Settlement in Harris County bail bond lawsuit receives final approval

A 2016 lawsuit over Harris County bail bond practices has officially been settled. (Courtesy Fotolia)
A 2016 lawsuit over Harris County bail bond practices has officially been settled. (Courtesy Fotolia)

A 2016 lawsuit over Harris County bail bond practices has officially been settled. (Courtesy Fotolia)

After more than three years, a lawsuit over Harris County bail bond practices has officially been settled.

The lawsuit—O'Donnell v. Harris County—was filed in an effort to force Harris County to change long-standing bail bond practices that plaintiffs said were unconstitutional, including detaining pretrial arrestees who were unable to afford bail. A federal judge found Harris County's bail bond practices unconstitutional in 2017, declaring them in violation of the Constitution's due process and equal protection clauses.

The same judge, U.S. District Judge Lee Rosenthal, gave final approval Nov. 21 to a settlement that had been reached between Harris County and the plaintiffs in July. Harris County initially fought the lawsuit, but the county dropped the fight and began settlement talks earlier this year after a wave of Democratic judges were elected into office following the 2018 elections.

"For too long, residents in Harris County have been taken advantage of by a broken, unfair and unconstitutional bail system," said Harris County Judge Lina Hidalgo, who supported the settlement, in a statement. "We do not have to choose between protecting the constitutional rights of defendants and protecting public safety. In fact, by reforming our broken bail system, we are taking a step toward rebuilding trust between our system of justice and the residents it serves."

Under the settlement,
Harris County will grant personal bonds for roughly 85% of misdemeanor arrestees with exceptions for several offenses, such as domestic violence and assault. The settlement also requires the county to implement programs to improve court appearance rates, which could include helping defendants with transportation, childcare and mental health problems.


During the July meeting at which the Harris County Commissioners Court approved the settlement by a vote of 3-2, officials said the overall cost of the settlement to the county could range from $59 million-$97 million.

Critics of the settlement have argued that it presents a danger to public safety and does not do enough to ensure arrestees will show up for their court dates after being released on bond. In approving the settlement, Rosenthal wrote that no bail system is perfect, and the need for Harris County to make its system compliant with the Constitution was at the center of the decision.

"No [bail bond] system can guarantee that all those accused of misdemeanors who are released on personal bonds—rich or poor—will appear for hearings or trial, or that they will commit no crimes on release," Rosenthal wrote. "No system can guarantee that all those accused of misdemeanors who are detained pending trial—rich or poor—should have been detained. But Harris County, which operates the third-largest jail system in the country, can stop systematically depriving indigent misdemeanor defendants of their constitutionally protected rights by detaining them simply because they cannot afford to post money bail."

The final approval came a little less than one month after a fairness hearing where critics of the settlement were able to make their cases for why it should not be approved.

Critics included Harris County District Attorney Kim Ogg, who filed an amicus brief in which she noted the number of open misdemeanor cases in Harris County increased by 59% from Jan. 1, 2018, to late October 2019, which she attributed to misdemeanor defendants not showing up to court. The settlement decree would make it harder for the district attorney's office to prosecute cases. Ogg said she supports bail bond reform overall, but took issue with key parts of the settlement decree.

Plaintiffs argued that cases moving more slowly was evidence that defendants were no longer being coerced into pleading guilty, an argument Rosenthal said she found persuasive.

Other critics—including
Precinct 3 Commissioner Steve Radack, Precinct 4 Commissioner Jack Cagle and several law enforcement organizations—argued the settlement presents a danger to public safety, pointing to examples of defendants committing crimes while out on bail. Rosenthal wrote anecdotes could not be used to refute the court's findings or stand in the way of the Constitutional issues that needed to be addressed.

Radack spoke about bail bond reform, among other topics, at a Nov. 19 luncheon hosted by the Cy-Fair Houston Chamber of Commerce. He said the settlement does not require the county to extend the same assistance to victims of crime as it does arrestees.

"
There are far, far less criminals than victims," he said. "People are getting away with crime. They are not being punished."

However, Hidalgo said the guilty will still be held accountable under the new system.

"The guilty will still be held accountable for their actions, but the accused won't have their lives, livelihoods, and families torn apart because they are too poor to buy their freedom," she said.

Moving forward, Harris County will be required to hire a court-appointed monitor who will oversee the implementation of programs laid out in the settlement for a seven-year period.
By Shawn Arrajj
Shawn Arrajj serves as the editor of the Cy-Fair edition of Community Impact Newspaper where he covers the Cy-Fair and Jersey Village communities. He mainly writes about development, transportation and issues in Harris County.


MOST RECENT

Polls will be open from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Election Day, Nov. 3. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
MAP: A look at early voter turnout by county in Texas

About 57% of registered voters in Texas have cast ballots so far in the Nov. 3 general election, according to the latest data from the Texas Secretary of State.

Isabel Longoria
Harris County taps Isabel Longoria as final candidate for first-ever elections administrator

The position will overtake election duties from the county clerk and the tax-assessor collector.

Houston Morning Market Company is poised to launch three new markets across the Greater Houston area by Nov. 19. (Courtesy Houston Morning Market Company)
Houston Morning Market Co. expands across region and more local news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

Several named storms have brought heavy rainfall to the Houston area during the 2020 hurricane season amid the coronavirus pandemic. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
In the midst of 2020’s economic downturn, Harris County continues to consider social vulnerability when prioritizing flood mitigation projects

Zoning expert and law professor Sara Bronin explained how marginalized populations can find themselves in a “vicious cycle” when government agencies do not take steps to protect them from flooding.

Jersey Village officials are preparing to launch a master plan that will guide improvements at city parks. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Jersey Village seeks resident feedback on comprehensive plan update, new parks master plan

The plan, which is meant to guide the city over the next 10-20 years, lays out goals across land use, transportation, economic development, parks and recreation, and community character.

Voters line up outside Juergen's Hall Community Center in Cypress on Oct. 14. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Harris County exceeds its previous voter turnout record before early voting ends

More than 1.3 million county residents cast ballots throughout the entire November 2016 election, but this year, that number was surpassed on Oct. 29—with one day of early voting remaining in addition to Election Day on Nov. 3.

Early voting runs through Oct. 30. Election Day is Nov. 3. (Adriana Rezal/Community Impact Newspaper)
Double-edged sword: As voter turnout reaches all-time highs in Greater Houston area, so does risk of incomplete ballots

Under-votes, or votes that are never cast in a particular race, occur when voters cast incomplete ballots. They typically surge in elections with high voter turnout, said Steve Leakey, president of the Montgomery County Voter Awareness Council.

Harris County residents have returned approximately 163,000 mail-in ballots. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)
Nearly 163,000 Harris County voters have submitted mail-in ballots

Early voting and mail-in ballots will be counted after polls close on Election Day.

ExxonMobil's Houston campus opened in Springwoods Village in 2014. (Courtesy ExxonMobil)
ExxonMobil to lay off 1,900 employees primarily in Greater Houston area

Citing economic strain due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic, ExxonMobil officials announced in a press release Oct. 29 plans to lay off approximately 1,900 employees primarily at its management offices in Houston.