South Austin developer sues city in ongoing saga to improve permitting process

Photo of new construction in process
With housing in short supply in Austin, developers are taking aim at inefficiencies in city permitting. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)

With housing in short supply in Austin, developers are taking aim at inefficiencies in city permitting. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)

Permitting efficiency in the city of Austin has long been a controversial issue. Since national consulting firm Zucker Systems released an 800-page report in 2015 calling for comprehensive reform of Austin’s Planning and Development Review Department, the city has taken steps to configure a new Austin Development Services Department and streamline permitting processes by adding an expedited review option. However, developers still complain about slow and complicated permitting experiences—including Chris Paladino, who recently filed a lawsuit against the city alleging an intentional violation of a bill aimed at curbing permitting inefficiencies.

Paladino is suing the city for allegedly circumventing Texas House Bill 3167, a 2019 law that requires permitting entities to approve or deny site plan and plat applications for subdivision projects within 30 days. Paladino’s application to subdivide one half-acre lot in South Austin was filed in November 2019, but the city has yet to officially begin the review of Paladino’s application, first sending it through a “preapplication check” process that has lasted nearly a year.

“Eleven months later and I have nothing. I do not have an approval or denial or conditional approval. What I have got are a dozen emails from the city saying, ‘Oh, we’re reviewing it against code,’” Paladino told Community Impact Newspaper.

Before HB 3167 passed in 2019, it took an average of around 37 days for Austin to complete a single round of permitting—not limited to subdivision permits. Often, several more rounds ensued to address issues pointed out by multiple departments.

“I was hopeful that the city would look at this and say, ‘There's no way. There is no amount of staff we could hire to do all of the reviews we want to do in 30 days. We're going to have to make the process simpler,” Paladino said.


Representatives for the development services department did not specifically respond to Community Impact Newspaper’s questions regarding Paladino’s case, but Robbie Searcy, the public information specialist for the department, said the preapplication check process “is intended to help developers identify potential complications that need to be addressed prior to submittal.”

Additionally, Searcy said the department was “proud of its collaborative work with the regulated community to achieve compliance with HB 3167.”

Other Austin development professionals expressed similar concerns to Paladino’s. Chris Peterson of Riverdale Homes said his experiences with the city have led him to adjust his business practices to avoid the most cumbersome parts of the permitting process for large subdivision projects.

“We're building in the city of Austin, but we look for other opportunities where we don't have to process maps and spend the time or the money to do that. We let other people do it and take the headache and buy it after it's been processed, or we'll just buy individual lots,” Peterson said.

Ultimately, a slow permitting process impacts more than just developers, according to David Glenn, the senior director of government relations for the Home Builders Association of Greater Austin. He said the city’s permitting process “is absolutely a barrier to housing [supply],” which is at a critically low point in 2020 and is playing a role in driving up costs for homebuyers.

“There's a lot of nexuses between the permitting process and affordability,” Glenn said. “One of our biggest concerns is just the timeliness in which we hear what the errors are in the plan. Just having that open communication is sometimes difficult to achieve.”

Greater efficiency in permitting would not only make developers’ jobs easier, Glenn said, but would also benefit the city by getting housing—and thus additional tax dollars and accompanying infrastructure—online sooner.

“There are always efficiencies that can be gained. But the problem is it's sometimes difficult for cities to identify and then realize these inefficiencies and then take action to correct them,” Glenn said. “I think that’s a good discussion that the city needs to have with the development community.”
By Olivia Aldridge
Olivia is the reporter for Community Impact's Central Austin edition. A graduate of Presbyterian College in upstate South Carolina, Olivia was a reporter and producer at South Carolina Public Radio before joining Community Impact in Austin.


MOST RECENT

Q2 Stadium in North Austin
U.S. women’s national soccer team to debut Q2 Stadium next month

The USWNT takes on the Nigerian national team at Q2 Stadium ahead of the summer Olympic Games.

Juneau was adopted at Austin Animal Center in November 2019. (Amy Rae Dadamo/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Animal Center reaches critical capacity, opens doors to all adopters for first time since May 2020

Austin and Travis County’s animal shelter, Austin Animal Center, reached negative kennel space May 4, meaning there are more dogs than available kennels, according to a release from the city of Austin.

Residential appraisal valuations have been sent to Travis County property owners. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Travis Central Appraisal Districts says hot housing market is reflected in 2021 appraisals

Property owners have until May 17 to file a protest of their home's appraisal.

Photo of the exterior of La Barbecue
La Barbecue opens new space, plus six more new Austin restaurants

Downtown Italian and Greek eateries are among those joining the Austin restaurant scene this spring.

The Austin City Council is set to meet May 6 to go over a 70-item agenda. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Hall notebook: Votes on revamped APD cadet academy, possible shift in homeless strategy on tap May 6

Council may look to the possibility of establishing designated campgrounds for the Austin's homeless this spring, with a citywide public camping ban set to go into effect May 11.

Austin City Council will vote on whether to reboot the police department's training academy May 6. (Courtesy Austin Police Department)
Benchmarks for 'reimagined' APD cadet academy on track ahead of City Council commencement vote

Training of the Austin Police Department's 144th cadet class could get underway next month following an overhaul of the academy's instructional process and curriculum.

Ryan Companies will be building 350 homes near the Mueller control tower. (Rendering courtesy Lake Flato Architects)
Coming soon to Austin: Vaquero Taquero adding a downtown location, Komé opening at the airport, Mueller to add 350 homes and more

A new ice cream shop is also opening in East Austin and an apartment project is being built near House Park.

Photo of a gloved hand holding a vaccine vial with the words "vaccine news" superimposed
Austin-area health officials prep for vaccines to open to kids 12 and up

Austin-Travis County interim Health Authority Mark Escott said he expects the FDA to authorize Pfizer's vaccine for kids 12 and up within a week.

New penalties for camping and several other activities will be enforced after the May 1 election is certified and Proposition B's homeless ordinances are in effect. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
With Proposition B's passage, Austin City Council looks to solidify homelessness summit goals, may consider designated campgrounds

The city may look to the concept of temporary designated campsites to house individuals experiencing homelessness after a new camping ban enacted through Proposition B goes into effect.

Photo of hands in purple gloves prepared a vaccine vial
As Travis County receives fewer vaccines this week, state asks for 'one more big push' in distribution

The Texas Department of State Health Services is shifting its distribution model for vaccines moving forward.