More Plano ISD parents opting out of Texas vaccine guidelines each year

Conscientious vaccination exemptions have been on the rise in Texas. These exemptions allow students to opt out of required school vaccinations without a medical release. In the chart below, the conscientious exemption rates for Plano ISD are compared to statewide rates.

Conscientious vaccination exemptions have been on the rise in Texas. These exemptions allow students to opt out of required school vaccinations without a medical release. In the chart below, the conscientious exemption rates for Plano ISD are compared to statewide rates.

The number of students opting out of the state’s mandatory vaccination requirements has been on the rise in recent years in Plano ISD and other school districts across the state.

During the 2018-19 school year, nearly 2.2% of PISD students received exemptions for reasons of conscience from the state’s vaccine requirements, according to the Texas Department of State Health Services.

These conscientious exemptions are granted when a parent objects to the requirement based on their personal beliefs, religious or otherwise. In this case, a parent or guardian has the legal right to exclude their children from otherwise required immunizations.

While the number of unvaccinated students is low compared to the number of vaccinated children, the risk for an outbreak of some vaccine-preventable diseases is higher when more than 5% of students are unvaccinated, according to the Texas Department of State Health Services.

“You want to build as much protection into the community as you possibly can to protect everybody,” said Chris Van Deusen, the director of media relations for the DSHS. “If it’s one [unvaccinated]  person and everybody else is immunized, it’s not going to be [a problem], but when you see immunization rates falling under 95%, you start to get concerned.”

Several Plano ISD schools have exemption rates that are double the districtwide rate, according to numbers provided by the district. Shepard Elementary School and Pearson Early Childhood School top the list with the number of exemptions granted at more than 5% of enrollment. Eight more elementary schools in the Plano district reported exemption rates higher than 4%.

“School immunization requirements are set by the Texas Department of State Health Services,” PISD Director of Health Services Staci Antelo said in response to a question about the Plano schools at or nearing the 5% threshold. “Exclusions from compliance are allowable on an individual basis for medical contraindications, reasons of conscience, including a religious belief, and active duty with the armed forces of the United States.”

As vaccination rates have declined in some communities, the U.S. has seen a spike this year in the number of cases of measles. The disease was considered eliminated in the U.S. in 2000, but 1,022 cases were reported nationwide from Jan. 1 through June 6—more than the previous four years combined, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Plano ISD reported a single case of the measles in August at Plano West Senior High School. The district advised parents at the time that there was a three-day window in which their children could have been exposed to the disease. No additional measles cases were reported.

Plano West had a 1.8% exemption rate this year, the highest of the district’s senior high schools, but still below the 5% threshold.

“Getting immunized is really the best way … the easiest, the least expensive, [and]  it’s the most straightforward way to protect yourself, protect your family and really anybody else around you,” Van Deusen said.

Requirements and exemptions

In accordance with Texas law, public and private schools require students to receive six mandatory vaccines before they can enroll in kindergarten.

Requirements are set by the state health department and the Texas Education Agency.

A seventh vaccine that prevents meningitis is also required for students to enroll in seventh grade.

A medical exemption is granted when a child is unable to receive a certain vaccine due to a health condition. This exemption requires a letter from a doctor.

Conscientious exemptions, on the other hand, require a notarized letter from a child’s guardian and require renewal every two years. The state began allowing exemptions for reasons of conscience in 2003.

Risk of outbreaks

Following the recommended vaccination schedule is important to prevent an outbreak of diseases, said Dr. Jawaid Asghar, the chief epidemiologist with Collin County Health Care Services.

According to the DSHS, the measles cases in Texas so far this year have not resulted in any outbreaks, as of this paper’s print deadline of June 14.

In the event of an outbreak in Plano ISD, the district has a policy that prohibits unvaccinated students from attending class.

“Plano ISD works very closely with the Health Department to manage communicable disease occurrences,” Antelo said. “In a case such as measles, the Health Department takes the lead investigating the illness and enforcing exclusion requirements.”

Part of the reason public health officials aim for high vaccination rates is because of a concept called herd immunity.

Herd immunity exists when enough people in a community are immunized that even a highly infectious disease has trouble spreading, said Zachary Simoni, an expert in medical sociology at The University of Texas at Dallas.

This reduces the chances of a disease spreading, especially to those who cannot be immunized or those who choose not to be immunized.

“Vaccines aren’t meant to be perfect for every single person; they rely on herd immunity,” he said.

Richardson Editor Olivia Lueckemeyer and McKinney Editor Cassidy Ritter contributed to this report.

Conscientious exemption rate by Plano ISD campus

Campus Conscientious exemption rate
Pearson Early Childhood School 5.2%
Shepard Elementary 5.0%
Carlisle Elementary 4.8%
Beverly Elementary 4.8%
Hedgcoxe Elementary 4.8%
Haggar Elementary 4.5%
Harrington Elementary 4.4%
Aldridge Elementary 4.3%
Davis Elementary 4.2%
Sigler Elementary 4.2%
Boggess Elementary 3.9%
Skaggs Elementary 3.8%
Haggard Middle 3.7%
Plano ISD Academy High School 3.7%
Hendrick Middle 3.6%
Miller Elementary 3.6%
Head Start 3.4%
Hughston Elementary 3.4%
Wells Elementary 3.2%
Barksdale Elementary 3.0%
McCall Elementary 2.9%
Beaty Early Childhood School 2.8%
Dooley Elementary 2.8%
Hightower Elementary 2.6%
Robinson Middle 2.6%
Schell Elementary 2.6%
Andrews Elementary 2.4%
Vines High 2.3%
Hunt Elementary 2.3%
Isaacs ECS 2.3%
Renner Middle 2.3%
Mitchell Elementary 2.2%
Rice Middle 2.2%
Haun Elementary 2.1%
Frankford Middle 2.1%
Carpenter Middle 2.1%
Jackson Elementary 2.1%
Shepton High 2.0%
Schimelpfenig Middle 2.0%
Otto Middle 1.8%
Plano West Senior High 1.8%
Daffron Elementary 1.8%
Wyatt Elementary 1.7%
Gulledge Elementary 1.7%
Mathews Elementary 1.6%
Christie Elementary 1.6%
Murphy Middle 1.6%
Memorial Elementary 1.6%
Thomas Elementary 1.6%
Huffman Elementary 1.6%
Wilson Middle 1.6%
Centennial Elementary 1.6%
Mendenhall Elementary 1.6%
Hickey Elementary 1.5%
Barron Elementary 1.4%
Jasper High 1.4%
Williams High 1.4%
Bethany Elementary 1.4%
Clark High 1.4%
Stinson Elementary 1.3%
Brinker Elementary 1.3%
Saigling Elementary 1.2%
Bowman Middle 1.2%
Meadows Elementary 1.2%
McMillen High School 1.1%
Rasor Elementary 1.1%
Weatherford Elementary 1.1%
Plano East Senior High 0.9%
Forman Elementary 0.9%
Armstrong Middle 0.7%
Plano Senior High 0.2%
By Emily Davis
Emily graduated from Sam Houston State University with a degree in multi-platform journalism and a minor in criminal justice in Spring 2018. During her studies, Emily worked as an editor and reporter at The Houstonian, SHSU's local newspaper. Upon graduation, she began an editorial internship at Community Impact Newspaper in DFW, where she was then hired as Community Impact's first McKinney reporter in August 2018.


Ebb & Flow serves original cocktails, salads and appetizers as well as burgers, sandwiches and full-size entrees, such as turkey stroganoff, grilled mahi mahi and ratatouille. (Rebecca Anderson/Community Impact staff)
Deep Ellum dining concept Ebb & Flow now open in Plano

Ebb & Flow is expected to celebrate its grand opening the evening of April 14 after initially opening in late March at The Shops at Legacy in Plano.

Chicken sandwich.
Fuku now fulfilling fried-chicken orders in Plano

Started by chef David Chang, Fuku offers several different fried-chicken sandwiches as well as chicken strips and fries.

Oak Point Park and Nature Preserve.
Environmental programs help Plano residents ‘live green'

“Sustainability has always been important to the city of Plano—making sure that what we’re leaving behind is sufficient for the future,” said Rachel Patterson, the city’s director of environmental health and sustainability.

Federal funding is set aside for public schools to address effects of the pandemic. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Why Texas has not yet distributed $18 billion in federal funds intended for public schools

As budget decisions loom for school districts across Texas, state leaders are holding on to federal funds intended for public schools to use in addressing the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The Electric Reliability Council of Texas said power outages are not expected April 13, while requesting energy conservation. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
UPDATE: ERCOT call for energy conservation ends April 13 without need for power outages

An ERCOT official said "tight" supply and demand conditions arose on the state's electric grid April 13 due to forecasting issues amid planned, seasonal maintenance outages by some power generators.

The chain has several restaurants in Texas, including two in College Station. (Courtesy I Heart Mac & Cheese)
I Heart Mac & Cheese coming to Highland Village; Gyro Shop opens in Frisco and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Denton County has been hosting mega vaccination clinics at Texas Motor Speedway. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)
Denton County COVID-19 cases continue to trend downward

Denton County is begining to see a "slight improvement" in COVID-19 cases, according to Matt Richardson, director of public health.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and U.S. Food and Drug Administration recommended health providers pause distribution of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine April 13. (Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
State, federal health authorities recommend pause of Johnson & Johnson vaccine after 6 rare, severe blood clots

Hub providers in Dallas, Harris and Travis counties have all announced they will follow the recommendations and pause distribution of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine.

Daniel Stockton, Frisco ISD's executive director of government and legal affairs (left) reviews a chart tracking positive COVID-19 cases among students and staff since November at the April 12 school board meeting. (Valerie Wigglesworth/Community Impact Newspaper)
Frisco ISD updates quarantine guidelines for COVID-19

Frisco ISD has updated its guidelines for close-contact quarantines related to COVID-19.

Community Impact Newspaper staff
$21M in rental assistance available in Denton County through Eviction Diversion Program

This eviction diversion program aims to prevent homelessness during the pandemic by helping tenants to stay in their homes and compensating landlords for unpaid rent.

The expanded pre-kindergarten program was discussed at Frisco ISD's board of trustees meeting on April 12. (Valerie Wigglesworth/Community Impact Newspaper)
Frisco ISD full-day pre-K program to expand for 2021-22 school year

Frisco ISD is opening registration on April 19 for an expanded full-day pre-kindergarten program for the 2021-22 school year.

Innovation studio.
AT&T opens 5G innovation studio in Plano

The studio, announced by AT&T April 8, will work to further the adoption of 5G technology into key areas of life, including sports, retail, education, travel, the public sector and small businesses, a company release shared.