Plano Tomorrow lawsuit continues as Supreme Court of Texas leaves appeals ruling intact

The city of Plano plans to continue fighting a lawsuit to dismantle the Plano Tomorrow comprehensive development plan after suffering a setback this week with the state’s highest civil court.

The Supreme Court of Texas on Friday denied two petitions—one from Plano and another from the group suing the city—to review a February decision from the state’s Fifth District Court of Appeals. The decision effectively leaves intact, for now, a lower court’s ruling that the courts can decide whether the city secretary is obligated to submit a petition for a referendum on the city’s comprehensive plan to Plano City Council.

City Attorney Paige Mims on Saturday said the city planned to continue contesting the claims, arguing the city’s comprehensive development plan is inextricably linked with the city’s zoning ordinances, and that the local legislative process that produced the plan cannot be replicated at the ballot box.

But Jack Ternan, an attorney for the group suing the city, said he hoped the city would reverse its stance rather than letting the case play out in the trial courts.

“From my perspective, they should recognize the city secretary should do their job” and submit the petition to the council, Ternan said. He added that his clients had already filed the case in the 380th District Court of Collin County, and would continue to argue their case after the appeals process is completed.

The city, which had argued the trial courts did not have jurisdiction to decide the matter, was dealt a blow in February when the appeals court ruled the trial courts could decide whether the city secretary should be compelled to submit the referendum petition to the City Council.

In the same February ruling, the appeals court had dismissed some of the group’s claims against the city for lack of jurisdiction. One of these dismissed claims asked the courts to require officials to suspend the Plano Tomorrow plan, readopt the city’s 1986 strategic plan and call a special election. After the Supreme Court’s petition denials on Friday, these additional requests remain off the table.

The city had already requested the appeals court reconsider its ruling, and Mims said it could also ask the same of the Supreme Court of Texas. After that, however, the main question—whether the city should be compelled to submit the petition to the City Council—could be placed in the hands of the trial court.
By Daniel Houston
Daniel Houston covers Plano city government, transportation, business and education for Community Impact Newspaper. A Fort Worth native and Baylor University graduate, Daniel reported previously for The Associated Press in Oklahoma City and The Dallas Morning News.


MOST RECENT

Here is the latest data from Collin County and Denton County's public health departments. (Chase Autin/Community Impact Newspaper)
Data: Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Plano ZIP codes

As of May 29, there have been 397 confirmed cases of coronavirus across the six Plano ZIP codes in both Collin and Denton counties, according to health officials.

(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Collin County to transition coronavirus case management to state health department

The Texas Department of State Health Services will perform all COVID-19 case investigations and contact tracing for Collin County following a vote by Collin County Commissioners Court on May 29.

The city of Plano has promoted a 31-year veteran to serve as its assistant police chief. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Plano promotes Sandra Rodgers-Tomeo to assistant police chief role

Plano has promoted a 31-year veteran of its police force to serve as assistant police chief.

Collin College is providing this assistance in partnership with the U.S. Department of Education and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act. (Chase Autin/Community Impact Newspaper)
Collin College offering grants, tuition credit for students affected by coronavirus pandemic

Collin College is offering student grants and tuition credit to students who have been affected by the coronavirus pandemic and the college's shift to online courses.

A LongHorn Steakhouse was expected to open in early 2020 at The Citadel development near I-35W and Heritage Trace Parkway. The opening has been delayed, according to staff. (Ian Pribanic/Community Impact Newspaper)
Tuesday Morning bankruptcy, census data and three other DFW-area stories

Here are five recent updates from the metroplex, on delayed openings, mass layoffs and more.

Those who give blood through May 31 will receive a t-shirt by mail while supplies last. For the month of June, donators will receive a $5 Amazon gift card through email, courtesy Amazon, according to American Red Cross. (Courtesy American Red Cross)
Red Cross offers incentives for blood donations in Dallas-Fort Worth area

The American Red Cross has roughly 1,300 blood donation appointments in North Texas that need to be filled through June 15.

The White Rock Family YMCA in Dallas is among the seven area locations that are set to reopen at partial capacity June 1. (Courtesy YMCA of Metropolitan Dallas)
MAY 31 ROUNDUP: Business news from Dallas-Fort Worth area

Read the latest business news from Dallas-Fort Worth.

The White Rock Family YMCA in Dallas is among the seven area locations that are set to reopen at partial capacity on June 1. (Courtesy YMCA of Metropolitan Dallas)
Plano Family YMCA to reopen at partial capacity, along with 6 other North Texas locations

The YMCA of Metropolitan Dallas on May 28 announced the phased reopening plans as it laid out a number of precautions that the organization will take to protect against the spread of the coronavirus.

Here are the latest coronavirus updates for Collin County readers. (Community Impact staff)
19 additional cases of coronavirus reported by Collin County

Health officials reported 19 new cases of coronavirus in Collin County on May 28.

Sam Johnson, former prisoner of war and Collin County-area congressman, dies at 89

Sam Johnson, a former prisoner of war who represented Collin County communities for nearly three decades in Congress, died May 27 in Plano.

Normally crowded toll roads are experiencing a decline in the number of motorists, according to data from the North Texas Tollway Authority. (Liesbeth Powers/Community Impact Newspaper)
North Texas Tollway Authority develops plan to mitigate unprecedented loss of revenue

Money-saving tactics include an indefinite hiring freeze and the delay of some projects, according to a spokesperson.

The application will close June 4 at 11:59 p.m., and recipients will be chosen using a lottery system. (Chase Autin/Community Impact Newspaper)
City of Plano relief grant for small businesses now accepting applications

Applications for the city of Plano’s Small Business Grant Program opened May 28.