Judge dismisses claims against Texas Railroad Commission, Kinder Morgan in Permian Highway Pipeline lawsuit

Kinder Morgan's preliminary map of the planned pipeline route was released before negotiations with landowners were completed.

Kinder Morgan's preliminary map of the planned pipeline route was released before negotiations with landowners were completed.

After several weeks of deliberation, Judge Lora Livingston of the 261st District Court in Travis County released a ruling June 25 dismissing claims in a lawsuit brought against the Texas Railroad Commission, the state agency in charge of permitting oil and gas pipelines.

Plaintiffs in the Permian Highway Pipeline-related case—a group that includes several landowners, Hays County and the city of Kyle—asked for a moratorium on the use of eminent domain by private pipeline companies until a more rigorous public process with greater transparency could be put in place.

Though the suit did not directly challenge the right of those companies to use eminent domain—an authority of the state outlined in the constitution and delegated to those companies by the state Legislature—it did charge that there is so little oversight and regulation of the routing of those pipelines by the Texas Railroad Commission that it is a violation of the Texas Constitution.

Livingston stated that she was concerned with how little is required of private companies that exercise eminent domain, but she believes it is ultimately not the place of the court to make those changes.

“The court is concerned with a power that, when exercised by a governmental entity, must be done in the harsh light of public scrutiny of open meetings and public notice, but, when exercised by a private entity, may be determined without public notice by a select few driven primarily by their financial interests,” Livingston wrote. “However, the court must also be conscious of its role to apply the law and not to dictate the policy of the state.”

The Permian Highway Pipeline is a 430-mile conduit for natural gas that, as planned, will run from the Permian Basin to the Gulf Coast, bisecting Hays County, among others, on its way. Since plans for the pipeline were made public, local opposition has become widespread, leading numerous jurisdictions—including Hays County, San Marcos, Kyle, Buda, Woodcreek, Wimberley, the Barton Springs-Edwards Aquifer Conservation District, and Hays CISD—to pass resolutions opposing the pipeline and asking the Legislature to take action against it and similar projects.

Kinder Morgan, which was named as a codefendent in the suit, issued a release attributed to Tom Martin, president of natural gas pipelines for the company applauding the ruling.

“The court’s finding validates the process established in Texas for the development of natural gas utility projects, as well as the steps we have taken to comply with that process,” Martin said in the statement.

The lawsuit was funded by members of the Texas Real Estate Advocacy and Defense, or TREAD Coalition—a bipartisan nonprofit concerned with property rights, among other issues—which issued a statement June 25 expressing disappointment in the ruling and stating that the organization may consider an appeal.

“We continue to believe the Texas constitution does not allow for the delegation of this awesome power to a private company without oversight,” the statement reads. “This issue should be heard by an appellate court. We are weighing our options for an appeal and planning additional legal actions in other venues to challenge this severely problematic route.”
By Katharine Jose
Katharine Jose has written about politics, infrastructure, environment, development, natural disasters and other subjects for The New York Observer, Capital New York, and The New York Times, among other publications. She was an editor for several publicat


MOST RECENT

Protesters march from the state Capitol in downtown Austin on May 31. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Mayor of San Marcos, school districts respond to death of George Floyd

As protests spark around the world to demand justice for the death of George Floyd and countless others who have died in police custody, San Marcos Mayor Jane Hughson, San Marcos CISD Superintendent Michael Cardona and Hays CISD Superintendent Eric Wright issued statements earlier this week addressing their stances on the matter.

SNAP, a federal program overseen in Texas by the HHSC, assists around 1.4 million eligible low-income individuals and families statewide. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Emergency SNAP food benefits extended in Texas during COVID-19 pandemic

SNAP assists around 1.4 million eligible low-income individuals and families in Texas.

The new storage location will be at 250 Riverwalk Drive, San Marcos. (Courtesy Guard Dog Storage)
Guard Dog Storage coming soon to San Marcos

The storage facility features drive-up storage access, standard and air-conditioned storage.

Mano Amiga will host a call for action at the Hays County Historic Courthouse at 3 p.m. June 6. (Christopher Neely)
Hays County activists seek reinvestment of policing funds, call a rally for action

Mano Amiga, a local grassroots organization in Hays County pushing for criminal justice reform, seeks to open a dialogue about how to better invest tax dollars allocated to law enforcement.

CMS also unveiled an interactive map that lets users search any nursing home in the U.S. to see its COVID-19 cases. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
CMS reports 321 coronavirus deaths in Texas nursing homes, nearly 32,000 nationwide

CMS also unveiled an interactive map that lets users search any nursing home in the U.S. to its COVID-19 cases.

Hays County cases are up four from June 3. (Community Impact staff)
Hays County has 4 new coronavirus cases on 13 tests reported June 4

Kyle has had more than 200 cases; San Marcos nearing 100 positive tests

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced Phase 3 of his Open Texas plan June 3. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Gov. Greg Abbott's June 3 guidelines allow most Texas businesses to operate at 50% capacity

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott continues to lift coronavirus-related business restrictions.

The shop specializing in daiquiris is located at 1617 Aquarena Springs, San Marcos. (Courtesy Longhorn Daiquiris)
Longhorn Daiquiris now open on Aquarena Springs in San Marcos

Longhorn Daiquiris, a Kyle-born daiquiri and wing shop, opened on May 31 at 1617 Aquarena Springs, San Marcos.

Buda businesses who did not receive funds from the Still Budaful fund may apply for Still Budaful 2.0. (John Cox/Community Impact Newspaper)
Still Budaful 2.0 kicks off with $250K for Buda businesses

Program applications are open for Buda businesses until June 10.

Volunteers get ready to load cars with food May 30. (Courtesy city of Kyle)
Central Texas Food Bank event serves nearly 1,500 families from Kyle area

The next area food distribution by the Central Texas Food Bank will be June 18.

Legendary baseball player Nolan Ryan has long enjoyed ranching. Now, he and his team are preparing to open a butcher shop in Round Rock to showcase Goodstock, Nolan Ryan Beef and other Texas-made products. (Photo courtesy Nolan Ryan)
Nolan Ryan to open Round Rock butcher shop and 20 other Central Texas business updates to know

Read the latest news on Central Texas businesses from Community Impact Newspaper's latest coverage.

Census reinstates some field operations in Texas following coronavirus delay. (Courtesy U.S. Census Bureau)
Census reinstates some field operations in Texas following coronavirus delay

Operations began in Fort Worth, Dallas, Austin and San Antonio beginning May 25.