Houston controller: City’s revenue losses will be more extreme than budget predicts

Houston Controller Chris Brown, who serves as an independent check on the city finance department, painted a much darker picture of Houston’s reserves than as projected in the city’s proposed fiscal year 2020-21 budget.

Brown’s annual trends report presented May 20 suggested that Houston’s savings could dip to a historic low of 2.1% of maintenance and operating expenses by the end of Fiscal Year 2020-21, falling well below the 7.5% threshold required by city financial policies. The balance can dip below 7.5% only in the event of economic instability beyond the city’s control, the policies state.

“I don't like having this talk about disastrous financial consequences for the city,” Brown said. “But I feel like if we don't have it now, in 12 or 18 months, we're going to be having the same meeting and you all are going to say, ‘why didn't you tell us that it could be this bad?’”

Brown’s projection of the city’s $45 million ending fund balance, a de facto savings account for the city, is $108 million lower than the projection used by the city's finance department to form the proposed FY 2020-21 budget, which already calls for 3,000 furloughs and other cost-saving measures.

The finance department’s projections place the ending fund balance at 7.15%, 5 percentage points higher than Brown’s prediction. Overall, Brown's figures show general fund revenues $88.5 million less than what the administration's proposal anticipates.


During last year’s budget cycle, which was marred by a different financial crisis brought on by the city’s ongoing firefighter pay raise dispute, Brown’s projection of the ending fund balance was just 0.9% percent lower than the city’s projection.

For FY 2020-21, Brown’s predicted loss of 9.96% sales tax revenues due to coronavirus shutdowns, the oil downturn and a slowing economy is the main driver of the fund balances’ losses, he said. The mayor's proposal used an assumption of a 0.74% decrease in sales taxes.

An estimate halfway between his and the city’s finance department, Brown said, would put the fund balance at $80 to $90 million total, leaving little room for additional losses in the next year, when property tax declines will be felt more acutely.

“If we see a 10% decrease in property tax revenues, that would be $120 million reduction,” he said. "So if we have a $120 million loss in revenue and we only have $80 or $90 million left in our savings account, where's the money going to come from?”

A budget hearing is slated for June 3 and a vote by City Council is expected June 10.


MOST RECENT

Attendees sample a wide variety of global wines and cuisine during Wine & Food Week. (Courtesy Food & Vine Time Productions)
Wine & Food Week returns to The Woodlands and more news from the Houston area

Read business and community news from the Houston area.

The number of deaths reported has been declining for the past three week, according to the Texas Medical Center. (Community Impact staff)
Texas Medical Center: COVID-19 hospitalizations down 10% since Aug. 3

The number of deaths reported has been declining for the past three week, according to the Texas Medical Center.

Harris County leaders discussed this week whether to raise or lower property taxes. (Courtesy Fotolia)
UPDATED: Harris Co. commissioners eyeing property tax rates

This article was updated Aug. 8 to clarify that an 8% tax rate increase is not considered to be on the table by commissioners.

A mother and daughter visit at Seasons Assisted Living & Memory Care in Conroe earlier in the pandemic. (Courtesy Seasons Assisted Living & Memory Care)
Texas allows limited visitations to nursing homes, long-term care facilities

Facilities that meet the requirements will allow limited visitations, but you still will not be able to hug or kiss your loved one.

HomeAid Houston partnered with Boys and Girls Country to open three cottages in Hockley. (Courtesy Boys and Girls Country)
Builders partner to serve homeless population through nonprofit HomeAid Houston

Since launching in 2003, the organization has helped provide 20,000 beds for homeless individuals in the Houston area.

Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner's police reform task force is gathering more community input. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Police reform task force asks Houston residents to share opinions through Aug. 9

The Houston Mayor's Task Force on Policing Reform is circulating a survey among Houston neighborhoods to collect opinions from residents.

An online training course to help prepare Houston ISD parents for the virtual return to school is set to go live Aug. 10. (Courtesy Canva)
Houston ISD to launch parent educational course on virtual learning Aug. 10

The district is asking parents to complete the course by Sept. 4.

The 2020 U.S. census response rate is already lagging behind 2010 numbers, and officials said the shortened timeline only increases the chances of an undercount. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Shortened census timeline could shortchange Houston, its most vulnerable communities

The 2020 U.S. census response rate is already lagging behind 2010 numbers, and officials said the shortened timeline only increases the chances of an undercount.

The farm-to-table restaurant plans to create 90 jobs and offer familiar American meals. (Courtesy Whiskey Cake)
Whiskey Cake restaurant to open in The Woodlands and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.