Plano seeks new water deal as costs surpass public safety

The city of Plano is paying more than ever for its water, despite residents using less than they did in 2001.

The city of Plano is paying more than ever for its water, despite residents using less than they did in 2001.

The city of Plano is working with 12 nearby cities to amend a contract that requires Plano residents to pay tens of millions of dollars for water they do not use.

Plano City Attorney Paige Mims said in a Sept. 5 statement that Plano is participating in settlement discussions regarding its contract with the North Texas Municipal Water District, as are many other cities served by the district.

Mims said she could not discuss details of the discussions because of a confidentiality agreement between parties.

The city mounted a challenge to the structure of the contract in late 2016 as Plano water and sewer costs were set to soon become the city’s greatest expenses, surpassing even public safety. The state’s Public Utility Commission has been reviewing the city’s request.

The possibility of a settlement takes on new significance given the continued growth of water and sewer costs as the city’s largest spending category. For most cities, public safety is the largest spending category because of the personnel and equipment required.

In Plano, however, water and sewer expenditures have risen by 27% in the last five years, outpacing growth in public safety spending by $5.5 million.

The water district supports the settlement efforts, provided the district can still cover the costs of maintaining the water system and expanding it to meet growing regional demands for water, a spokesperson said.

“Those costs must be funded regardless of the amount of water consumed each year, which fluctuates based on weather patterns and other factors such as growth,” NTMWD spokesperson Janet Rummel said.

The city of Plano has asked the Public Utility Commission of Texas to delay its consideration of the case until Dec. 13 as the parties work toward a settlement.

In the meantime, Plano residents continue to pay more for water even as they use less.

Less water, higher bills

During times of drought, the city has occasionally set guidelines on how often, and on what days of the week, homeowners may water their lawns. Generally, these efforts have been successful, Plano Budget Director Karen Rhodes-Whitley said.

During the last two decades, Plano’s population increased by more than 20% while total water usage declined by roughly 30%, according to city records. However, water and sewer costs continued to rise because of the water district’s “take or pay” contract.

Under the agreement, which has been in place since 1988, cities pay for the amount of water used in their single year of highest usage, not how much their residents and businesses actually use in each year. For Plano, its year of highest usage was 2001.

The district raises water and sewer rates primarily to pay for capital investments.

“The most significant project driving water cost increases in recent years [was] construction of the $1.6 billion Bois d’Arc Lake project,” Rummel said. “The lake, pipeline, pump stations and new treatment plant in Fannin County will provide future water for our fast-growing North Texas region.”

But because the cost of water Plano pays for stays the same regardless of how much it uses, the city ends up passing the water district’s rate increases on to consumers, Rhodes-Whitley said.

While some other cities use general revenue funds, which come from property and sales taxes, to subsidize the water portion of their budgets, Plano does not. The only part of the water and sewer expenses that Plano officials typically have control over is tied to personnel and city infrastructure investments.

But those personnel and infrastructure costs make up only 33% of total water and sewer expenditures each year, Rhodes-Whitley said, and they have remained fairly constant. The rest goes toward payment to the water district.

“We don’t have any staffing increases over there [or] infrastructure increases,” Rhodes-Whitley said of the city’s water and sewer operations. “We’re ‘pay as you go’ on water and sewer [investments].”

Growing demand

Plano’s negotiations with the water district and member cities come at a time when water rates are expected to continue to climb, although not by as much as in recent years.

Cities in the coming year will pay 2.4% more per 1,000 gallons of water than they did the year before. This is the lowest rate increase the water district has asked for since 2006, Rummel said.

That said, a quickly growing Collin County population is expected to require more water sources and infrastructure. The district’s openness to a change in the cost-sharing structure does not necessarily mean it can afford to take in fewer dollars overall, Rummel said.

“The district is open to a contract change as long as adequate funding is available to cover the costs to maintain, operate and expand the regional system the cities share and to cover any debt costs,” Rummel said.

But until such an agreement is reached, the city of Plano plans to continue to promote water conservation policies, Rhodes-Whitley said.

One of these measures, which charges residents a significantly higher rate for water if they use more than 20,000 gallons a year, helps dampen the impact of rate increases on residents who use less water, she said.

“The city of Plano believes that the lower tier should be as low [as it is] because you’ve got the senior citizens on those, the people who are living by themselves,” Rhodes-Whitley said. “We really built into the rate structure where, if you are using a bunch of water, you really are subsidizing that lower tier.”
By Daniel Houston

Daniel Houston covers Plano city government, transportation, business and education for Community Impact Newspaper. A Fort Worth native and Baylor University graduate, Daniel reported previously for The Associated Press in Oklahoma City and The Dallas Morning News.


Collin, Denton, Dallas and Tarrant counties have a higher response rate than the state of Texas as of Mach 31. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Census responses ahead of U.S. in Dallas-Fort Worth, growth highest in nation

Dallas-Fort Worth counties vary in self-response rates on the U.S. census as Census Day arrives April 1.

Gov. Greg Abbott issued an executive order regarding the state's response to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic during a March 31 afternoon press conference. (Screenshot via livestream)
Plano nixes stay-at-home policy discussion in light of Texas governor's guidelines on essential activities

A dash to prepare a stay-at-home ordinance for the city of Plano was halted this week after the governor unveiled his own set of guidelines defining essential services.

Texas Tribune: Some local elections in Texas moving ahead despite coronavirus spread

A handful of towns and special districts still plan to go ahead with their May 2 votes, arranging polling places despite calls from the president on down directing people to stay at home to prevent the spread of the deadly virus.

Lake Travis Fire Rescue is one of hundreds of emergency service districts serving millions of Texas residents across the state. Firefighters, EMTs and medical professionals said they are concerned about the availability of personal protective equipment as the coronavirus public health crisis continues. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
First responders, medical professionals across Texas worry about inadequate personal protective equipment supplies

In a survey of emergency service districts across the state, two-thirds of respondents said they were concerned about a shortage of equipment such as masks, goggles and gloves.

Owner of Asian Mint Nikky Phinyawatana saw an opportunity to support at-home cooking endeavors by launching the Chef Mint from Home program. (Courtesy Asian Mint)
ROUNDUP: DFW businesses provide adjusted services to community, support each other during coronavirus

Read more about some of the businesses the Community Impact Newspaper team has featured.

Collin County Judge Chris Hill rescinded his order that urged residents to stay home except for travel related to essential activities and defined all business as essential. (Courtesy Collin County)
Collin County judge rescinds order defining all business as essential after governor issues statewide guidelines

Collin County’s top elected official has withdrawn his stay-at-home order that defined all business as essential.

The city of Plano has placed signs at its various parks communicating social distancing guidelines. (Courtesy city of Plano)
In effort to keep Plano parks open, city to monitor visitors ignoring social distancing rules

The city of Plano is stepping up enforcement of social distancing requirements at public parks amid reports that people are not observing the recommended guidelines.

J.C. Penney announced March 31 that many of its employees would be furloughed in a series of cost-saving efforts. (Daniel Houston/Community Impact Newspaper)
Plano-based JCPenney furloughs more than half of hourly workforce, some corporate office employees

Plano-based JCPenney Co. announced plans to furlough more than half of its hourly workforce in a series of cost-saving moves driven by loss of revenue related to the new coronavirus.

Unsheltered individuals in Plano are encouraged to take advantage of the temporary shelter at the the Kay Bailey Hutchison Convention Center during the new coronavirus threat. (Adobe Stock)
Options remain limited for homeless seeking shelter in Plano, Collin County during coronavirus pandemic

Unsheltered individuals in Plano are encouraged to take advantage of the temporary shelter available at the the Kay Bailey Hutchison Convention Center in Downtown Dallas during the coronavirus pandemic.

Pharmacists at ReNue Pharmacy produced 40 gallons of hand sanitizer for first responders in Frisco and Plano. (Courtesy ReNue Pharmacy)
ReNue Pharmacy donates 40 gallons of hand sanitizer to first responders in Frisco and Plano

The production of hand sanitizer is “very labor intensive,” but the business felt the donation would benefit the community, managing parter Raj Chhadua said.

Census day is April 1. (Courtesy U.S. Census Bureau)
Dallas-Fort Worth area sees highest population increase in last decade of any metropolitan area

The North Texas area’s population rose by more than 1.2 million between 2010 and 2019.

The North Texas Collin County Taiwanese Chamber of Commerce donated 4,000 surgical masks and 101 N95 masks to Plano Fire-Rescue on March 31. Pictured here are Plano City Manager Mark Israelson, Plano Fire-Rescue Assistant Chief Jeff Moberley, Plano Fire Chief Sam Greif, City Council Member Maria Tu and NTCCTCC members Charlie Chen, Fred Hwong, Andy Liu and Jimmy Lee. (Courtesy Plano Fire-Rescue)
Community steps up to provide medical gear, sanitation supplies for Plano's first responders

Plano Fire Capt. Peggy Harrell said the department has received donations ranging from frozen meat to medical supplies.