Bellaire sidewalk charter election builds on longstanding divisions

Bellaire sidewalk charter election
A charter election is on the ballot Nov. 3 for Bellaire residents to decide how the city should handle sidewalk improvements. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)

A charter election is on the ballot Nov. 3 for Bellaire residents to decide how the city should handle sidewalk improvements. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)

Image description
When Bellaire resident Mike Jacobs stepped to the podium during a January 2019 Bellaire City Council meeting, it was for one purpose: to declare he had secured 2,500-3,000 signatures—far more than the 580 required—to formally request a charter amendment.

Jacobs communicated the frustration felt by some Bellaire residents regarding the city’s process for sidewalk construction across three areas: flooding concerns, transparency from local government, and lack of local control.

“Ladies and gentlemen, we’ll not have this issue coming forth every year with every new overzealous council member,” Jacobs said.

The petition was the culmination of years of debates about sidewalks in Bellaire. Nearly two years later, voters will weigh in this November.

“People felt like they didn’t have a voice,” Jacobs said. “This was an issue where people just need to protect their property, and they need to protect their rights.”

Stepping back

Since he came on to the City Council in the late 1990s, Pat McLaughlin, a longtime Bellaire resident and former City Council member, knows firsthand about the sidewalk controversy.

“Some people have very strong feelings opposed to sidewalks,” McLaughlin said. “Others favor the sidewalks.”

The debate dates back decades to Bellaire’s development post-World War II, when sidewalks were installed in some areas but not others, Mayor Andrew Friedberg said.

“Because Bellaire did not have sidewalks from the very beginning of the city, that’s why it’s the subject of disagreement,” Friedberg said. “Had we had them from the start, nobody would give them a second thought. But because any new sidewalk necessarily involves retrofitting into an existing landscape, it represents change.”

Bellaire’s Comprehensive Plan, adopted in 2015 and amended in 2017, made a continuous sidewalk network a high priority for city elected officials, “even in the face of vocal, localized opposition as particular segments are to be built or improved” while recommending a case-by-case approach for constrained and contentious locations.

However, the $54 million Bonds for Better Bellaire program, approved by voters in November 2016 with $24 million focused on streets, drainage, and sidewalk work, later sparked resident pushback. As a result, around $4 million in potential sidewalk projects was reallocated to drainage work.

“I think at the end of the day, it starts and ends with the way they went about the Bonds for Better Bellaire program and the way they moved to implement it,” Jacobs said. “They could’ve gone out of their way to make sure that people knew their blocks were going to be affected.”

Not long after the bond election, a proposal for a Community Pathways Plan looking to lay out a project agenda for a new sidewalk network prompted further resident concerns.

“Although it was only a very preliminary study, the citizens perceived that the bulldozers were idling and ready to plow through their front yards to implement this connectivity or pathway study,” said McLaughlin, who left office at the end of 2019. “And the citizens were quite irate about it, and that warmed up the citizens for further sidewalk opposition.”

As a result of the pushback, City Council shelved the plan in 2018.

Ballot battle

The petition presented in 2019 put forward three propositions: require the city to provide six months’ notice of potential sidewalk construction along with detailed project implications, require 50% of residents on a block to approve a sidewalk improvement and require the city to mitigate the drainage effects of all sidewalk projects.

Each proposition will be voted on separately, meaning all three, none, or one or two could pass depending on the vote.

Meanwhile, a political action committee pushing back against the propositions said the amendments will make it impossible to build new sidewalks.

“I was deeply shocked when I read these charter amendments,” said Patricia Bernstein, a member of the group, SafeBellaire. “They don’t say in so many words we’re going to ban any new future sidewalks in Bellaire forever, but in effect, that’s what it would accomplish, and that is their purpose.”

If the three propositions are passed, the city would need to hire an independent firm to perform a hydrological study, and then 50% or more people on a particular block would need to express written support in favor of the construction, a significant roadblock in future sidewalk efforts, McLaughlin said.

“The city could engage in that study, spend a bunch of money on each specific block, and then have the citizens reject it,” he said.

Council Member Nathan Wesely, however, disagreed with that notion.

“There are some hoops you need to jump through, but I think if residents want it, those hoops will be easy,” Wesely said.

However there is a bigger issue, Wesely said: the struggle by the city to maintain solid, two-way communication with residents.

“I think the feeling is that people felt they had no input on sidewalks unless they put them in as a charter amendment,” Wesely said.

Ballot guide

Three amendments to Bellaire’s city charter are up for vote in November, each related to sidewalk construction and the notification process by the city to residents who would be affected by such construction. Residents can vote for any of the propositions.

Proposition A— Requires the city to provide six months of notice prior to a City Council action item to construct a sidewalk. The notice would include project schematics and other details, as well as a hydrological study of the proposed project by a third party.

Proposition B—The city may not construct a sidewalk on a residential block without 50% written approval of the property owners on that block no more than three months prior to construction.

Proposition C—The city may not construct a sidewalk unless it also eliminates the impact of the material used in the sidewalk construction on water discharge and runoff in the city.
By Hunter Marrow
Hunter Marrow came to Community Impact Newspaper in January 2020. Before that, Hunter covered local news in Ontario, OR for three years, covering municipal issues, crime, and education across Malheur County and across the border into Idaho.


The show is making a stop at Sam Houston Race Park this December. (Courtesy UniverSoul Circus)
Cy-Fair hosts events and more Houston-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Houston area.

Francesca’s clothing boutique has filed Chapter bankruptcy 11 as it looks to sell its business. Pictured above is a Francesca's store at 2515 University Blvd., Houston, in Rice Village, which remains open. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)
Local boutique clothing chain Francesca’s files Chapter 11 bankruptcy, will initiate sale of business

The chain has received a commitment from its current lender, Tiger Finance LLC, for a $25 million debtor-in-possession financing facility.

Meyerland Jewelers, located at Meyerland Plaza, has announced it will be going out of business. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)
Meyerland Jewelers to close in January

Meyerland Jewelers is offering up to 70% off its storewide products until it closes in mid-January.

Tracking police reform text
Police oversight board seen as target for reform

A new study confirms task force report findings and complaints from board members stating that the oversight process is dysfunctional.

Council Member Robert Gallegos, Arturo Michel, Mayor Sylvester Turner and Ron Lewis.
Mayor announces changes among Houston’s top-level staff

Several key staff are retiring or leaving for new positions.

Several projects around the area will add stormwater capacity and improved drainage. (Hunter Marrow/Community Impact Newspaper)
7 flood-fighting projects to know around Bellaire-Meyerland-West University

Several local projects have made headway in recent months.

Houston ISD reported that 42% of its students failed at least one class in the first six-week grading period for 2020-21, which was held exclusively online. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Houston ISD acknowledges role of COVID-19 virtual instruction in student performance drop

"The most notable difference between last year and this year is the virtual education component implemented due to the COVID-19 pandemic," the district said.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced Dec. 2 that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has allotted 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines to the state of Texas. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
First allotment of COVID-19 vaccinations expected to arrive in Texas in mid-December

About 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines have been allotted to the state of Texas and will arrive the week of Dec. 14.

The East Montgomery County Industrial Park off Gene Campbell Road will welcome the Lowe's Distribution Center in July. (Courtesy East Montgomery County Improvement District)
Lowe's to bring 200 jobs to Montgomery County and more Houston-area news

Read the latest Houston-area business and community news.

Harris County has launched a tool to allow homeowners to identify appraisal activity in their neighborhood. (Courtesy Pexels)
Harris County Appraisal District launches new 'Appraiser Field Operations Map' tool

Harris County has launched a tool to allow homeowners to identify appraisal activity in their neighborhood.

Through Jan. 10, the Houston Zoo brings out the holiday cheer with Zoo Lights, featuring large-scale light installations, including a 100-foot-long tunnel. Visitors age 10 years and older are required to wear facial coverings over the nose and mouth. 5:30-10:30 p.m. $12.95-$25.25. 6200 Hermann Park Drive, Houston. 713-533-6550. (Courtesy Houston Zoo)
Check out these virtual and in-person holiday events in Houston, West U

There are virtual and in-person events to keep the holiday spirit alive.