Travis County commissioners push back against proposed rollback tax rate, advocate for school finance reform

Travis County Commissioners are against a proposed rollback tax rate of 2.5 percent, which state lawmakers have introduced as a priority item for the 86th Legislature.

Travis County Commissioners are against a proposed rollback tax rate of 2.5 percent, which state lawmakers have introduced as a priority item for the 86th Legislature.

Travis County commissioners voted unanimously to approve a resolution pushing back against a property tax revenue cap proposed by state lawmakers at its Feb. 19 meeting. Precinct 3 Commissioner Gerald Daugherty was not in attendance.

State lawmakers introduced bills in both chambers of the Legislature on Jan. 31 that would restrict local governments, including counties, from increasing their property tax revenue by more than 2.5 percent year-over-year.

Such a cap is referred to as a rollback tax rate because if a taxing entity exceeds that rate, a rollback election is triggered, giving voters the chance to approve or reject the proposed increase.

“Arbitrarily lowering the rollback rate produces modest savings for taxpayers with significant loss of county revenue,” said Deece Eckstein, intergovernmental relations officer for Travis County, during a presentation to the Commissioners Court.

If such a cap had been in place this fiscal year, Eckstein said, the average homestead owner in Travis County would have saved approximately $33.34, but the county would have lost nearly $18 million in revenue.

“Of course, we would have to consider across-the-board cuts of services,” Eckstein said of the proposed cap, adding it would also be hard for the county to build its reserves, which are necessary for funding long-term projects, and likely lead to costly elections if the court ever proposed a tax rate that exceeded the rollback rate.

Unlike cities and other municipalities, counties are funded almost entirely by property taxes and lack other sources of revenue, such as sales taxes.

The proposed cap, Eckstein said, would also make it difficult for the county to fund the services for which it is responsible.

For example, the state mandates that counties provide indigent criminal and civil defense services but does not provide funding to do so. In FY 2019, these services will cost Travis County nearly $24 million.

County Judge Sarah Eckhardt acknowledged there is an affordability issue in the city of Austin and Travis County but pointed out Texas has a relatively low tax burden compared to other states.

Indeed, a study by the Tax Foundation found during the years 1997 and 2012, Texas ranked 46th in the nation for combined state and local tax burden.

“I blanch at the idea that we are being crushed by our tax burden in Texas, especially if we are middle-income or above,” Eckhardt said.

Commissioners and county staff agreed property tax relief is intrinsically tied to school finance reform, which the proposed cap does not address.

“That’s really the crunch that people are feeling,” Eckstein said, pointing to data that shows Travis County residents pay more in property taxes that are recaptured by the state and distributed to other school districts than to the city of Austin or Travis County.

Recapture is a state policy that is often referred to as "Robin Hood" because it sends money from property-wealthy districts, such as in Austin ISD, to property-poor districts.

In the 2018-19 school year, the state of Texas will recapture more than half of the tax revenue Austin ISD collects from local property owners, totaling an estimated $672.9 million.

"These are our local property taxes, and they are being taken to the tune of a very substantial amount of money ... from our local property taxes for an obligation that the Texas Constitution very clearly says is the state's responsibility," Precinct 2 Commissioner Brigid Shea said.

“There can be no meaningful tax relief for Travis County voters unless the Legislature fixes the broken school finance system," Eckstein said.
By Emma Freer
Emma Freer began covering Central Austin for Community Impact Newspaper in 2017. Her beat includes the Travis County Commissioners Court and local business news. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School in 2017.


MOST RECENT

A photo of a finger-prick test being administered
Victory Medical now offers 10-minute coronavirus tests

The new finger-prick test gives results in a few minutes.

(Designed by Mel Stefka/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin-area health care centers receive more than $7 million from CARES Act

Three Austin-area nonprofit health care centers have been awarded federal grants totaling more than $7 million for coronavirus relief.

A photo of Walnut Springs Elementary School
Dripping Springs ISD extends registration period for kindergarten and pre-K students

First-time students now have until May 1 to be registered for kindergarten and pre-K.

At an April 8 press conference, Dr. Mark Escott, the Austin Public Health interim health authority, said emergency backup medical facilities will open soon in case local hospitals are not able to provide enough space for coronavirus patients. (Courtesy ATXN)
Austin, Travis County officials planning for up to 1.7 million coronavirus cases, 9,000 deaths in metro

Emergency backup medical facilities will open in case local hospitals are not able to provide enough space for patients who contract the coronavirus.

Many of the city's outdoor amenities, such as Barton Springs Pool, have already been shut down. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin mayor considering shutting down parks and trails to further social distancing measures

The city's parks and trails will already be shut down through the holiday weekend.

Austin Community College classes will be held online this summer. (Courtesy Austin Community College)
Austin Community College to move scheduled summer courses online

The announcement comes one week after the district announced it would close its campuses through at least May 31.

A photo of a man in a red shirt and black hat standing in a video rental store
After 35 years in Austin, Vulcan Video says goodbye

After weathering rent hikes and industry shifts, the classic Austin video rental store has closed in response to the business effects of COVID-19.

Nearly half of Central Texas residents have completed the 2020 census as of April 6, U.S. Census Bureau data shows. (Graphic by Community Impact staff)
Nearly half of Central Texas residents have completed the census so far

The census is available in 13 languages online and over the phone, and the print version is available in 59 languages.

Austin's and Travis County's orders went into place March 25 and require residents to stay home for everything but essential travel. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin looks to lease 3 hotels in $3.6 million coronavirus shelter plan

The hotels are being used for coronavirus patients and members of vulnerable communities who cannot safely isolate on their own.

Projections from University of Texas researchers say continued social distancing is working. (Screenshot courtesy University of Texas at Austin)
UPDATED: UT projections say continued social distancing is working

Coronavirus demand projections released by The University of Texas at Austin on April 6 show that cases in the Austin-Round Rock metropolitan statistical area could vary from 6,000 to 1.7 million based on the effectiveness of social distancing.

Austin and Travis County adopted new guidelines, recommending local residents wear face masks or fabric covering when out in public. (Christopher Neely/Community impact Newspaper)
5 coronavirus stories Austin-area readers might have missed

Readers might have missed the following five coronavirus-related stories.

(Graphic by Mel Stefka/Community Impact Newspaper)
Animal adoption, foster numbers up as Austin community comes together to support shelters

Austin animal shelters reported increases in animal foster applications, adoptions and intakes.