Travis County group urges bond reforms after settlement in Harris County

Work group members—including Geoffrey Burkhart, Texas Indigent Defense Commission executive director; District Attorney Margaret Moore; County Attorney David Escamilla; County Court-at-Law Judge Elisabeth Earle; and Amanda Woog, Texas Fair Defense Project executive director—recommended a series of bond reforms at a Feb. 11 Travis County Commissioners Court meeting. (Courtesy Travis County)
Work group members—including Geoffrey Burkhart, Texas Indigent Defense Commission executive director; District Attorney Margaret Moore; County Attorney David Escamilla; County Court-at-Law Judge Elisabeth Earle; and Amanda Woog, Texas Fair Defense Project executive director—recommended a series of bond reforms at a Feb. 11 Travis County Commissioners Court meeting. (Courtesy Travis County)

Work group members—including Geoffrey Burkhart, Texas Indigent Defense Commission executive director; District Attorney Margaret Moore; County Attorney David Escamilla; County Court-at-Law Judge Elisabeth Earle; and Amanda Woog, Texas Fair Defense Project executive director—recommended a series of bond reforms at a Feb. 11 Travis County Commissioners Court meeting. (Courtesy Travis County)

Following historic bail reforms made in Harris County and ahead of the primary election in March, a work group consisting of local elected officials, county staff, judges and attorneys presented a series of recommendations to Travis County commissioners at a Feb. 11 meeting.

The key proposals include identifying certain nonviolent offenses and criteria for which defendants could be preapproved for release on a personal bond, which requires no payment except an administrative fee, and exploring the possibility of providing representation at magistration.

“This is not replacing what we have currently,” County Court-at-Law Judge Elisabeth Earle told commissioners. “It’s adding to it.”

The precedent


In December, Harris County instituted historic bail reforms, granting personal bonds to most misdemeanor arrestees and requiring the pretrial release of all misdemeanor arrestees, excluding those accused of offenses such as domestic violence or assault.

The reforms resulted from a landmark settlement.

In 2016, three people charged with misdemeanors—which include crimes such as drug possession, theft and driving while intoxicated—filed a lawsuit against Harris County, alleging it unfairly jailed misdemeanor defendants who could not afford bail. In 2017, a federal judge declared the county’s bail system unconstitutional.

The local system


When someone is arrested in Travis County, he or she is booked at the local jail and screened by staff to determine if he or she is eligible for release on a personal bond and a court-appointed attorney.


A personal bond is a sworn agreement by a defendant that he or she will return to court as ordered. It does not require a payment except for an administrative fee.

If recommended for a personal bond, he or she then goes before a judge, whose approval is required for release. This is called a magistration hearing, and in Travis County attorneys are not present.

“The first time they stand in front of a judge; they are standing there alone,” said Geoffrey Burkhart, executive director of the Texas Indigent Defense Commission. “They don’t have an attorney counseling them on this, and this is an important moment where probable cause is being determined, where bail is being determined.”

Possible changes


The recommendations followed the issuance of a standing order by Travis County’s seven court-at-law judges, who oversee misdemeanor criminal cases, on Feb. 6. The order lays out a plan to expand the use of personal bonds for defendants who meet certain criteria.

County Attorney David Escamilla told commissioners that the work group and the county court-at-law judges “have taken the extraordinary step to move forward with a standing order providing for an automatic bond process to be added in conjunction with our already very wonderful personal bond system."

In 2018, 60% of misdemeanor defendants eligible for release on a personal bond received one, according to an earlier presentation made by the work group.

Serious consequences can result for those denied a personal bond. If they cannot afford bail, they remain in jail, which can lead to a lost job or the removal of one’s children by Child Protective Services.

“The longer a person is in jail, the worse your outcomes are going to be,” said Bradley Hargis, deputy director of the Capital Area Private Defender Service, which assigns private counsel to clients who quality for a court-appointed attorneys.

The work group in Travis County also recommended identifying a list of nonviolent felony offenses for which defendants could be preapproved for release on a personal bond.

“I’m hopeful,” District Attorney Margaret Moore said of achieving this within the current budget cycle, which ends Sept. 30.

Expanding the use of personal bonds could create cost savings and other benefits for the county by reducing the number of people in jail and the length of time they spend incarcerated.

“It saves the jail to handle the people they need to focus on,” Earle said.

What’s ahead


While commissioners expressed their personal support for the recommendations, County Judge Sarah Eckhardt stressed the added costs of providing representation at magistration.

“We need to have a sharp pencil and figure how much it would cost under a 3.5[% property tax] revenue cap,” Eckhardt said. “It’s going to be a large number. This kind of pilot would be important to us so that we would know what kind of offsetting benefits there are both in human benefit and in financial benefit because it will be a big number.”

Additionally, criminal justice reform advocates raised concerns about the standing order and expressed hope that a second version might be issued that follows the precedent set by Harris County, in which defendants preapproved for release on a personal bond can bypass the magistration process altogether.

“I think this is a place where Travis County can show up Harris County,” said Amanda Woog, executive director of the Texas Fair Defense Project.

SHARE THIS STORY

Emma Freer



MOST RECENT

A Capital Metro employee who worked as a bus mechanic has died after testing positive for the coronavirus. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Capital Metro employee who tested positive for coronavirus dies

The individual worked as a bus mechanic. Capital Metro announced April 2 he and three other employees tested positive for the virus.

The Central Texas Food Bank served 1,515 households free food at an event April 4 at Nelson Field in northeast Austin. (Courtesy Central Texas Food Bank)
Central Texas Food Bank serves free food to 1,515 households April 4

Each household received two boxes with about 24 pounds of food each.

(Brian Perdue/Community Impact Newspaper)
Thousands of construction workers this week returned to work in Austin. What are developers doing to ensure safe work sites?

After most residential construction briefly shut down across the city of Austin, home building crews now have the opportunity to return the work.

(Graphic illustration courtesy Jay Jones/Community Impact Newspaper)
‘We’ve got this’: Central Texas librarians step up to help their communities amid coronavirus pandemic

The example in Bee Cave appears to be just one of many stories relating how, amid the COVID-19 crisis, librarians are helping their communities throughout the Greater Austin area.

Local restaurant Emmer & Rye is offering groceries at its Rainey Street location. (Courtesy Emmer & Rye)
Local business efforts to help the community: restaurants open grocery markets; Service Dogs, Inc. donates 18,000 pounds of dog food

Malibu Poke is donating meals to the Central Texas Food Bank, and Santa Rita Cantina is offering customers a chance to purchase meals for employees at Seton Medical Center.

Economic relief options for small business owners include the Small Business Administration's Economic Injury Disaster Loan. (Community Impact Newspaper Staff)
Has your Austin-area small business been affected by the coronavirus? Here are resources you can access.

The U.S. Small Business Administration is offering a short-term loan program intended to help cover payroll and a separate, long-term loan program intended to help business owners stay afloat.

A recent string of incidents where Zoom meetings have been “hacked” has put the future viability of teleconferencing security in doubt. (Courtesy Pixabay)
String of racist attacks via videoconferencing software leads to heightened security concerns

A recent string of incidents where Zoom meetings have been “hacked” has put the future viability of teleconferencing security in doubt.

Austin and Travis County's orders went into place March 25 and require residents to stay home for everything but essential travel. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
5 recent coronavirus stories from the Austin area readers should know

Read local updates on the coronavirus pandemic.

Austin FC and Upper Ninety on March 30 released a guide of resources for local families. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin FC, Upper Ninety compile bilingual resource guide for Austin families

Austin FC and Upper Ninety on March 30 released a guide of resources for local families.

Friday's digital telethon will help Austin metro residents through nonprofits during the coronavirus pandemic.
Donations to All Together ATX will help local residents through grants to nonprofits

Friday's digital telethon seeks donations to help the community

Power lines
DATA: Austin’s residential electricity usage up more than 30% since beginning of March

The total residential electricity usage has increased by more than 31.88% across Austin Energy’s service area since the last week of February, the new numbers show.