Historic housing shortage spurs buying frenzy in Plano

Image description
Image description
Image description
Prospective homebuyers in Plano are facing a historically tight market characterized by a dearth of inventory and skyrocketing sales prices.

“We are seeing inventory levels at a 50-year low,” said Marvin Jolly, a Plano-based Realtor and chairman of real estate advocacy group Texas Realtors. “It’s not just perception—it’s reality.”

As of May, there was 0.8 months worth of housing inventory in Plano, down from 2.4 months in May 2020, according to data provided by Collin County Association of Realtors. A stable market is one that has six months worth of homes available to buy, according to the Texas Real Estate Research Center.

A lack of supply and the rapid pace of sales are behind the surge in home costs in Plano and beyond, said Chris Kelly, president and CEO of Ebby Halliday, which recently relocated its headquarters to the city. May data lists the median sales price in Plano as $430,400, an increase of about 25% year-over-year.

“The million-dollar price point has been on fire—anything above that has been selling at an accelerated pace—but when it comes to someone looking to buy in the [$200,000 and $300,000 price range], that is a very difficult property to find right now,” Kelly said.

Despite these challenges, real estate experts hold out hope that inventory levels will go up as seller confidence is restored and issues around the building supply chain are resolved.

“We do expect the market to slow down,” said Jim Gaines, an economist with the Texas Real Estate Research Center. “The dominoes have to fall in the right order and at the right time.”

Effect on first-time homebuyers

High levels of demand mean most homes are selling for above asking price. But the bank will only approve a loan for what a home is worth, said Lisa-Marie Thompson, a loan officer with Primary Residential Mortgage Inc., which has offices across the metroplex, including one in Plano.

Many first-time homebuyers do not have the cash on hand to make up the difference, Thompson said. May data from the Collin County Association of Realtors shows the median home in Plano sold for 104.4% over asking price, which is up from the 98.2% recorded a year prior.

“This isn’t a market that is feasible for them,” she said. “It’s almost impossible.”

As a result, millennials and other first-time homebuyers are leaving Plano and moving to less populated counties—such as Grayson, Kaufman, Hill, Parker and Ellis counties—that have a greater supply of homes at lower price points, Kelly said.

“We are seeing sales growth in those counties, sometimes 30% to 40% year-over-year,” he said. “Part of the reason is when you get out to those areas, the affordability starts to come down.”

Mary Reeves, a Plano-based Realtor with Ebby Halliday, said most of her current clients are empty-nesters who have the cash on hand to go above asking price. But even those buyers are having to be flexible about what they are willing to accept in a home, Reeves said.

“They are having to say certain things are OK that they probably wouldn’t have a few years ago,” she said. “Most of that has been in updates—they think, ‘OK, I can just update it later.’”

After touring around 70 homes and putting in above-asking offers on three properties, Erin Frey and her husband purchased a house near Coit Road and Park Boulevard in Plano. She said they had a wishlist for what they wanted in a home but were forced to make a slew of concessions due to the lack of available options in their price range of around $400,000.

“It’s not the ideal neighborhood that we would have liked to move into, but it’s the one that we’re in,” Frey said.

Buyers looking to purchase a home right now should set realistic expectations about what they can find under current market conditions, she said.

“Make your hierarchy of needs but be ready to settle and move fast,” she said.

Resolving issues of supply

Skyrocketing prices are not the only thing preventing first-time homebuyers from entering the market. Baby boomers and other older residents are aging in place, which is curtailing resale inventory, Kelly said.

“What we have found is that people are living longer, they’re healthier, and they’re staying in their homes longer,” Kelly said. “So there wasn’t this natural migration out of homes ... that would have created a supply as millennials grew into the homebuying age.”’

The prevalence of investors buying single-family homes as rental properties is also responsible for low levels of supply, Jolly said, noting he estimates 30% of buyers in the metroplex are investors.

“A lot of them have a very, very high level of cash,” he said. “So, they’re putting either 50% down or in some cases 100% cash down.”

Jolly said his association is working with the National Association of Realtors and state legislators to enact policies that would alleviate housing affordability and supply issues. One strategy is to ease VA and FHA loan restrictions around paying above-asking prices, he said.

Land, supply chain complications

Despite a lack of available space, interest from builders in Plano persists, particularly with an eye on multifamily developments. The city is just over 95% built-out, according to Plano officials.

“Long term, eventually, the answer is more units. ... That’s going to require some new thinking, some new perspective on redevelopment of aging areas in Plano,” Jolly said.

Driven by demand, developers are increasingly looking at less conventional routes to new homes. That may include converting commercial zoning to residential, Jolly said.

“There is a lot of office space that is vacant, and it may stay vacant for a long time as the workforce moves virtually,” he said.

Of course, even when there is available land, disruptions to the supply chain have further complicated the job for homebuilders.

According to the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB), aggregate construction material costs are up 12% year-over-year and lumber costs have increased by as much as 300% since last April.

And while contractors have had to deal with shortages and price spikes in the past, it is often just with one item at a given time. There are documented issues with lumber, metals and semiconductor chips, among other materials.

Taken together, land and supply chain challenges are helping to drive prices up. NAHB data suggests recent material cost increases have raised the price of a new single-family home by $36,000 over the past 12 months.

What the future holds

Experts do not predict a crash similar to what was experienced following the 2008 housing crisis. National statistics from the Mortgage Bankers Association indicate lenders are being more restrictive, according to Gaines.

“[Mortgage] lending has not been excessive,” he said. “[Lenders are] requiring a higher FICO score, a lower debt-to-income ratio, and, in many cases, a higher down payment.”

Interest rates have increased slightly since plummeting to historic lows at the beginning of the pandemic, Thompson said. But they continue to remain optimal for potential homebuyers looking to secure a low monthly payment.

“Anything below 4% is still a beautiful interest rate on a mortgage,” she said.

Relatively low interest rates will keep buyer demand high, Kelly said. This, coupled with the fact that North Texas is a highly desirable place to live, means the Plano market could continue to fire on all cylinders for the foreseeable future, he said.

Steven Ryzewski contributed to this report.
By Olivia Lueckemeyer
Olivia Lueckemeyer graduated in 2013 from Loyola University New Orleans with a degree in journalism. She joined Community Impact Newspaper in October 2016 as reporter for the Southwest Austin edition before her promotion to editor in March 2017. In July 2018 she returned home to the Dallas area and became editor of the Richardson edition.


Stumpy's Hatchet House offers ax throwing for groups of any size. (Courtesy Stumpy's Hatchet House)
Ax-throwing venue comes to Frisco; Plano ISD to offer back-to-school fair and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area, including an Aug. 3 event Plano ISD is hosting to give away backpacks.

School supplies.
Plano ISD to offer back-to-school fair for district families in need

Families will receive a box of shelf-stable food and a backpack filled with school supplies for each student present and/or shown with proof of enrollment.

student writing on paper
Texas Legislature allows parents to opt for students to repeat grade levels or courses

Senate Bill 1697 is effective for the 2021-22 school year.

Candida auris causes invasive infections and can be transmitted in health care settings, a news release from Collin County Health Care Services said. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Collin County health officials say yeast infection that killed 4 not public threat 

The county gave no indication that generally healthy individuals should fear infection.

Oni Ramen plans to open a location in Richardson's CityLine development later this year. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Oni Ramen coming to Richardson; American-Italian restaurant Sfereco set to open in Lewisville and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area, including a new bakery coming to McKinney.

Plano ISD trustees to consider new district health, safety protocols at Aug. 3 meeting

The draft protocols note face masks are optional for all students, staff and visitors, but states “universal indoor masking is recommended" for everyone, regardless of vaccination status.

Dick's Sporting Goods Warehouse Sale now offering outlet-priced items in Plano

The company's outlet stores offer an assortment of goods, including apparel and footwear, at discounted prices.

On July 29, the city announced that it acquired 230 acres of parkland within the Painted Tree residential development. (Courtesy city of McKinney)
McKinney pays $23M for 230 acres of parkland in Painted Tree development

Athletic fields, recreational facilities and future community and economic development projects will be built upon the new land.

Mad for Chicken opened July 23 at 216 W. Virginia St., Ste. 102, in downtown McKinney. (Courtesy Mad for Chicken)
Mad for Chicken opens; work on container homes community begins and more top news from DFW

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

School supplies will be exempt from the 8.25% sales tax Aug. 6-8. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
What to know before the statewide tax-free weekend Aug. 6-8

Customers will not have to pay the standard 8.25% sales tax on select clothing, footwear, school supplies and backpacks under $100.

Boxochops to bring Nigerian small chops to Plano in August

Boxochops will offer a variety of authentic Nigerian small chops, which come in various forms and include puff puff, a traditional sweet or savory fried dough; snack-size pastries; and savory meats seasoned with peppers and fiery spices, per its website.