High turnout, straight ticket voting helped Democrats win seats in 2018 midterms, experts say

Image description
Democrats win seats in high-turnout elections
Image description
Democrats win seats in high-turnout elections
Image description
Democrats win seats in high-turnout elections
High voter turnout in Harris and Fort Bend counties during the Nov. 6 midterm elections resulted in several state and county seats, long-held by Republicans, switching to Democratic control.

Notable changes include Democrat Lina Hidalgo unseating incumbent Republican Ed Emmett for Harris County Judge, Democrat KP George winning his bid for Fort Bend County judge over incumbent Republican Robert Hebert and Democrat Gina Calanni winning Texas House District 132 over incumbent Republican Mike Schofield.

Experts who study voting trends locally said high-profile races—such as the state’s U.S. Senate race between Democrat Beto O’Rourke and incumbent Republican Ted Cruz—helped push people to the polls in the Katy area. Sources said straight-ticket voting, which will be eliminated by the next election, was a factor in both Harris and Fort Bend counties, especially in county-level elections given the number of races.

With more than 250 races to watch in the Greater Houston area, it is understandable that residents vote based on races receiving the most media attention, said Linda Voht, president of the League of Women Voters of the Houston Area.

“I think you’re going to have a lot of [partial voting] down the ballot,” Voht said. “I think you’re going to have a lot of folks voting in the races that have the most publicity, [and] vote party one by one or just drop off and not cast a vote in down-ticket elections.”

Turnout trends


Harris and Fort Bend counties saw increases in voter turnout for the Nov. 6 election. Harris County turnout was the highest ever recorded for a midterm, according to the Texas Secretary of State. Fort Bend County Elections Department data indicates turnout was the highest since 2002.

About 52.9 percent of registered voters in Harris County cast ballots in November, up from 33.7 percent in 2014. In Fort Bend County, 59.3 percent cast ballots this year, a rise from 36.8 percent in 2014.

In the Harris County portion of the Katy area, Precinct 522 near the intersection of Kingsland and Westgreen boulevards was busiest during this year’s election with 65.1 percent of the precinct’s voters casting ballots. Fort Bend County Precinct 3144 near the intersection of Cinco Ranch Road and Cinco Crossing Lane saw the most voters for the portion of the Katy area in that county with a 67.8 percent turnout.

The 2018 midterms were  the last Texas election in which straight-ticket voting was an option, allowing voters to push one button to select all candidates from one party. In 2016, state lawmakers passed a bill ending the practice in 2020.

In the Nov. 6 election about 76 percent of voters in Harris County cast a straight-ticket ballot. That number was about 66 percent in Fort Bend County.

While straight-ticket voting has been useful to voters Voht said she hopes Texans will begin preparing ahead for elections by completing sample ballots. She understands the number of elections voters see is daunting.

“You’re [still] going to have people that are going to check all the Republicans or all the Democrats or all of the Libertarians,” Voht said.

County implications


Hidalgo, who will take over as Harris County judge Jan. 1, defeated Emmett by roughly 19,000 votes.

“Seventy-seven percent of the people voted straight ticket, and the margin of Democrats over Republicans is 105,000. … There aren’t enough non-straight-ticket voters out there to make up the difference,” Emmett said after a Nov. 13 commissioners court meeting.

Richard Murray, a political science professor and director of the Survey Research Institute at the University of Houston agreed with Emmett.

“Three-fourths voted a straight-ticket Democrat or Republican and there were 100,000 more Democratic votes than Republican, and that was too much for the [Harris] County judge to overcome,” Murray said.

Hidalgo said while straight-ticket voting was a factor, her campaign and the Harris County Democratic Party worked to get people to the polls for candidates in positions such as the one she sought.

Hidalgo was not the only new Democrat to be elected to the court. Former Harris County Sheriff Adrian Garcia won his bid to unseat Precinct 2 Commissioner Jack Mormon. Democrats will now hold a majority of seats on the court in January.

Hidalgo said her priorities will include overhauling criminal justice, improving transparency and flood prevention. As for initiatives Emmett’s administration began, such as projects associated with the $2.5 billion Harris County Flood Control District bond, Hidalgo said she will work with colleagues to determine whether changes are needed.

“Every time you take over an organization you do a complete review of the operations and finances,” Hidalgo said.

In Fort Bend County, George defeated incumbent Republican Hebert by about 15,000 votes and will take office Jan. 1. Hebert was first elected to the county judge’s seat in 2003.

George received 52.91 percent of the vote.

“My top priorities are community engagement and emergency management so when [something like] Hurricane Harvey happens, we know what to do,” George said.

The Fort Bend County Commissioner for Precinct 4 also changed parties Nov. 6 with Democrat Ken DeMerchant defeating Republican incumbent James Patterson with 51.7 percent of the vote.

Hebert said at the county level the switch in party affiliation will not have a huge impact on operations because the roles of the commisioners and judge help county government work in a less partisan manner than the state and federal levels.

“For most of my time in office we had ... an evenly split court politically, but we all worked together,” Hebert said.

Schofield, who lost his Texas House seat, believes the Katy area remains conservative. He credits the change in the Fort Bend and Harris county judge positions to a well-organized Democratic campaign that used straight-ticket voting and data gathering to its advantage.

He thinks the 2020 election will see Republicans applying lessons learned from 2018.

“However, I expect next election that we’ll see Republicans regain ground in Texas,” Schofield said. “Typically, after a wave year, there’s a receding of the wave.”

Statewide implications


The Texas House seat for District 132 that Calanni won was one of 12 seats statewide flipped from Democrat to Republican, according to the secretary of state’s office. The district represents Katy and Cypress.

Although the loss of 12 seats by Republicans did not result in a change of control in Austin, it could result in new priorities for lawmakers to address during the 2019 legislative session, said Mark Jones, a political scientist with Rice University.

“I think there’s going to be a tendency to focus more on bread -and-butter issues and less focus on hot-button issues,” Jones said. “Bread-and-butter issues would be things like school funding, infrastructure, trying to find some type of movement on health care.”

The midterm results could also have implications on who the next speaker of the house will be, Jones said.

“I think we’re probably looking at a Texas House that now elects a speaker who is more in line with [former speaker Joe]Strauss than somebody who is more conservative,” he said.

Additional reporting by Zac Ezonne, Christine Hall and Beth Marshall
By Vanessa Holt
A resident of the Houston area since 2011, Vanessa began working in community journalism in her home state of New Jersey in 1996. She joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2016 as a reporter for the Spring/Klein edition and became editor of that paper in March 2017 and editor of The Woodlands edition in January 2019.


MOST RECENT

Katy ISD student waiting in line for COVID-19 test
Katy ISD expanding COVID-19 testing services to students

Students enrolled in Katy ISD can get tested through the partnership with RediMD.

Hurts Donut
Hurts Donut leaves Katy for new location near Rice Military

The Missouri-based chain serves up creative toppings on donuts 24 hours a day.

Voters wait in line at a Cy-Fair polling location Oct. 16. (Danica Lloyd/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County ballot totals approach 630,000 in first six days of early voting

Ballot counts have averaged about 100,000 daily. Twelve days of early voting remain before the Nov. 3 general election.

Amazon's new sorting center is now open at 22525 Clay Road, Katy. The 800,000-square-foot building opened Oct. 9. (Courtesy Amazon.com Inc.)
Amazon center in Katy to bring 3K jobs and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

An election official directs a car to a spot at the Humble Civic Center's drive-thru voting location. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Drive-thru voting locations in Harris County see greater numbers than in-person, despite challenges

More than 42,000 residents in Harris County have used the drive-thru centers so far in early voting.

Early voting in Fort Bend County for the Nov. 3 election runs Oct. 13-30. (Community Impact staff)
Nearly 56,000 Fort Bend County voters cast in-person ballots in first three days of early voting

Three days into early voting for the Nov. 3 general election, 55,999 Fort Bend County voters have cast ballots in person at the polls, and another 9,160 mail ballots have been received.

Amazon's new sorting center is now open at 22525 Clay Road, Katy. The 800,000-square-foot building opened Oct. 9. (Courtesy Amazon.com Inc.)
New Katy Amazon sorting center to employ 3,000 full- and part-time positions

Amazon's new sorting center is now open at 22525 Clay Road, Katy. The 800,000-square-foot building opened Oct. 9.

Fort Bend County saw 326 new cases of the coronavirus Oct. 9-15, a nearly 50% increase from the week prior. (Community Impact staff)
DATA: Fort Bend County averages 46.57 new daily coronavirus cases Oct. 9-15

Fort Bend County saw 326 new cases of the coronavirus Oct. 9-15, a nearly 50% increase from the week prior.

The outlet mall is located in Cypress. (Courtesy Houston Premium Outlets)
Outlet mall in Cy-Fair opens 3 new stores and more top Houston-area news

Read the most popular news form the past week from our Houston coverage area.

Great Harvest Bread Co opened a second location Oct. 5 inside Kingsland Baptist. (Courtesy of Harvest Bread Co.)
Great Harvest Bread Co. opens second location in Katy area

Great Harvest Bread Co opened a second location Oct. 5 inside Kingsland Baptist.