Case against Montgomery County Judge Craig Doyal, commissioners Riley and Clark dismissed

The case against Montgomery County Judge Craig Doyal and other elected officials has been dismissed.

The case against Montgomery County Judge Craig Doyal and other elected officials has been dismissed.

Presiding Judge Randy Clapp of Wharton County’s 329th District Court ruled that a portion of the Texas Open Meetings Act is unconstitutional—thus dismissing the case against Montgomery County Judge Craig Doyal and other officials.

The case, which was heard in Montgomery County’s 221st District Court, brought to question whether Doyal, Precinct 2 Commissioner Charlie Riley, Precinct 4 Commissioner Jim Clark and political consultant Marc Davenport violated the Texas Open Meetings Act while negotiating details of the November 2015 Montgomery County road bond. However, the case never made it to trial.

During the court hearings, attorneys questioned a mix of expert witnesses and government officials about their experience with the TOMA and questioned the constitutionality of one statute in particular—Texas Government Code 551.143. The statute states that members of a governmental body cannot knowingly conspire to circumvent the TOMA by meeting in numbers less than a quorum for the purpose of secret deliberations.

On Wednesday, Clapp ruled the statute is unconstitutional. The ruling does not affect the remainder of the TOMA, but it does strike the provision from the law.

“We hope to show through this evidence that we are not challenging TOMA,” Doyal’s attorney Rusty Hardin said during the hearings. “This is simply talking about [a] single statute that criminalizes a supposed conspiracy. The problem with the statute is it does not set out in specific set ways what a person that may be exposed to it can and cannot do. This specific statute is unconstitutionally vague.”

Special prosecutor Chris Downey, who represents the state of Texas on the case, said his team will make a decision soon on whether an appeal will be filed.

“I regret that the court elected to rule on this matter before receiving the briefs the sides were preparing to address the issues raised in this unusual hearing," Downey said. "That said, I certainly respect the court’s ruling. Given the constitutional challenges the defense raised in opposition to one of the important enforcement components of the open meetings act, this is an important matter of both legal and public policy. With that in mind, we will determine in short order whether to file notice of appeal.”

Doyal said the challenge to the provision does not affect the remainder of the open meetings act. The ruling instead means that Clapp agreed the provision did not meet constitutional standards. Defense attorneys also argued that the statute can also capture innocent behavior because it did not explicitly outline which behavior is and is not permitted by law.

“We got word from the judge that he ruled in our favor and dismissed the indictment," Doyal said. "I agree with the open meetings act and the public should be involved. I never did anything wrong and I have tried hard not to do anything wrong. I am excited that the judge has dismissed this indictment. Now it is time to move forward and take care of Montgomery County."

Riley said he is relieved now that a decision has been reached, and that the ruling will help elected officials across the state openly discuss issues in their communities with constituents and one another.

“This has been one of the biggest tests of faith my family has ever endured.  I am so thankful for the court’s ruling," Riley said. "It is a ruling that affirms my support for open government and my belief that public officials ought to be able to constructively talk to, and work with, the people of Montgomery County without fear of being prosecuted.  My staff and I look forward to continuing the excellent service that our community has come to expect from the Precinct 2 Commissioner’s Office.”


The Atrium Center will be able to be reserved for meetings, conferences, weddings, anniversary celebrations, birthday parties and community events. (Courtesy Rockin’ AD Photography)
East Montgomery County Improvement District offices to be repurposed into event venue The Atrium Center

The venue will be able to be reserved for meetings, conferences, weddings, anniversary celebrations, birthday parties and community events.

Construction on the The Promise House, a day center aimed at assisting the local homeless population, will begin on June 14 in Humble. (Rendering courtesy of The Family Promise of Lake Houston)
Construction set to begin on The Promise House homeless day center in Humble

The Promise House will serve the local homeless community by providing individual counseling services, higher education and training classes, mentoring, and administrative offices for area families.

Taco Bueno sells tacos, burritos, quesadillas, nachos and more unique items, including the Muchaco, a taco made with a soft pita-like shell. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Taco Bueno coming to Katy and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

Lake Houston Redevelopment Authority has secured an almost $49.1 million bond to fund the upcoming Northpark Drive overpass project in Kingwood. (Courtesy Pexels)
Lake Houston Redevelopment Authority secures $49.1M bond to fund Northpark Drive overpass project

The board of directors also discussed $50 million that was earmarked in the state's budget to fund future dredging efforts in Lake Houston.

Sen. Brandon Creighton announced his re-election campaign for Texas Senate District 4 on June 10. (Courtesy Brandon Creighton)
'Unfinished business remains': Brandon Creighton aims at re-election for Texas Senate District 4

Creighton announced his plans to run for re-election to serve his third term for the 88th Texas Legislature.

Humble ISD Trustee Robert Sitton took his oath of office for his final four-year term on June 8. (Courtesy Humble ISD)
Newcomers, long-standing trustees take oath of office for Humble ISD board of trustees

"This community is genuinely the very best place for children, and one of the reasons why is because of people like you—all of you—who are willing to do this job for free," Humble ISD Superintendent Elizabeth Fagen said.

Economist Elliot Eisenberg spoke about the economic recovery post-pandemic, saying this year's GDP growth will be the best since the 1950s. (Brooke Ontiveros/Community Impact Newspaper)
Economist explains housing demand, price booms in Texas, Greater Houston area

Eisenberg explained why home prices are rising at a June 9 Greater Houston Builders Association luncheon.

I-45 Houston
Houston extends pilot period for freeway crash towing program

A pilot program that aims to reduce wait times for towing after freeway accidents got an extension June 9.

Officials with the Harris County Justice Administration Department said they identified racial disparities in citations and use of force by law enforcement, among other areas. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Harris County identifies racial disparities in use of force, citations from law enforcement agencies

Analysis in the report included racial demographics in instances of consent search, contraband discovery, traffic stops that led to arrests, types of citations or warnings, and use of force.

Single-family home sales in the Houston area surged 48.2% percent compared to May 2020, when real estate was in the process of recovering from coronavirus-related lockdowns. (Courtesy Houston Association of Realtors)
Houston-area home sales in May up nearly 50% versus last year

Single-family home sales were up 48.2% compared to a year ago, with 9,702 units sold versus 6,546 a year earlier.

Mark Mitchell, chief economic development officer for Partnership Lake Houston, will leave the organization this summer. (Courtesy Mark Mitchell)
Mark Mitchell to leave Partnership Lake Houston after 4 years of aiding area's economic growth

Mitchell's last day with Partnership Lake Houston will be June 18, but he will remain at the organization until his replacement is hired this summer.