Petition to reinstate Austin's homeless camping ban ruled invalid by city clerk

A camp is set up by someone experiencing homelessness in August 2019. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
A camp is set up by someone experiencing homelessness in August 2019. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

A camp is set up by someone experiencing homelessness in August 2019. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)

A petition aimed at reinstating Austin's ban on homeless encampments, sitting and lying down and soliciting was ruled insufficient after Austin's city clerk determined it did not have the required 20,000 signatures to make its way onto the Nov. 3 ballot.

Local nonprofit Save Austin Now submitted the petition July 20 with what organizers said were 24,087 valid signatures. The petition asked signatories whether they support reinstating the ban on camping, prohibiting sitting and lying in the downtown area, and the criminalization of panhandling between 7 p.m. and 7 a.m. If the petition contained enough signatures, the language from the petition would make its way onto the Nov. 3 ballot as a referendum. Save Austin Now had been working on gathering signatures since February.

After a thorough analysis, City Clerk Janette Goodall determined she and the city were "virtually certain" the number of valid signatures fell below the 20,000 threshold set by local law. She estimated the petition contained only 19,122 valid signatures.

In a memo, Goodall said she discovered the petition contained two versions of the language, requiring her to remove 397 signatures. Then using the standard method, she took a sample of 6,501 signatures to analyze for validity. Goodall said she removed 41 duplicate signatures and 1,106 signatures for "other reasons." Goodall did not provide clarification of "other reasons," but a city spokesperson said the reasons for disqualifying signatures included absence from the registered voter rolls, missing signatures and missing dates.

Using the random sample, Goodall concluded she and the city were 95% confident there more than 18,887 valid signatures, but fewer than 19,356.

"The probability that checking all 24,201 submitted signatures would find a total of at least 20,000 valid signatures is less than 3 in one billion," Goodall wrote in her analysis. "The city is virtually certain that the true number of valid signatures is fewer than 20,000."

Matt Mackowiak, co-founder of Save Austin Now and Travis County GOP chairman, said the organization was reviewing its options, which he said could include legal action.

"I don't believe for one second that 1,100 out of 6,000 signatures were invalid," Mackowiak said. "I don't want to attack the integrity of the clerk because I believe she does have integrity. But based on what we were told, we believe there were some problems with the way all of this was conducted."

Mackowiak would not elaborate on specifics, but he said he does not believe signatures missing dates should be ruled invalid. He said there are other ways to determine whether a signature was collected within the last six months, as law requires.

"This fight is not over," Mackowiak said.

Chris Harris, project director for Homes Not Handcuffs, welcomed the news.

"We are ecstatic, but unsurprised that Save Austin Now failed to gain meaningful support for a petition seeking to punish poverty and re-establish policing as our primary approach to homelessness," Harris said in a statement. "It is clear that this community wants an Austin for all, not just an Austin for the privileged few.”

For more information on how the city's petition process works, check out Community Impact Newspaper's coverage from 2019.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, USA Today and several other local outlets along the east coast.


Aba, a Mediterranean restaurant based in Chicago, will open in Austin on Oct. 1. (Courtesy Aba)
Coming soon to Austin: Pavement opening second vintage store, Chicago-based Mediterranean spot comes to Music Lane and more

Two Hands, an Australian café, and Mediterranean spot Aba will both be opening in the Music Lane area along South Congress within the next few weeks.

Simon Madera, owner of Taco Flats, said business is down 40% across the board but that he has readjusted the business model to stay afloat in the pandemic long term. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
After surviving six months, Austin's workers, small businesses are acknowledging pandemic's long-term reality

After months of day-to-day reassessments, many in the business community are now figuring out how to make it to the other end of the pandemic.

From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)
In Austin City Council’s District 4, candidates discuss addressing homelessness and mental health

Two challengers will face incumbent Greg Casar for the Northeast Austin City Council seat.

Gov. Greg Abbott on July 27 issued an executive order extending the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election. (Screenshot of Sept. 17 press conference)
Lawsuit takes aim at start date for early voting as some Texas Republicans challenge Gov. Greg Abbott's order

A group of prominent Texas Republicans has embarked on a legal effort to undo the governor's executive order that extended the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election.

A photo of Elong Musk
After filing Travis County site plans, Tesla CEO Elon Musk speaks to new gigafactory’s place in the company

Tesla has filed the intial site plans for a massive manufacturing plant in southeastern Travis County.

Straying from traditionals like cheese and pepperoni, Tony C's serves specialty pies such as eggplant, prosciutto and goat cheese, and the Truffle Shuffle. (Courtesy Tony C's Pizza & Beer Garden)
Restaurant Tony C's to open Sept. 24 in Round Rock and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

(Graphic illustration by Rachal Russel/Community Impact Newspaper)
From New Braunfels to Cedar Park, Central Texas outdoor recreation shops scrambling to keep inventory

When combined with temporary state restrictions due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many local shop owners are speculating a perfect storm of low supply and high demand is the main reason for changes in an industry that has of late been turned on its head.

Austin ISD teachers have been able to teach virtually from their classrooms to start the school year. Some students will return to the classroom Oct. 5. (Courtesy Austin ISD)
Austin ISD teachers adjust to virtual learning as in-person demands approach

Austin ISD teachers and principals discuss the first few weeks of virtual learning.

Early voting runs from Oct. 13-30. Election Day is Nov. 3. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Find a polling location where you can vote early in Travis County

Voters can cast their ballots at any of the 37 early voting locations from Oct. 13-30.

Mercury Hall will close in 2021. (Courtesy Mercury Hall)
Mercury Hall property cleared for 5-story apartment development

Mercury Hall will close after 2021, and a dense multifamily development is set to arrive in its wake.

Buddy's Burger is open in Northeast Austin off of Cameron Road. (Courtesy Buddy's Burger)
Now open in Austin: Party Barn is back, drive-in movies downtown, burgers in North Austin and more

Blue Starlite began showing drive-in movies downtown in September. Buddy's Burger is open off Cameron Road and planning to expand to more locations, and new bar High Noon is open on the east side.

City Post is located at 113 E. Eighth St., Georgetown. (Courtesy City Post)
Georgetown to get steakhouse, speakeasy plus more Central Texas news

Read the latest Central Texas business and community news.