Plano petition seeking eminent domain special election falls short of requirements

School building.
An easement on the property of the Montessori Children’s House school is the subject of a legal dispute between the owner of the school and the city of Plano. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)

An easement on the property of the Montessori Children’s House school is the subject of a legal dispute between the owner of the school and the city of Plano. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)

Image description
Plano City Council held a special called meeting April 20 to discuss the proposed ordinance. (Screenshot courtesy city of Plano)
Plano staff said a petition to call a public vote on a proposed ordinance regarding eminent domain was not compliant with state and city requirements.

The proposed ordinance to limit the city’s eminent domain authority was submitted April 9 by supporters of the Montessori Children’s House school at 1900 Hedgcoxe Road. Plano is looking to take an easement on the school’s property to put in a hike and bike trail that would connect the Russell Creek Park and Hoblitzelle Park trails.

Montessori Children’s House owner Effie Saifi said the loss of the easement would hinder her planned expansion and adversely affect her current operations. Saifi and the city have been in a legal fight over the land for the last four years.

“The city [is] wasting taxpayer dollars on this case against my school,” Saifi said.

During a special called meeting of Plano City Council on April 20, City Secretary Lisa Henderson said only 4,237 of the nearly 7,500 signatures included on the petition could be verified for the minimum requirements under state election code and the Plano city charter.


“Section 702 of the charter requires signatures equal to 20% of the number of votes cast in the last regular election, or 4,403 for this petition,” Henderson said.

City staff spent around 300 hours doing multiple reviews of the document, City Manager Mark Israelson said. Aside from the lack of enough qualifying signatures, City Attorney Paige Mims said the proposed ordinance was in conflict with state law and would not be enforceable.

“At the end of the day, this ordinance would have no legal meaning, in our opinion,” Mims said. “It's just in conflict with a lot of things and also would create some exposure to the city for paying attorney's fees. For those reasons, we don't think that the council should take this up.”

In his closing remarks for the meeting, Mayor Harry LaRosiliere said the proposed trail connection has been part of the city’s Parks Master Plan since the 1980s and that plan was previously acknowledged by Saifi and her family.

“For years, we have negotiated in good faith to come to a reasonable conclusion to this,” LaRosiliere said. “In the meantime, I've seen a campaign of falsehoods [against the city]. ... That is completely contrary to how we operate as a city. This is not who we are and is inconsistent with the way we conduct our business. It's a shame ,and unfortunate, we've come to this point.”

Mims said Saifi has appealed a previous court ruling concerning the easement, and a trial on the matter is scheduled for this summer in county court.

“We have just kind of decided to let her have her day in court this summer,” Mims said.
By William C. Wadsack
William C. Wadsack is the senior reporter for the Plano and Richardson editions of Community Impact Newspaper. He previously served as managing editor of several daily and weekly publications in North Texas and his native state of Louisiana before joining Community Impact Newspaper in 2019.


MOST RECENT




Baylor Scott & White Medical Center-Centennial is expanding its cardiovascular services. (Courtesy Baylor Scott & White Health)
Plano heart hospital bringing cardiovascular services to Frisco

Baylor Scott & White The Heart Hospital-Plano—ranked among the top 1% of heart hospitals in the country—is bringing its services to the Frisco hospital and providing relationships and oversight of the program

Food.
Big Tony’s West Philly Cheesesteaks puts customers first in Plano

Anthony “Big Tony” Blaylock grew up in west Philadelphia and moved to Texas in 1995 to start his own cheesesteak business.

Five men in an office cutting a ribbon
Toyota Insurance Management Solutions opens headquarters in Plano

Toyota Insurance Management Solutions opened its first office space and national headquarters in Plano.

McKinney Mayor George Fuller has been re-elected for another term. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
Local election results, a trash pickup rate increase in McKinney and more top news from the Dallas-Forth Worth area

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

sandwich
Fat Shack coming soon to Plano

Fat Shack is known for its signature Fat Sandwiches and late-night hours.

Walk-On's is opening in McKinney in 2022. (Courtesy Walk-Ons Sports Bistreaux & Bar)
Co-owner Dak Prescott to launch eatery in McKinney; Goody Goody Liquor coming to Keller and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Crumbl Cookies offers over 120 rotating cookie flavors. (Courtesy Crumbl Cookies)
Crumbl Cookies to open in Plano; McKinney trash pickup rates to rise and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news form the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Salad and Go food.
Drive-thru eatery Salad and Go now open in Plano

The drive-thru concept eatery offers made-to-order salads, wraps, soups and drinks.

Student walking into school.
Plano ISD to receive $43M in federal COVID-19 relief funding

“These additional funds will be a tremendous help in facilitating a comprehensive, long-term approach to support students and staff affected by the pandemic,” Plano ISD Chief Operating Officer Theresa Williams said.

Frankford Middle School.
Plano ISD to partner with Dallas for park at Frankford Middle School

Plano ISD will not contribute any funds toward the park, but will be able to reserve it for the district's exclusive use.

Cookies.
Crumbl Cookies to open first Plano location

Crumbl Cookies offers a weekly rotating menu of fresh-baked cookies, such as Strawberry Poptart, Cosmic Brownie, Cinnamon Swirl and Muddy Buddy.