Texas Gov. Greg Abbott floats ‘statewide camping ban’ as homeless debate heats up

The legality of reinstating tighter restrictions on public camping, solicitation, and sitting and lying down remains vague. (Courtesy Office of the Texas Governor)
The legality of reinstating tighter restrictions on public camping, solicitation, and sitting and lying down remains vague. (Courtesy Office of the Texas Governor)

The legality of reinstating tighter restrictions on public camping, solicitation, and sitting and lying down remains vague. (Courtesy Office of the Texas Governor)

The debate over public camping laws that threw Austin into a frenzy less than two years ago as the city faced a growing homelessness crisis is trending toward a resurrection after Gov. Greg Abbott highlighted the issue as a priority of the 87th Texas Legislature.

Abbott, a harsh critic of how Austin has handled its homelessness challenges, said the issue of public camping would be addressed this legislative session, which opened Jan. 12 and will last through May 31.

“I do expect to announce a statewide plan to address homelessness that will include a ban on camping as well as other ideas to make sure that Texas will be able to effectively and aggressively address the homelessness situation,” Abbott said following a public safety roundtable discussion.

The comments come a day after Abbott threatened to step in and reinstate tighter camping restrictions in Austin if Austin City Council did not act.

Austin Mayor Steve Adler, who voted for the relaxed camping measures in 2019, told a local media outlet this week that the current rules in place around public camping are not working; however, he said the city could not go back to “where we were.”

On June 20, 2019, Austin City Council voted to decriminalize public camping, solicitation and sitting and lying down, a polarizing decision intended to help address the city’s growing homelessness crisis. The logic was that decriminalizing these acts would lessen the frequency with which people experiencing homelessness dealt with the legal system.

A 2017 city audit called the laws prohibiting those behaviors regressive, ineffective and inefficient in dealing with homelessness. The audit reported that out of 18,000 citations issued between 2014-16, people frequently did not appear in court, which often led to arrest warrants that could hurt a person’s prospects for an apartment or job. The audit also highlighted constitutional violations baked into the ordinances, such as freedom of speech being breached by the no-solicitation law.

The decision led to months of heated debate in the community, which culminated with City Council putting some of the rules, such as prohibitions on camping on the sidewalk and sitting and lying down less than 15 feet from an operating business, back into place.

A campaign began the following year to put the policies up to a referendum. The group leading the push, Save Austin Now, initially failed to get enough valid signatures to put the question on the Nov. 2020; however, on Jan. 19, the group submitted another petition with 27,000 signatures they said supported the referendum vote. The city clerk is in the process of validating the petition. It only needs 20,000 valid signatures to reach the May 1 ballot.

The legality around reinstating policies that drew constitutionality concerns while in place remains unclear. The city of Austin’s legal team declined to comment as to whether reinstating the camping bans and the tighter restrictions on solicitation and sitting and lying down was legal.

The 2017 city audit of the rules highlighted the legal concerns around the laws. In 2018, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the federal court that covers the western U.S., ruled that bans against public camping violated protections against cruel and unusual punishment as outlined in the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The court ruled that unless a community had enough shelter beds for its homeless population, the community could not ban camping.

Texas is within the jurisdiction of the Fifth Circuit, which has not ruled on any similar cases. A Ninth Circuit ruling does not have jurisdiction in Texas.

Matt Mackowiak, co-founder of Save Austin Now, said that given the conservative makeup of the Fifth Circuit, any court challenge brought to the court is likely to favor tighter restrictions.

“We would prevail. We don’t believe this is unconstitutional,” Mackowiak said. “I have no doubt that left-wing extremists may very well explore legal avenues. There’s no real fear there. The city clerk, City Council [and] left-wing groups are scared to death of people voting on this policy.”

Emily Gerrick, policy director with the Texas Fair Defense Project, said reinstating the tighter restrictions could bring “severe constitutional problems that open the city up to litigation.”

Gerrick, who has helped advocate for the changes since 2018, said if a challenge were to make it to the Fifth Circuit and the court were to rule in favor of the restrictions, it would be a circuit split, which is when two federal circuit courts rule differently on the same issue. Circuit splits can lead to the U.S. Supreme Court getting involved.

The Ninth Circuit ruling against such bans took into consideration the formula of a community’s shelter bed inventory to its homeless population. Should Abbott follow through with his plan for a statewide camping ban, Gerrick said, it could get complicated.

Community Impact Newspaper reached out to several constitutional lawyers for clarity on how a court battle could play out; however, none of our sources were available by press time.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, USA Today and several other local outlets along the east coast.


Lawmakers began hearings Feb. 25 to hear from energy executives about what led to dayslong power outages following a Feb. 14 winter storm. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin weekly roundup: The storm is over, but the questions are just beginning

In hearings last week, a state senator from the Houston area called the power and water outages in Texas "the largest trainwreck in the history of degregulated electricity."

Crawfish season,  from mid-January through June, is the busiest time at Shoal Creek Saloon. (Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
Shoal Creek Saloon brings a piece of New Orleans to Austin

COVID-19 has dealt the Shoal Creek Saloon a blow, but owner Ray Canfield is hanging in there and said he was prepared for a disaster. He just thought it would be another flood, not a virus.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee recommended Johnson & Johnson’s one-shot vaccine for emergency authorization use Feb. 26. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine recommended for emergency authorization use by FDA

This is the third COVID-19 vaccine that has been approved for emergency authorization use after those produced by pharmaceutical company Pfizer and biotechnology company Moderna.

Josh Frank, owner of Blue Starlite Mini Urban Drive-in for more than a decade, holds up a Blue Starlite-branded mask. (Photo by Olivia Aldridge/Community Impact Newspaper)
Long-time Austin theater Blue-Starlite Mini Urban Drive-In takes on new life in pandemic

Drive-in theater Blue Starlite found itself in a unique position in 2020: After more than 10 years as a small business “just getting by,” demand for drive-in movies exploded, owner Josh Frank said.

The University of Texas Radio-Television-Film department will be offering virtual camps this summer. (Courtesy The University of Texas)
2021 Central Austin summer camp guide: 44 options including virtual and in-person offerings

Our list of camps happening in Austin this summer includes options focusing on academics, arts, sports and language.

Samsung's proposed $17 billion chip-making plant would dwarf other recent megaprojects that sought tax incentives in the region.
Samsung’s request to pay no property tax on $17 billion plant tests Austin’s incentive policy

Samsung is asking for 100% property tax reimbursement over 25 years, which would mark the most aggressive corporate tax break in Austin history.

A new Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine could help expand vaccination availability in Travis County, according to local health officials. (Courtesy Pexels)
Johnson & Johnson vaccine could mean additional supply, easier distribution rollout in Travis County

If approved, the Johnson & Johnson vaccine will be a valuable weapon against the ongoing pandemic, according to local health officials.

Austin ISD students will begin the 2021-22 school year Tuesday, Aug. 17. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Take a look at Austin ISD’s newly approved calendar for the 2021-22 school year

Austin ISD trustees have approved the academic calendar for the upcoming 2021-22 school year.

Snow covers I-45 in Houston during a winter storm that hit Texas the night of Feb. 14. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Legislators probe energy officials over power failures, lack of preparation heading into winter storm

The Texas Legislature held hearings Feb. 25 with energy companies including Oncor Electric Delivery and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas in response to last week’s historic winter storm, which left millions of Texans without electricity for days.

Austin ISD students are scheduled to return to classrooms March 1 for the first time since Winter Storm Uri. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Winter storm damage could prevent 10 Austin ISD campuses from reopening next week

Austin ISD students are scheduled to return to classrooms March 1 for the first time since Winter Storm Uri.

A tree's branches fell on a car in North Austin in the midst of Winter Storm Uri in February. With downed tree limbs and burst water lines causing property damage across Austin, the city has directed additional funds into programs to help some homeowners with emergency home repairs. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Still in crisis mode, Austin City Council initiates recovery following winter storm

With 200 to 400 apartment and condo complexes in Austin still without water, City Council is aiming to direct aid and relieve some of the financial burden felt by residents following the devastating winter storms.