Shortened census timeline could shortchange Houston, its most vulnerable communities

The 2020 U.S. census response rate is already lagging behind 2010 numbers, and officials said the shortened timeline only increases the chances of an undercount. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
The 2020 U.S. census response rate is already lagging behind 2010 numbers, and officials said the shortened timeline only increases the chances of an undercount. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

The 2020 U.S. census response rate is already lagging behind 2010 numbers, and officials said the shortened timeline only increases the chances of an undercount. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)

Officials with the U.S. Census Bureau announced earlier this week that the deadline to complete the final census count was being moved from Oct. 31 to Sept. 30, reducing the amount of time to count every man, woman and child across the United States by one month.

Now, advocates with local civic engagement groups in Houston are warning the lost time could result in an undercount, which could shortchange the city by millions of dollars over the next decade with an especially detrimental effect for its most vulnerable communities.

"What you are seeing is something that is going to devastate our communities," said Nabila Mansoor, the census coordinator for Emgage USA who also co-chairs the Harris County/Houston Complete Count Committee. "Our plan was to work all the way until the end of October and make sure that we got to those historically undercounted populations that tend to be missed. By having it cut short by a month, what you’re going to find is there is going to be less outreach to those people that need it the most."

As of Aug. 5, the response rate in Harris County was at 57.6%, which is about 7% lower than the final response rate the last time the census was conducted in 2010. Mansoor said cities across the country are seeing the lowest response rates in recent memory, a likely side effect of the coronavirus pandemic.

Officials with the city of Houston have estimated missing 1% of the population in the count will result in the area losing $250 million over the next 10 years. For every single individual in Harris County who does not respond, Mansoor said, the county loses about $10,000 per year.


Over the course of the 2010 decade, the Houston area received about $101.6 billion in funding from federal spending programs as a result of the census count, including Title I grants, emergency response funding, and various employment and training grants, according to analysis by the Greater Houston Partnership.

While Emgage aims for a 100% response rate, Mansoor said the organization set a more realistic target of reaching 75% this year. She said that target is still their goal, but the loss of a month's worth of time will make things substantially more difficult.

After the coronavirus pandemic took hold in the U.S. in March, the U.S. Census Bureau pushed deadlines back to allow more time for employees to safely carry out counting operations, including efforts that involve going door to door to track down the county's hardest-to-reach residents. Bureau officials originally set a deadline for themselves to deliver the final count to the president and the U.S. Congress by April 30, 2021, which would have required wrapping up counting operations by Oct. 31.

Officials have since announced they will aim to deliver the data to Congress by Dec. 31, which caused the October deadline to be pushed to the end of September.

Since the announcement, governors in several states—including Michigan, California and Illinois—have publicly criticized the change and said it will impair the ability to have a fair and accurate count. As of the publication of this article, Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner and Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo have not publicly commented on the moved deadline.

Houston in Action—a group promoting civic and cultural engagement in Houston that has worked to increase the census count locally—was among the local advocacy groups warning of an inaccurate count and citing the low response rate so far.

"These last-minute changes to the constitutionally mandated count of every person living in the U.S. threaten the accuracy of population numbers used to determine the distribution of political representation and federal funding for the next decade," officials said in an Aug. 4 Facebook post.

The effects of an undercount will be seen at the hyperlocal level, Mansoor said, because federal, state and local governments often take census data into account when determining budget allocations to certain areas. Census data is also used in the redistricting process, which determines how much political representation certain areas have based on population.

"
When you erase certain communities by not counting them, what happens is they get shortchanged when it’s time to distribute that funding," Mansoor said. "And these are communities that cannot afford to miss out on that funding. They can’t afford to miss out on representation."

Mansoor said she hopes to see an effort taken up in Congress to have the deadlines reverted back to what the bureau originally laid out. In the meantime, she said groups such as Emgage will continue to make the best use of what time is left. The group is now looking for ways to compress three months' worth of public outreach events into two, she said.

"
We know that we have our work cut out for us, but we certainly hope that Congress will act," Mansoor said. "Someone needs to act to make sure the census is not cut off early."

Individuals can fill out the 2020 U.S. census on behalf of their households by going to www.my2020census.gov or by calling the U.S. Census Bureau phone number at
844-330-2020.
By Shawn Arrajj
Shawn Arrajj serves as the editor of the Cy-Fair edition of Community Impact Newspaper where he covers the Cy-Fair and Jersey Village communities. He mainly writes about development, transportation and issues in Harris County.


MOST RECENT

Houston reports 100,000 gallons of wastewater spilled amid flooding

The spills were reported near downtown and the Heights area along White Oak Bayou.

Fort Bend County judge calls on TikTok to build its HQ there

Fort Bend County Judge KP George wrote a letter to TikTok Global calling on the company to consider the county for its global headquarters and future programs in Texas.

Clear Creek ISD will hire a new superintendent at the end of 2020. (Jake Magee/Community Impact Newspaper)
Clear Creek ISD board of trustees, search firm create superintendent candidate profile

The profile consists of a statement of desired characteristics, which will be used to help select Greg Smith's successor.

Fort Bend County is at a Stage 3 on the flood scale as of Sept. 22. (Courtesy of Space City)
Fort Bend County officials urge locals to stay off flooded roadways

Fort Bend County officials are closely monitoring Tropical Depression Beta as of Sept. 22.

City of Bellaire budget
Bellaire City Council approves $60 million budget, flat tax rate for 2020-21

This year, Bellaire expects to tap into its fund balance while raising less money from property taxes.

Texas Central
Texas Central Railroad bullet train project receives rulings on safety framework, selected alignment

Construction for the high-speed bullet train system is slated to begin in the first half of 2021 and to be completed in 2027.

Jersey Village City Council members debated a proposed Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone at a Sept. 21 virtual meeting. (Screenshot courtesy Zoom)
Jersey Village considers tax zone as new tool to address flooding

The concept could help advance "teardown-rebuild" efforts on Jersey Drive.

Ostia will serve Italian- and Mediterranean-inspired cuisine in the Montrose area. (Courtesy Jenn Duncan/Ostia)
New Montrose restaurant Ostia sets opening date

Chef Travis McShane brings his well-traveled experience back to Houston.

The deadline to register to vote for the Nov. 3 election is Oct. 5. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Here's how to register to vote in Montgomery County

Find out early voting dates and the deadline to register.

See how Cy-Fair ISD stacks up to neighboring districts, including Katy, Klein and Tomball ISDs. (Community Impact staff)
See how Cy-Fair ISD compares to neighboring districts in salaries, enrollment

See how Cy-Fair ISD stacks up to neighboring districts, including Katy, Klein and Tomball ISDs.

Conroe ISD's six high schools will host football games at Woodforest Bank Stadium and Moorhead Stadium this fall. (Courtesy Conroe ISD)
Conroe ISD football season kicks off Sept. 24 with new ticketing plan, precautions in place

A new prioritized ticketing system will be in place this fall due to limits on capacity at the district's two stadiums.