves as a dispatch facility for 17 emergency agencies.