New Travis County Public Defender's Office aims for better legal outcomes

The Travis County Juvenile Public Defender's Office currently represents around 70% of juvenile defendants. Sources: Texas Indigent Defense Commission, Travis County Juvenile Public Defender’s Office/Community Impact Newspaper
The Travis County Juvenile Public Defender's Office currently represents around 70% of juvenile defendants. Sources: Texas Indigent Defense Commission, Travis County Juvenile Public Defender’s Office/Community Impact Newspaper

The Travis County Juvenile Public Defender's Office currently represents around 70% of juvenile defendants. Sources: Texas Indigent Defense Commission, Travis County Juvenile Public Defender’s Office/Community Impact Newspaper

Image description
More than 93% of adults booked at the Travis County Jail are screened to determine bond eligibility and income. People who cannot afford to hire an attorney are constitutionally entitled to one. Photos by Emma Freer/Community Impact Newspaper and courtesy Travis County Pretrial Services, Travis County Sheriff’s Office
Image description
Sources: Council of State Governments Justice Center; “The Effects of Holistic Defense on Criminal Justice Outcomes,” Harvard Law Review; Texas Indigent Defense Commission; Travis County Commissioners Court; Travis County Jail Population Monitoring Group; Travis County Juvenile Public Defender Office; Travis County Mental Health Public Defender Office; Travis County Pretrial Services/Community Impact Newspaper
Image description
Sources: Council of State Governments Justice Center; “The Effects of Holistic Defense on Criminal Justice Outcomes,” Harvard Law Review; Texas Indigent Defense Commission; Travis County Commissioners Court; Travis County Jail Population Monitoring Group; Travis County Juvenile Public Defender Office; Travis County Mental Health Public Defender Office; Travis County Pretrial Services/Community Impact Newspaper
Image description
Sources: Council of State Governments Justice Center; “The Effects of Holistic Defense on Criminal Justice Outcomes,” Harvard Law Review; Texas Indigent Defense Commission; Travis County Commissioners Court; Travis County Jail Population Monitoring Group; Travis County Juvenile Public Defender Office; Travis County Mental Health Public Defender Office; Travis County Pretrial Services/Community Impact Newspaper
Image description
Sources: Council of State Governments Justice Center; “The Effects of Holistic Defense on Criminal Justice Outcomes,” Harvard Law Review; Texas Indigent Defense Commission; Travis County Commissioners Court; Travis County Jail Population Monitoring Group; Travis County Juvenile Public Defender Office; Travis County Mental Health Public Defender Office; Travis County Pretrial Services/Community Impact Newspaper
Image description
Sources: Council of State Governments Justice Center; “The Effects of Holistic Defense on Criminal Justice Outcomes,” Harvard Law Review; Texas Indigent Defense Commission; Travis County Commissioners Court; Travis County Jail Population Monitoring Group; Travis County Juvenile Public Defender Office; Travis County Mental Health Public Defender Office; Travis County Pretrial Services/Community Impact Newspaper
On a sunny Wednesday afternoon in November, a 15-year-old boy was escorted into a windowless courtroom. He had been staying at the Gardner Betts Detention Center, just off South Congress Avenue, and was there for his arraignment.

Like 97% of children ages 10 to 16 charged with a crime in Travis County, he was unable to afford a lawyer and was therefore represented by the juvenile public defender’s office.

Because of legislative efforts by the office, the boy is guaranteed counsel and attends hearings unshackled. His lawyer is paid similarly to those in the district attorney’s office.

Most adults charged with crimes in Travis County are also unable to afford an attorney, but they lack the same protections. In fiscal year 2017-18, the county found nearly three in four screened defendants to be indigent, or unable to afford an attorney. The threshold for indigence is 125% of the federal poverty line, or $15,612.50 in annual income for an individual.

But Austin is the largest city in the country without a public defender’s office to serve them. Instead, indigent clients are represented by contracted attorneys paid a flat fee—$600 for a typical felony case, less for a misdemeanor.


The median hourly rate for full-time private attorneys in 2017 was $281, per the Texas Bar Journal.

This system incentivizes attorneys to take on as many cases as possible, data shows.

According to state-commissioned guidelines, attorneys should carry no more than 236 misdemeanors or 174 felonies annually.

In 2018, one appointed attorney took on 628 cases, per the Texas Indigent Defense Commission. One in seven exceeded the maximum caseload of 236; nearly all had a mixture of misdemeanors and felonies.

“What’s different, I think, about Austin is that a significant part of the criminal defense community has a business model [in which] court appointments are an integral part,” said Kameron Johnson, director of the juvenile public defender’s office.

In contrast is the DA’s office, which hires salaried attorneys. Last year, the average caseload was 236.

“I don’t think that anyone would think that we could run a DA’s office better if we contracted that out,” Johnson said.

Things are starting to change, however.

In August, the county received a $48 million state grant—the largest ever awarded by the TIDC—to create a public defender’s office.

Advocates said the office will better serve defendants because its staff can build legal expertise, share resources and respond to oversight in ways that individual contractors cannot.

When the grant expires in 2024, Travis County will have a 67-person staff—about two-thirds attorneys—taking on 30% of indigent cases. The remainder will continue to be appointed private attorneys.

In search of a culture

In late September, the Travis County Commissioners Court tasked a 12-member oversight group—made up of legal professionals, local advocates and community leaders—with finding a chief public defender.

“With a brand-new office, the person that you hire is really going to have both the administrative and bureaucratic skills to get all your workplace processes and workflows [in place],” said Chito Vela, a criminal and immigration defense attorney who is a member of the group. “But then on the other hand we also want somebody who has the softer qualities.”

These include compassion and leadership skills.

“Being a lawyer is completely different than managing and motivating a whole office full of different people,” said Melissa McRoy Shearer, director of the Travis County Mental Health Public Defender’s Office, which represents adults with serious mental illnesses.

The group finalized a job description Oct. 15 and expects to interview candidates by December.

Once hired, the new chief will need to build not only a staff but also a culture.

While the county was in the process of developing its proposal for state funding, some local criminal defense attorneys and criminal court judges pushed back against the new office, which they argued could threaten the existing system of appointments.

“It’s creating this new culture that doesn’t exist now,” said Maria Emerson, a member of Advocates for Social Justice Reform, or ASJR, a local organization that helped mediate the proposal drafting process. “It’s us and them, where we’re trying to really make it a we.”

Investing in public defense

Public defenders are salaried and have caseload limits guided by American Bar Association standards.

These limits allow public defense attorneys to do more than just triage cases, Shearer said, and instead spend time with each client.

A centralized public defender’s office can also better identify trends and strategies.

“A private attorney coming into the courtroom may do one or two cases a year,” said Bradley Temple, an associate juvenile court judge. “They’re not going to develop that expertise and that specialization, nor are they going to form those relationships [with district attorneys and judges] that are really important.”

Public defenders also have more resources, including staff investigators and social workers.

In the mental health public defender’s office, staff meet twice a week to review ongoing cases, Shearer said. Teams of public defenders and social workers talk through their strategies and solicit feedback from their colleagues.

When the new office is up and running, these benefits will also extend to private attorneys.

“We’ve always embraced and supported the private bar,” Johnson said. “Because of the specialization and the expertise that we have, they will come to us when they have these juvenile cases.”

Both Johnson and Shearer’s offices host continuing education and training, open to public defenders and private attorneys alike.

Alex Bunin is the chief of the Harris County public defender’s office, which he helped found in 2011, as well as a member of the oversight group.

A 2013 evaluation by the Council of State Governments Justice Center found that the Harris County Public Defender’s Office saw better outcomes than assigned and retained attorneys.

This year, nearly 60% of the office’s felony clients were acquitted, dismissed or avoided a custody sentence, Bunin said via email.

Moving forward

The Travis County Public Defender’s Office will begin taking cases in 2021 and ramp up to representing 30% of indigent clients by 2024.

In the meantime, the chief public defender and oversight group will be tasked with building a system of checks and balances to make sure the new office fulfills its promise.

“I think one of the reasons why there was the disconnect [between advocates and private attorneys] early on is because anecdotes were substituted for data,” said Bob Batlan, a member of ASJR. “But until you have a measurement system, it’s all finger pointing.”

Additionally, members of the oversight group and advocates alike have expressed hope that the new office could eventually mirror the juvenile public defender’s office, which takes almost every indigent case—even as they acknowledge serious funding constraints and likely pushback from the private bar.

“My experience with [public defenders] is far superior representation,” said Rick Cofer, a criminal defense attorney who represents juveniles in cases where there is a conflict.

“You get what you pay for.”
By Emma Freer
Emma Freer began covering Central Austin for Community Impact Newspaper in 2017. Her beat includes the Travis County Commissioners Court and local business news. She graduated from Columbia Journalism School in 2017.


MOST RECENT

A tree with fallen branches has fallen on a car in North Austin in the midst of Winter Storm Uri.
Does your emergency repair need a city permit? Here is how you can find out

The city of Austin has directed additional funds into programs to help some homeowners with repairs following February's winter storm.

Photo of Judge Brown in a mask and orange vest with megaphone
Travis County and 3 Central Texas neighbors to pilot mass vaccination site

Some 3,000 people will be vaccinated at a drive-thru event at the Circuit of The Americas this weekend.

Austin Water has lifted its boil-water notice for the city of Austin. (Iain Oldman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Water lifts boil-water notice for all customers

Water quality tests have shown that city water is now safe to drink, and Austin Water continues to repair water mains and leaks.

Boil-water notices are still in place for some Austin residents. (Courtesy Pexels)
Austin dealing with ‘tens of thousands’ of water main breaks, officials say

Austin's water director said water main breaks during the winter storm were the likely culprit behind the draining of the city's reserves.

Photo of a desk with vials of Moderna vaccines on top
Austin Public Health resumes vaccinations, testing after weather-related delays

APH is currently in the process of rescheduling 3,300 vaccine appointments that were postponed beginning on Feb. 13.

Austin ISD staff at Pleasant Hill Elementary School distribute meals. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin ISD offering free meals to children and caregivers Feb. 25

Austin ISD is distributing meals at 33 campuses across the city of Austin.

Photo of cars driving in the snow
Travis County sees surge of 911 calls, emergencies during winter storm

Sheriff's Office patrollers also responded to heightened calls regarding vehicle collisions and distressed motorists.

Austin Resource Recovery resumed curbside pickup of items such as trash, recycling and composting Feb. 22. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Crews will collect extra material curbside for no charge as service resumes in Austin

On their scheduled days, customers can leave extra material, such as trash, recycling and composting, on the curb with no fees after winter storms caused delays in service.

Austin Water lifted its boil water notice for customers within its central pressure zone the morning of Feb. 22. (Amy Denney/Community Impact Newspaper)
Boil notice partially lifted in Austin, water service expected to be fully restored Feb. 22

Austin Water director Greg Meszaros said in a statement he expects service to be fully restored to all customers Feb. 22 and the boil notice to be fully lifted shortly thereafter.

Trees were covered in ice throughout Austin after freezing rain fell the night of Feb. 16. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin weekly roundup: This energy and water disaster won't be soon forgotten

As water service is slowly restored across the city, Austin remains under a boil notice and volunteers are handing out free cases of water to those in need.

building
Austin ISD cancels class Feb. 22-23, plans to go fully virtual through the rest of the week

The school district is planning to allow students who choose in-person classes to return to campuses March 1.