Rental homes becoming unaffordable

Rental homes becoming unaffordable Central Austin rental facts[/caption]

Single-family rental homes are becoming increasingly unaffordable for Central Austin renters, forcing more moderate-income residents into apartments—or outside the central core entirely.


The average Central Austin rental home costs $2,232 per month, according to 2015 first-quarter MLS Listings data. During that same three-month timeframe, apartments were leased for $1,137 per month on average. Rental homes and other non-apartments made up only 1.5 percent of the 28,061 Central Austin units leased during that time.

The average Central Austin renter earns approximately $33,827 annually, or nearly three times less than homeowners living in the same area, according to American Community Survey five-year research data. That makes most Central Austin homes and apartments out of reach for the average renter, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, which measures affordability by whether a resident is “housing cost burdened,” or someone who spends 30 percent or more of his or her income on housing.

The debate on market-rate affordable housing was recently revived as part of an effort to reduce regulations for accessory dwelling units, or secondary units built on single-family properties. Mark Rogers, executive director of the Guadalupe Neighborhood Development Corp., sounded the alarms during an April 14 panel discussion about ADUs.

“The danger I see in Austin, single-family homes are going extinct in Austin very quickly, and the low- to moderate-income [residents] are disappearing in the city,” said Rogers, whose organization helps East Austin residents obtain affordable housing. “It’s a crisis, in my mind.”

He touted ADUs as a viable, more affordable option for renters. They are also better alternatives than living in large-scale apartment complexes, Rogers said in a followup interview.

“Living in a home represents the essence of what Austin is, and we need to try to maintain that,” he said.

However, members of the advocacy group Austin Neighborhood Council have voiced opposition to relaxed ADU requirements. ANC President Mary Ingle, who also spoke on the April 14 panel, later said that smaller units only serve developers and not residents who need affordable housing.

“People who already live here need to stand up,” Ingle said. “This city is being built for the people who are moving here—and not for the people who live here now.”

Meet in the middle


City of Austin renters are nearly two times more likely than homeowners to be housing cost burdened, based on data released in May from Community Advancement Network, or CAN, a nonprofit coalition that tracks Austin’s social issues. That difference could be attributed to rising rental rates, which increased 50 percent between 2004 and 2013, according to the Real Estate Council of Austin, while median annual family incomes increased only 9 percent.

[polldaddy poll=8895112]

The ongoing CodeNEXT process seeks to allow more “missing middle housing” by rewriting Austin’s land development code. The missing middle housing concept was coined by Dan Parolek, principal of OpticosDesign, the consulting firm hired by Austin to rewrite the code.

His new website outlines the duplexes, triplexes, fourplexes, courtyard apartments, bungalow courts, townhomes and live-work units needed to help fill the housing gap between detached single-family homes and mid-rise apartment complexes.

“Missing middle housing types may likely end up being rentals to help meet that local demand,” Parolek said.

But the CodeNEXT process risks ruining years of effort by 30 neighborhood planning teams that created their own development standards, ANC Vice President Joyce Basciano said. For example, her Bryker Woods neighborhood plan took 3 1/2 years to complete, she said. Basciano also said she is reluctant to further densify Central Austin, recommending instead the city draw inspiration from New York City and other places that have multiple high-activity points.

“Otherwise, we wind up with the core of the city being as expensive as Manhattan,” Basciano said.

The focus should be less on density, Parolek said, and more on neighborhood compatibility. The code rewrite process will still offer neighborhoods the tools needed to ensure only compatible housing is constructed, he said.

“Some communities fear a blanket application of all missing middle types to all neighborhoods, but that won’t be the case,” Parolek said. “The process will be much more targeted.”

Parking problems


Neighborhood advocates also expressed discomfort with relaxed parking requirements proposed for ADUs. A city proposal would reduce ADU parking requirements from two to one off-street parking space—and zero should the unit be 550 square feet or less. Similarly, Parolek said no living unit should be required to have more than one-and-a-half parking spaces, on average, and ideally no more than one space.

“Parking is going to be controversial—reducing parking always is,” he said. “We would have to spend a lot of time with communities educating about the pluses and minuses of keeping parking requirements high.”

Unfortunately, most Austinites still live in car-dependent households, said Mandy De Mayo, executive director of housing advocacy group Housing Works and a CodeNEXT advisory group member. Development regulations could help change that habit, she said.
“Parking is a major cost in any development,” De Mayo said, suggesting that cost gets passed to the end user. “It’s frustrating because we’re trying to get to a place where we’re a more walkable city.”

Ingle and Basciano said any reduction in parking requirements will not deter residents from using vehicles. Ingle cited her own experience managing an ADU.
“My garage apartment tenants always say they have one car and then show up with two cars every time,” Ingle said.

Other barriers to ADUs


ADUs can also increase property values, both on-site and for surrounding homeowners, according to the Travis Central Appraisal District. That has caused a great deal of angst among neighborhood residents, De Mayo said.

“People are very interested in ADUs theoretically,” she said. “But when they realize [ADUs] would be in their immediate neighborhood, then it just really riles people up.”

During an April 28 city of Austin Planning Commission meeting, multiple speakers voiced opposition to ADUs and asked to have their neighborhood “opt out” should any decreased regulations gain approval. However, city staff said  they were against that idea.

“Each neighborhood area that has a neighborhood plan—about 30—would have to go through the process and decide yes or no, and then the neighborhood plan would have to be amended to include this option, and all 30 of those would have to go through City Council,” said Ming-ru Chu, the city’s urban planner who drafted the proposed ADU regulations.

The Planning Commission on May  26—after Community Impact Newspaper’s print deadline—considered regulations that would enable neighborhoods to opt out and would limit Type 2 short-term rentals, a prohibition Chu said she embraces. The proposal, which comes to City Council on June 18 for a potential vote, also requires space for one additional vehicle regardless of the size of an ADU.

Only 240 ADUs were constructed between 2007 and mid-2014, according to Chu, despite more than 46,000 zoned properties that are potentially eligible.
“I think reducing the parking and getting rid of the driveway requirement would free up a whole lot of people to build ADUs,” Chu said. “The problem is I don’t know how they would finance it.”

Ingle said the revenue made from her garage apartment is sometimes not enough to pay off her property taxes. Most property owners would need a loan to afford construction costs, Chu and Ingle agreed. Some ADU advocates have proposed creating a city-funded financing program to encourage construction of the secondary units.

“I think we should at least start having those conversations if we really want to build ADUs,” Chu said.
By Joe Lanane
Joe Lanane’s career is rooted in community journalism, having worked for a variety of Midwest-area publications before landing south of the Mason-Dixon line in 2011 as the Stillwater News-Press news editor. He arrived at Community Impact Newspaper in 2012, gaining experience as editor of the company’s second-oldest publication in Leander/Cedar Park. He eventually became Central Austin editor, covering City Hall and the urban core of the city. Lanane leveraged that experience to become Austin managing editor in 2016. He managed eight Central Texas editions from Georgetown to San Marcos. Working from company headquarters, Lanane also became heavily involved in enacting corporate-wide editorial improvements. In 2017, Lanane was promoted to executive editor, overseeing editorial operations throughout the company. The Illinois native received his bachelor’s degree from Western Illinois University and his journalism master’s degree from Ball State University.


MOST RECENT

Brooke Elementary School is closing after the 2019-20 school year. (Photo by Jack Flagler, design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)
Pease, Brooke elementary school communities seek closure from a distance

Both schools will close permanently at the end of the school year. On May 28, Brooke and Pease held rolling parades to say goodbye.

Outdoor venues in all Texas counties will be permitted to operate at up to 25% capacity starting May 31. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Spectators to be welcomed back to Texas outdoor sporting events May 31 at 25% of venue capacity

Venue owners must operate under guidelines that facilitate appropriate social distancing.

Each eligible child will receive $285 in benefits. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Some Texas students eligible for one-time federal benefit to aid with food purchases

Texas received approval from the U.S. Department of Agriculture to provide more than $1 billion in pandemic food benefits.

Zilker Theatre Productions announced May 28 that its summer musical, "Mamma Mia," has been postponed to 2021. (Courtesy Zilker Theatre Production)
Zilker Theatre Productions postpones summer musical to 2021

This will be the first time the free outdoor show in Zilker Park has not run since it began in 1959.

A screen shot of Dr. Mark Escott speaking
Austin Public Health planning response in case of coronavirus hospitalization spike

As local health authorities monitor an upward trend in COVID-19 cases, they are bracing for a possible uptick in hospitalizations.

There have been 1,084 total coronavirus recoveries in Travis County as of May 27. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Travis County reports 73 new coronavirus cases May 27

There have been 1,084 total coronavirus recoveries in Travis County as well.

East Austin bar La Holly opened a pop-up on West Sixth Street at Key Bar on May 22. (Courtesy Summer Madeline)
La Holly opens pop-up on West Sixth Street at Key Bar

East Austin bar La Holly opened a pop-up on West Sixth Street at Key Bar on May 22.

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar spoke to members of the Clear Lake Area Chamber of Commerce on May 27 about what the state's post-pandemic economic turnaround might look like. (Screenshot of May 27 virtual luncheon)
Texas comptroller predicts slow, steady economic turnaround post-pandemic

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar said the state entered the era of the coronavirus in a healthy financial situation, which bodes well for the future as reopening continues, but that Texans are not out of the woods yet.

Traffic on toll roads operated by the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority has steadily climbed over the last two months after nosediving in March. (Amy Denney/Community Impact Newspaper)
As economic restrictions loosen, some Central Texas toll roads are beginning to fill up with traffic

Traffic counts on roads operated by the Central Texas Regional Mobility Authority have consistently climbed since early April.

Nursing facilities across Texas will be able to apply for federal funds to purchase devices to connect residents to friends and family. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Gov. Greg Abbott announces $3.6 million project to connect nursing home residents to families

Gov. Greg Abbott announced May 27 that $3.6 million will be provided to nursing facilities to purchase tablets, webcams and headphones to connect residents with family members.

Amie Gonser will open 620 Art Gallery & Studio in June as a fine art gallery and space for art education classes. (Courtesy Amie Gonser)
IMPACTS ROUNDUP: News on 20 Central Texas businesses and nonprofits

Read about Central Texas business news from Community Impact Newspaper's coverage this week.

A new executive has been brought in to fill leadership roles at the University of Texas at Austin Dell Medical School and Dell Children’s Medical Center. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Dell Children’s Medical Center, Dell Medical School announce new addition to executive team

A new medical executive has been brought in to fill leadership roles at Dell Medical School and Dell Children’s Medical Center.