River Place scraps pet portion of controversial trail fee, and letter from TPWD emerges rebutting district's defense of fee

The board of directors for the River Place Limited District decided it will no longer charge a $10 fee for pets during its Oct. 22 meeting.

The board of directors for the River Place Limited District decided it will no longer charge a $10 fee for pets during its Oct. 22 meeting.

The board of directors for the River Place Limited District in Northwest Austin has decided it will no longer charge $10 for pets that accompany humans using its nature trail, but humans will still have to pay the fee during designated hours.

The ruling came during the Oct. 22 board meeting and was accompanied by a decision to reduce its yearly charge for nonresidents of the limited district to use its tennis facilities from $300 to $100.

"We had a conversation with Texas Parks & Wildlife, and they brought up their concerns about the pet fee," said Scott Crosby, River Place Limited District board president.

The decision is the latest in an ongoing situation between the limited district and TPWD. The state agency began investigating the River Place trail fee earlier this year.

Since March, the River Place Limited District has been charging nonresidents $10 per person and per pet to use its nature trail. At issue has been whether trail access can be limited because the walkway was constructed partially via the use of state grant money, $500,000 of which was awarded in 2002.

A copy of a 2002 state project agreement shows that the state agency approved a state-funded grant of $500,000 to go toward completion of River Place MUD Woodlands Park and Nature Preserve, with a portion of that money to go toward the creation of the trail system.

Guidelines from the Texas Recreation & Parks Account Program in the same document stipulate the project sponsor “… will permanently dedicate for public park and recreation use all project area(s) which receive TRPA assistance, as required by Chapter 640.1.2 of TRPA Grants Manual Guidelines.”

Following the initial investigation, TPWD sent a letter to the limited district July 23 stating the fee must be "terminated immediately." The River Place board responded with a letter dated Aug. 6 from its legal team stating the trail fee was valid and comparing its fee to nearby Emma Long Metropolitan Park, which also charges admission.

The Oct. 22 decision to get rid of the pet portion of the fee also follows an Aug. 30 letter sent to the limited district from TPWD. That letter, obtained by Community Impact Newspaper and verified as having been seen by Crosby, stated the Aug. 6 letter from the limited district did not provide a valid defense of its trail fee.

The Aug. 30 rebuttal letter from TPWD states a comparison to Emma Long Metropolitan Park is not valid for several reasons. Among those: Emma Long charges the same fees for residents and nonresidents; the fee is assessed per vehicle, not per person; the fee is substantially lower than River Place's trail fee; and Emma Long offers far more amenities, activities and acreage.

"Due to major differences in fee structure and recreational diversity offered by the two parks, TPWD does not view Emma Long as a comparable facility to the River Place Nature Trail," the letter states. "The Turkey Creek Trail, located adjacent to Emma Long Park, is a comparable facility to the nature trail and is free to the public. There are also no user fees imposed on the adjacent motorcycle trail system."

Crosby said the decision to scrap the pet portion of River Place's trail fee was in no way influenced by the Aug. 30 letter from TPWD, but the board did discuss the letter with representatives from the state agency.

"In our initial phone conversations, we kind of went over that," he said. "We kind of presented our side and they presented their side and nothing really occurred."

On Oct. 30, members of TPWD will conduct a “walk through” of the nature trail, but earlier in the month, a TPWD representative said they would not comment further on proceedings at this time.

From the beginning of the implemention of the trail fee up through the end of August, the continuing costs for the fee program totaled $53,938.12, and the revenue was $55,360, resulting in a net gain of $1,421.88, Crosby said Oct. 4, adding the removal of the pet portion of the fee should not heavily impact revenue, which has mainly been channeled back into costs associated with charging the fee.

"There haven't been all that many dogs," he said. "We don't keep track of how many dogs versus people there are."
By Brian Rash
Brian has been a reporter and editor since 2012. He wrote about the music scene in Dallas-Fort Worth before becoming managing editor for the Graham Leader in Graham, Texas, in 2013. He relocated to Austin, Texas, in 2015 to work for Gatehouse Media's large design hub. He became the editor for the Lake Travis-Westlake publication of Community Impact in August 2018.


Tents have become a common sight throughout Austin including along Cesar Chavez Street downtown, but with the passage of Proposition B the city may now consider moving unsheltered homeless individuals to designated sites. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Hall notebook: Designated campsites for the homeless are back on the table

City staff had previously dismissed developing official camping locations in 2019, but new directives from City Council this week could revive the concept in Austin.

Wag-A-Bag is headquartered in Round Rock. (Megan Cardona/Community Impact Newspaper)
Wag-A-Bag to operate under new ownership, name; Austin, TxDOT at odds over I-35 overhaul; and more top Central Texas news

Read the most popular business and community news from the past week from the Austin area.

Stephanie Hayden-Howard will become an assistant city manager in Austin on May 10. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Role changes coming for health officials leading Austin-Travis County COVID-19 efforts

Dr. Desmar Walkes will take over as Austin's next medical director and local health authority as Dr. Mark Escott and Stephanie Hayden-Howard transition to new roles with the city.

Road closure stock image
TxDOT to demolish I-35 ramp in North Austin early Saturday morning

State crews will perform controlled implosions of the northbound I-35 to northbound US 183 flyover between 6-8 a.m. in the morning on May 8 and May 15.

Hand casting ballot stock image
What a potential election recount would look like at Pflugerville ISD

A race to determine a seat on the Pflugerville ISD board of trustees is separated by only 2 votes. What happens if a recount is requested? Read here to find out.

Pflugerville ISD administrative building
Facing possible budget constraints, Pflugerville ISD exploring energy conservation program

District officials are mulling over a program that may save the district more than $2 million in utility costs.

Bohls Middle School rendering
Pflugerville ISD officials working to get off-schedule middle school construction back on track

The contractor on the Bohls Middle School project has requested an extension on the timeline to substantially complete construction.

A pilot Austin Police Department cadet class is now set to commence in June under an updated training regimen and with additional city and community oversight on the APD academy's culture and curriculum. (John Cox/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Council votes to restart APD cadet training in June, with framework for ongoing reviews of pilot academy

The Austin Police Department's 144th cadet class will now kick off training next month, with continued oversight of APD's instruction and culture throughout the 34-week academy process.

Here are the most recent coronavirus updates from Williamson County. (Community Impact staff)
Here is what you need to know about COVID-19 in Williamson County

Here are the most recent coronavirus updates from Williamson County.

A sign advertises a property for rent in Austin on May 6. Local eviction orders remain in place through August 1 protecting most tenants from eviction. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Local eviction moratoriums remain in effect despite federal judge’s decision

The May 5 ruling from a U.S. District Court judge striking down a federal moratorium does not affect orders in place in Austin or Travis County.