Travis County commissioners consider cost of public defender's office in light of revenue caps

State lawmakers' plan to implement revenue caps has threatened municipal government spending, including a plan in Travis County to establish a public defender's office.

State lawmakers' plan to implement revenue caps has threatened municipal government spending, including a plan in Travis County to establish a public defender's office.

After more than seven months of development, a plan to create a public defender’s office in Travis County is coming up against state lawmakers’ pledge to pass property tax revenue caps.

"Unfortunately in this state and all across the South—all across the country, actually—you only get the justice you can afford," said Travis County Commissioner Jeff Travillion, who represents Precinct 1, at an April 30 meeting.

The county plans to apply for a state grant that would cover around half of the costs of a public defender’s office over four years, up to $20.3 million. The deadline for the grant application is May 10.

If the county is awarded the grant, however, it will assume full financial responsibility for the office when the grant runs out.

Starting in fiscal year 2024, the Travis County Commissioners Court would need to fund the office, which would cost $10.1 million annually, according to an analysis submitted to commissioners April 18 by Katie Petersen, senior planning and budget analyst for Travis County.

“Unfortunately, the timing is a little bit of a challenge dealing with revenue caps,” Budget Director Travis Gatlin said.

State lawmakers in both chambers of the Legislature have made property tax reform a key priority this session.

Senate Bill 2 passed April 15 and restricts local governments—including counties—from increasing their property tax revenue by more than 3.5% year-over-year. The House considered its version of the bill April 30 but has not yet voted on it.

“There is about to be a day of reckoning with budgets,” said Commissioner Gerald Daugherty, who represents Precinct 3.

Despite uncertainty about the county’s ability to fund future projects, most members of the Commissioners Court remain committed to creating a public defender’s office.

“Ultimately, at the end of the day, we figure out the formula, and we figure out the particulars as we go,” Travillion said. “But I think it is critical and important to build this system with these resources, and it is a little embarrassing to be the largest metropolitan area in the entire country that has not figured out that we need to do this."

Commissioner Margaret Gomez, who represents Precinct 4, also supports funding the new office, although she acknowledged that doing so would likely require cutting funding for other programs.

“Let’s get tough, and let’s make some cuts to make room for it,” she said.

The state of Texas mandates counties provide defense for indigent defendants—those who are unable to afford a private attorney—but provides little funding for them to do so.

On average, the state provides around 13% of counties’ indigent defense budgets, according to the Texas Indigent Defense Commission.

In Travis County, however, the state funded only 5% of indigent defense costs in FY 2018, per Petersen's analysis.

The grant, which is awarded by the TIDC, would significantly increase the state’s contribution to indigent defense spending in Travis County, if only for a four-year period.

“I do not want to leave $20 million of state money on the table,” County Judge Sarah Eckhardt said. “We can definitely use that money.”

The Commissioners Court will vote on the final grant application May 7.
By Emma Freer
Emma Freer began covering Central Austin for Community Impact Newspaper in 2017. Her beat includes the Travis County Commissioners Court and local business news. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School in 2017.


The Office of Police Oversight released its first comprehensive report detailing its operations though 2019 and 2020 this June. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Office of Police Oversight report finds complaints against Austin police officers went up, but discipline fell in 2020

The new report centers on the office's three main functions, including tracking APD officer discipline, reviewing the city's police policies, and engaging with Austin residents.

Dreamland adding a disc golf course to its Dripping Springs outdoor entertainment and arts offerings in June. (Courtesy Dreamland)
Dripping Springs and Driftwood business news: Dreamland gets disc golf, new dog grooming business gets closer to opening and more

The new disc golf course at the outdoor entertainment venue sits on 42 acres and is free to play through June.

Volunteers of Austin Vaccine Angels gathered after becoming fully vaccinated. (Courtesy Jodi Holzband)
Grassroots groups aimed at vaccine outreach look toward the future

For the past five months, grassroots volunteer groups have been working to connect thousands of Central Texans to COVID-19 vaccines.

Washington Prime Group Inc. owns six area shopping centers, including The Arboretum. (Courtesy The Arboretum)
Owner of Austin-area shopping centers files for bankruptcy; entertainment complex coming to Cedar Park and more top area news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from the Central Texas area.

Photo of a woman and girl walking the trail with the Austin skyline behind them
Travis County commits to electrify fleet, doubles down on climate goals

Commissioners directed staff this week to develop a plan to fully electrify Travis County's fleet of vehicles, a leading source of greenhouse gas emissions for the county.

The Bloomhouse—an 1,100-square-foot home in the hills of West Austin—was built in the 1970s by University of Texas architecture students for fellow student Dalton Bloom. It was featured in the Austin Weird Homes Tour of 2020. (Brian Perdue/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Weird Homes Tour ends; Z’Tejas to close Arboretum restaurant and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Central Texas area.

Project Connect's proposed Orange Line will run from Tech Ridge, through downtown Austin and to Slaughter Lane. (Rendering courtesy Project Connect)
Project Connect Orange Line design reveals proposed locations for rail stations in North, South Austin

The latest Orange Line design shows potential elevated rail line over I-35, as well as options for the Drag.

Photo of a weird home
Austin's Weird Homes Tour says goodbye—for now

The tour's founders say they are open to a new local operator taking over the event.

The former hotel off I-35 had most recently been used as a COVID-19 homeless Protection Lodge. (Courtesy City of Austin)
East Cesar Chavez encampment residents move into former South Austin hotel

Through Austin's HEAL initiative, residents of an encampment near East Austin's Terrazas Branch Libarary were relocated to a South Austin shelter before that camp is cleared away.

The regional blood bank appealed for further donations in the wake of the June 12 shooting in downtown Austin. (Courtesy We Are Blood)
We Are Blood appeals for blood donations following weekend shooting in downtown Austin

The Central Texas nonprofit also said its blood supply remains depleted due to decreased donations through the COVID-19 pandemic.

Photo of a man holding robotic equipment
Tesla teams up with Austin Community College for manufacturing training and hiring program

The Tesla START program will hire and train ACC students to work with robotics and other advanced manufacturing equipment.

Austin City Council's Housing and Planning Committee met virtually June 15. (Screenshot via City of Austin)
Austin City Council members, city Realtors talk housing market increases and affordability

The median sale price of Austin homes surged past $500,000 through the first five months of 2021.