Latest Austin police budget proposal seeks compromise, longer-term commitment to transformational change

Austin City Hall was one of several downtown buildings to get vandalized during June's protests against police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Hall was one of several downtown buildings to get vandalized during June's protests against police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

Austin City Hall was one of several downtown buildings to get vandalized during June's protests against police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

For months, loud voices in the community have pressed a sense of urgency into drastically cutting Austin’s police budget and reinvesting those funds into transformational changes to the city’s law enforcement and public safety strategy. During that time, city bureaucrats have begun mapping out avenues toward change but have offered little in terms of immediacy, proposing plans and timelines that stretch months.

With Austin City Council preparing to vote on the city’s fiscal year 2020-21 budget Aug. 12, one council member has offered a compromise proposal.

District 1 Council Member Natasha Harper-Madison has been among City Council’s most stringent supports of fundamentally reimagining how policing works in Austin. She has also expressed concern over making substantial decisions without proper vetting. Seeking a middle ground, Harper-Madison proposed City Council only authorize six months of police department funds.

The move, she said, was two-fold. It would allow more time for city staff to vet the various proposals—from restructuring to refinancing—made by council members, the community and experts. It would also require City Council, staff, the police department and the community to come back in March 2021 to face and vote on implementing the various proposals during what would be a mandatory mid-year budget session.

“This year’s accelerated budget process has left us with little time to do the work that is necessary to create lasting change in how our city addresses public safety,” Harper-Madison, City Council’s lone African-American representative, wrote on the City Council message board Aug. 4. “[My proposal] will ensure that [City Council] is in a position to vote on those items prior to or as part of a mid-year budget authorization in six months.”


Harper-Madison’s proposal would maintain the $11.3 million reduction to the police budget already proposed by City Manager Spencer Cronk through cutting 30 full-time officer positions and defunding the roughly 70 vacancies the department cannot reasonably fill next year.

Austin Mayor Steve Adler said the proposal “made sense” to him, admitting that he remains unsure about several of the police budget proposals made by City Council members. Although he acknowledged there are improvements the “community wants to see happening yesterday,” he is hard-pressed to support proposals that have not received proper vetting.

“I don’t know how best to give [Cronk’s team] the time to do that work without signaling to the community that we’re serious about getting this stuff done,” Adler said.

Last week, Cronk’s team, led by Deputy City Manager Nuria Rivera-Vandermyde, laid out its plans for reimagining public safety in Austin. The scope was wide, and the plan provided few definite dates and results. Adler pressed Cronk’s team to acknowledge the pressure from those in the community calling for immediate changes. Adler warned that taking too long could erode community trust.

Harper-Madison’s six-month proposal was welcomed by Austin Police Association President Ken Casaday. However, he said, ideally, such substantial changes to policing and public safety as those proposed by other City Council members would get punted for at least another year.

“I think out of everything I’ve heard so far come out of City Council’s mouth, this is probably the smartest thing,” Casaday said. “You can’t make major changes too quickly. If you’re trying to do the best for the city, the best for employees and the best for the community overall, these things take time.”

Casaday said to make significant changes to policing and public, the wider citizenry, not just activists, needed to be in on the conversations.

For months, local activist organizations have been mobilizing calls for dramatic cuts to the Austin police budget, between $100 million to $220 million, and reinvesting those dollars into public safety initiatives outside of policing, from mental health intervention to violence-prevention programs. Austin Justice Coalition, a criminal justice organization that has been at the forefront of local police debates in recent years, has called for a $100 million cut since June, with several City Council members supporting the effort.

The group’s executive director, Chas Moore, said he knows that substantial police reforms will take time but still wants to see City Council commit to significantly altering the public safety budget to spend less on policing and more on social programs that prevent harm.

“Obviously we have our sights on immediate cuts and transitions, and support the proposals that aligned with these goals,” Moore said via text. “There was discussion at [the July 28 City Council meeting] around this urgency and the benefits of these amendments and we hope there is more agreement between council members for [a] push for change now.”

Moore said some changes can be made immediately, such as expanding emergency medical services. He acknowledged there are other changes that will take more time but said this is a “both and” not an “either or” moment.

District 4 Council Member Greg Casar said he remains committed to reaching a $100 million reduction to the police budget by City Council’s scheduled Aug. 12 budget vote. Casar is among a few council members who have pushed specific proposals that would divert the $100 million away from the police department and into various public safety-focused programs. Casar said he supports Harper-Madison’s proposal to fund only the first six months of the police budget but believes it can happen alongside significant budget changes by next week.

“My sense is that we can do both,” Casar said. “I think the debate you’ll see next week will be around which things City Council members feel comfortable getting done in August and which things they think need more time.”

Citing the common practice of city staff to request deadline extensions, Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza said she was "nervous" about the six-month timeline offered by Harper-Madison. Garza has supported what she called the "symbolism" of the demands to cut $100 million from the police department budget.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, USA Today and several other local outlets along the east coast.


MOST RECENT

From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)
In Austin City Council’s District 4, candidates discuss addressing homelessness and mental health

Two challengers will face incumbent Greg Casar for the Northeast Austin City Council seat.

Gov. Greg Abbott on July 27 issued an executive order extending the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election. (Screenshot of Sept. 17 press conference)
Lawsuit takes aim at start date for early voting as some Texas Republicans challenge Gov. Greg Abbott's order

A group of prominent Texas Republicans has embarked on a legal effort to undo the governor's executive order that extended the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election.

A photo of Elong Musk
After filing Travis County site plans, Tesla CEO Elon Musk speaks to new gigafactory’s place in the company

Tesla has filed the intial site plans for a massive manufacturing plant in southeastern Travis County.

Straying from traditionals like cheese and pepperoni, Tony C's serves specialty pies such as eggplant, prosciutto and goat cheese, and the Truffle Shuffle. (Courtesy Tony C's Pizza & Beer Garden)
Restaurant Tony C's to open Sept. 24 in Round Rock and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

(Graphic illustration by Rachal Russel/Community Impact Newspaper)
From New Braunfels to Cedar Park, Central Texas outdoor recreation shops scrambling to keep inventory

When combined with temporary state restrictions due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many local shop owners are speculating a perfect storm of low supply and high demand is the main reason for changes in an industry that has of late been turned on its head.

Austin ISD teachers have been able to teach virtually from their classrooms to start the school year. Some students will return to the classroom Oct. 5. (Courtesy Austin ISD)
Austin ISD teachers adjust to virtual learning as in-person demands approach

Austin ISD teachers and principals discuss the first few weeks of virtual learning.

Early voting runs from Oct. 13-30. Election Day is Nov. 3. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Find a polling location where you can vote early in Travis County

Voters can cast their ballots at any of the 37 early voting locations from Oct. 13-30.

Mercury Hall will close in 2021. (Courtesy Mercury Hall)
Mercury Hall property cleared for 5-story apartment development

Mercury Hall will close after 2021, and a dense multifamily development is set to arrive in its wake.

Buddy's Burger is open in Northeast Austin off of Cameron Road. (Courtesy Buddy's Burger)
Now open in Austin: Party Barn is back, drive-in movies downtown, burgers in North Austin and more

Blue Starlite began showing drive-in movies downtown in September. Buddy's Burger is open off Cameron Road and planning to expand to more locations, and new bar High Noon is open on the east side.

City Post is located at 113 E. Eighth St., Georgetown. (Courtesy City Post)
Georgetown to get steakhouse, speakeasy plus more Central Texas news

Read the latest Central Texas business and community news.

Easy Tiger announced Sept. 18 it had closed its downtown Austin location on Sixth Street. (Courtesy Easy Tiger)
Easy Tiger announces permanent closure of original Sixth Street location

The local bakery and restaurant remains open at the Linc and still plans to open in South Austin.

A photo of a "sold" sign
Central Austin August housing market numbers show high dollar-volume sales

While housing inventory remains low, home prices continue to rise.