Austin grapples with regulations for scooters, micro-mobility after one year in the city

Image description
All over the map
Image description
Relative Safety
Image description
Future Features

Nearing one year in Austin, dockless vehicles are poised to stay, develop new functions


Updated March 26 at 4:30 p.m. to clarify the city of Austin's effort to regulate ride-hailing companies 

This April will mark one year since dockless vehicles arrived in Austin, but the city continues to workshop their regulations, balancing a need for safety with room for innovation.

“Half of people I run into have had near-death experiences with a scooter, and the other half of the city can’t imagine life without a scooter,” Austin Mayor Steve Adler said at a Feb. 28 mobility committee meeting.

While some cities—such as Seattle and Dripping Springs—have banned dockless scooters, Austin has emerged as a leader that other cities look to as they develop their own regulations, said Greg Griffin, an associate research scientist at the Texas A&M Transportation Institute—the largest transportation research agency in the country—who has researched bike-share programs.

But Austin continues to refine its rules. The transportation department paused issuing licenses to companies in January as it revises demand for these vehicles. The parks and recreation department is overseeing a pilot program to determine how to integrate these vehicles on trails and parkland. The public health department has partnered with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to study scooter crashes and their causes. And City Council will vote on a number of changes to its ordinance regulating rider behavior at its March 28 meeting.

Despite concerns about safety and enforcement, all signs point to scooters and similar disruptive technologies—innovations that spawn new industries  and shake up existing industries— remaining a part of the city’s transportation network for years to come.

“[T]his is perhaps the early side of a rapid set of changes in mobility,” Griffin said.

Market forces


Today, there are 10 dockless mobility companies licensed to operate in Austin, with a combined total of 17,650 permitted vehicles among them, per the Austin Transportation Department. The majority of the vehicles—15,300, or nearly 87 percent—are electric scooters.

“We see private companies looking at transportation as a kind of new consumer market,” said Ginger Goodin, an Austin-based senior research engineer at the Texas A&M Transportation Institute who has studied disruptive  transportation technologies. “We’re going to continue to see innovators and entrepreneurs developing solutions to address the really big challenges that we have, in congestion and safety and equity,” which, she added, public agencies do not have the funding to address.

It appears Austinites are seeking such solutions. Between March 1 and March 18, 496,608 dockless vehicle rides occurred in the city, up from 371,307 in February and 51,166 in April 2018, when the first scooter operators launched, per ATD.

Consumer demand is critical, as the city learned when it tried to require ride-hailing companies to perform fingerprint background checks on drivers, which some companies, such as Uber and Lyft, argued were overly burdensome and led them to halt operations in Austin. Ultimately, state lawmakers passed regulation in 2017 that trumped local ordinances.

“[Ride-hailing companies] had already built up a consumer market where people were getting it; they liked the services; and they wanted to continue to use them,” Goodin said. “So those policymakers faced a backlash from their constituencies [when they tried to ban them].”

This technology may also appeal to tourists and Austinites who are interested in sustainability.

“More and more people are actually concerned about the environment, and more and more people are understanding that this is the future,” said Dor Falu Korngold, co-founder of Mod Bikes, an electric bike store in South Austin, likening electric vehicles to solar panels and recycling.

Challenges


“I hear about scooters on an extremely regular basis,” Council Member Kathie Tovo said at the Feb. 28 mobility committee meeting, citing constituent feedback on scooter pickup, safety and enforcement. Tovo represents District 9, which includes downtown.

South Austin resident Clint Buckley said he uses scooters to get lunch while at work and when traveling locally along Ben White and Lamar boulevards but worries about areas that lack designated spaces for dockless vehicles.

“As long as the infrastructure is there, like having a bike lane and having some distance from the cars, it is so much more comforting,” Buckley said.

A sample of data, collected by Austin/Travis County Emergency Medical Services between Dec. 1 and Jan. 31 shows 71 scooter-related injuries resulting in EMS response occurred.

As of press time, one scooter-related fatality has been reported. It occurred around 1 a.m. on Feb. 2, when a 21-year-old scooter user riding the wrong way on the I-35 frontage road was hit by a car.

Austin Public Health, along with the CDC, continues to study the causes of these incidents as well as the safety of these devices relative to other forms of transportation. Their findings are expected to be published by early April.

Another concern is whether riders are following rules established by the city’s transportation department last fall.

“There really is no enforcement happening,” said Heidi Anderson, executive director of the Trail Foundation, a nonprofit that maintains the Butler Hike-and-Bike Trail along Lady Bird Lake.

Dockless vehicles are not allowed on the trail, per city ordinance, but Anderson said people frequently ride and leave scooters along the trail and, sometimes, in the lake.

“[W]e’ve lost donations due to the scooters,” Anderson said. “[Previous donors said] they don’t want to support us because they think that we have more authority than we do.”

On the horizon


On March 28, City Council will vote on a series of changes to its ordinance governing rider behavior.

The changes include redefining dockless mobility as “micro-mobility,” a broader term that would allow regulations to apply to future transportation modes; requiring micro-mobility users to obey the same rules of the road as drivers; and providing local law enforcement authority to issue citations to those violating the ordinance, per a draft presented by ATD at a March 18 meeting of the Urban Transportation Commission.

Later this spring, ATD will present additional proposals to council, including a potential cap on the number of micro-mobility operators, similar to the city’s approach to pedicabs, and increased operation fees that would allow the city to recoup the costs of processing applications, inspecting fleets, responding to citizen service requests and investing in infrastructure.

“What we see in public policy innovation is it tends to be an incremental process,” Goodin said. “It’s hard for public agencies ... to anticipate what could be coming and to set up a regulatory framework in advance.”

Dockless mobility “is the biggest change to the transportation landscape in over 70 years,” Jason JonMichael, assistant director of smart mobility for ATD, told Community Impact Newspaper in January. But it is not likely the last.

Representatives at Lime, Bird and Ojo Electric said they are working to improve their geofencing capabilities, which would allow them to restrict vehicles’ use to areas where they are allowed.

“We’re striving for that technology,” said Matt Tolan, vice president of sales and partnerships at Ojo, which recently launched 100 seated electric commuter scooters in Austin. “We’re not there yet.”
By Emma Freer
Emma Freer began covering Central Austin for Community Impact Newspaper in 2017. Her beat includes the Travis County Commissioners Court and local business news. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School in 2017.


MOST RECENT

From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)
In Austin City Council’s District 4, candidates discuss addressing homelessness and mental health

Two challengers will face incumbent Greg Casar for the Northeast Austin City Council seat.

Gov. Greg Abbott on July 27 issued an executive order extending the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election. (Screenshot of Sept. 17 press conference)
Lawsuit takes aim at start date for early voting as some Texas Republicans challenge Gov. Greg Abbott's order

A group of prominent Texas Republicans has embarked on a legal effort to undo the governor's executive order that extended the early voting period for the Nov. 3 election.

A photo of Elong Musk
After filing Travis County site plans, Tesla CEO Elon Musk speaks to new gigafactory’s place in the company

Tesla has filed the intial site plans for a massive manufacturing plant in southeastern Travis County.

Straying from traditionals like cheese and pepperoni, Tony C's serves specialty pies such as eggplant, prosciutto and goat cheese, and the Truffle Shuffle. (Courtesy Tony C's Pizza & Beer Garden)
Restaurant Tony C's to open Sept. 24 in Round Rock and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

(Graphic illustration by Rachal Russel/Community Impact Newspaper)
From New Braunfels to Cedar Park, Central Texas outdoor recreation shops scrambling to keep inventory

When combined with temporary state restrictions due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many local shop owners are speculating a perfect storm of low supply and high demand is the main reason for changes in an industry that has of late been turned on its head.

Austin ISD teachers have been able to teach virtually from their classrooms to start the school year. Some students will return to the classroom Oct. 5. (Courtesy Austin ISD)
Austin ISD teachers adjust to virtual learning as in-person demands approach

Austin ISD teachers and principals discuss the first few weeks of virtual learning.

Early voting runs from Oct. 13-30. Election Day is Nov. 3. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Find a polling location where you can vote early in Travis County

Voters can cast their ballots at any of the 37 early voting locations from Oct. 13-30.

Mercury Hall will close in 2021. (Courtesy Mercury Hall)
Mercury Hall property cleared for 5-story apartment development

Mercury Hall will close after 2021, and a dense multifamily development is set to arrive in its wake.

Buddy's Burger is open in Northeast Austin off of Cameron Road. (Courtesy Buddy's Burger)
Now open in Austin: Party Barn is back, drive-in movies downtown, burgers in North Austin and more

Blue Starlite began showing drive-in movies downtown in September. Buddy's Burger is open off Cameron Road and planning to expand to more locations, and new bar High Noon is open on the east side.

City Post is located at 113 E. Eighth St., Georgetown. (Courtesy City Post)
Georgetown to get steakhouse, speakeasy plus more Central Texas news

Read the latest Central Texas business and community news.

Easy Tiger announced Sept. 18 it had closed its downtown Austin location on Sixth Street. (Courtesy Easy Tiger)
Easy Tiger announces permanent closure of original Sixth Street location

The local bakery and restaurant remains open at the Linc and still plans to open in South Austin.

A photo of a "sold" sign
Central Austin August housing market numbers show high dollar-volume sales

While housing inventory remains low, home prices continue to rise.