Austin's $4.2 billion proposed budget includes 2.5% reduction to police department funding

The proposed fiscal year 2020-21 budget includes an $11.3 million reduction in police spending, achieved largely by eliminating 100 vacant positions within the Austin Police Department. (Design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)
The proposed fiscal year 2020-21 budget includes an $11.3 million reduction in police spending, achieved largely by eliminating 100 vacant positions within the Austin Police Department. (Design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)

The proposed fiscal year 2020-21 budget includes an $11.3 million reduction in police spending, achieved largely by eliminating 100 vacant positions within the Austin Police Department. (Design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)

After calls from community advocates to reallocate at least $100 million from Austin Police Department to other city services, Austin City Manager Spencer Cronk proposed a budget July 13 that includes an $11.3 million reduction in police spending.

The $4.2 billion overall budget and the $1.1 billion taxpayer-supported general fund for fiscal year 2020-21 are both largely unchanged from last year. Property tax revenue would increase by 3.5%, resulting in a $19.73 increase in annual city property tax payments for the homeowner of a median-valued $362,000 property.

Community groups, such as the Austin Justice Coalition and Grassroots Leadership, have called on the city to reduce the police department budget significantly and reassign certain duties, such as responding to mental health crises, to other departments or public agencies.

On June 11, City Council voted on a set of four policies aimed at responding to the growing local and national momentum around policing, including a commitment to spending fewer public dollars on the police budget.

The $11.3 million cut would put the overall police department funding in FY 2020-21 around $434.3 million overall—a 2.5% reduction from the forecasted budget this spring.


Alicia Torres of community advocacy group ICE Fuera de Austin, or ICE Out of Austin, said that reduction is not enough and that city leaders should listen to community members who want to see more money diverted from the police budget to the city's Relief In a State of Emergency Fund, or RISE Fund.

"We are not asking City Council to take a wild guess as to where the money needs to go. We are providing them a roadmap as to where the money needs to go," Torres said.

David Johnson, criminal justice organizer at Grassroots Leadership, said the proposal to cut just $11 million from the budget is "disrespectful" to those calling for more broad, sweeping changes.

"$11 million is spitting in our eyes. $11 million is telling the city, 'We don't take your needs or your wants seriously, and this is the best we're going to give you,'" Johnson said.

Ed Van Eenoo, the city's deputy chief financial officer, said most of the projected savings would come from eliminating 100 vacant police officer positions from the forecast budget. Other cost-cutting measures include delaying the July 2020 cadet class and holding off on replacing officers' service pistols.

Ken Casaday, president of the Austin Police Association—the union representing police—said the city had an agreement with the police department to add 30 positions a year and that the city staff are now "going back on their word" by eliminating the vacant positions in the budget.

The positions are needed for Austin police to provide a high level of service to the community, Casaday said. In an average year, about 50 Austin PD officers retire, according to Casaday, but in 2020, he said, 60 officers have retired already.

"Cutting officers like they did was, in my opinion, irresponsible," he said.

In June, amidst nationwide protests to reform policing following the killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, the Austin Justice Coalition called for a $100 million reduction to the police department budget.

In a statement released after the proposal, AJC Executive Director Chas More said the proposed budget "comes nowhere near" the changes the group thinks are appropriate.

Most City Council members who sat down for interviews with Community Impact Newspaper said they wanted to see significant change in the city's approach to policing but were not sure how those changes would translate to a dollar amount in the budget. However, Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza and District 4 City Council Member Greg Casar both said they would like to see a $100 million reduction.

“I mean, $100 million is less than 25% of the police budget. I would say asking for a 25% reduction is the right thing to be doing right now. Frankly, you always ask for more than what you think you can get," Garza said.

Casar released a statement after the proposal saying the budget is an incremental step in reducing patrol funding in favor of community safety, but he said "it is far from enough."

COVID-19 impact

Despite declining sales tax revenue—which makes up roughly a quarter of the city's general fund—Van Eenoo said a hiring freeze, limiting additions of positions, the increase in property tax funding and the city's "austere" approach will allow Austin to keep the budget flat.

The most recent data from the Texas State Comptroller's Office shows that in May, Austin took in $17.5 million in sales tax revenue, down 10.8% from the same period the year before.

Van Eenoo said city staff projects those revenue numbers will rebound slightly in the future, although they likely will not return to 2019 levels, allowing the city to avoid layoffs and give employees a 2% salary increase.

Under Gov. Greg Abbott's disaster declaration due to the outbreak of COVID-19, Van Eenoo said the city had the option of increasing property tax revenue by up to 8% without needing to go to the voters for a tax rate election. However, in recognizing city leaders may ask voters in November to approve a tax increase for Capital Metro's $9.8 billion plan to revamp public transportation in the area, Van Eenoo said city staff wanted to keep the budget conservative.

"We felt it was important to bring the budget forward with as low a tax rate as possible," he said.

The city is scheduled to hold public input sessions on the budget July 23 and 30, and City Council will hold work sessions July 28 and Aug. 4. Council will then hold meetings beginning Aug. 12 to adopt the budget.

Editor's note: This story has been updated with additional information after it was originally posted, including a clarification to the police budget reduction figures.


MOST RECENT

Chief Equity Officer Stephanie Hawley speaks to trustees at a board information session Aug. 10. (Courtesy Austin ISD)
Outside equity assessment at AISD could evaluate hiring practices, past closures

A report could look at the root causes of inequities and offer the district best practices as potential solutions.

Retailer Harbor Freight Tools will open a Georgetown location Aug. 11. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harbor Freight Tools coming to Georgetown and more Central Texas news

Read the latest Central Texas business and community news.

Capital Metro and the City of Austin are preparing to ask voters in November to fund $7.1 billion of a $10 billion plan to expand public transportation across the city. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Project Connect one step away from officially heading to Austin voters

Austin City Council and the Capital Metro board of directors approved a contract with the voters Aug. 7 laying out details of the plan and set up the rules for a board that will make funding decisions.

Beginning at noon Aug. 10, Lake Pflugerville trail will reopen for public use. (Courtesy city of Pflugerville)
Lake Pflugerville trail to reopen and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

Rapid nasal swab antigen tests are recommended as options for individuals who were potentially exposed to a confirmed positive carrier, as well as for people traveling, returning to work or undergoing a medical procedure. (Courtesy Total Primary Care)
Find out where to get a 15-minute COVID-19 test in Austin, Dallas-Fort Worth metros

Rapid nasal swab antigen tests are recommended as options for individuals who were potentially exposed to a confirmed positive carrier, as well as for people traveling, returning to work or undergoing a medical procedure.

Thom's Market will open at the corner of Burnet Road and Koenig Lane. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Thom's Market to open fourth Austin location

The new spot for the locally owned market will be on the corner of Burnet Road and Koenig Lane.

Three new concepts will open at 2113 Manor Road, Austin, the future location of seafood restaurant Este. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Pop-ups from former Olamaie, Pitchfork Pretty chefs opening on Manor Road

Este, the seafood restaurant from the team behind Suerte, is set to open in 2021. Until then, Le Cowboy, Rogue Radish and Heritage Seafood Market will operate at the property.

JewBoy Burgers will be moving to a brick-and-mortar location on Airport Boulevard in September. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
JewBoy Burgers moving to Airport Boulevard brick-and-mortar

Owner Mo Pittle will be moving from his food truck on Burnet Road to a new space formerly occupied by Cluck-n-Burger.

A mother and daughter visit at Seasons Assisted Living & Memory Care in Conroe earlier in the pandemic. (Courtesy Seasons Assisted Living & Memory Care)
Texas allows limited visitations to nursing homes, long-term care facilities

Facilities that meet the requirements will allow limited visitations, but you still will not be able to hug or kiss your loved one.

Chelsea Wine and Mike Hooker opened Rave On Vintage in 2013. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Rave On Vintage will close North Loop store at the end of August

Owners Mike Hooker and Chelsea Wine will transition the store fully to online sales.