Carroll ISD, Grapevine-Colleyville ISD brace for HB 3 finance changes

Members of the Texas House of Representatives gathered at a news conference March 5 in support of House Bill 3.

Members of the Texas House of Representatives gathered at a news conference March 5 in support of House Bill 3.

Image description
Intro to House Bill 3
Image description
Doing the homework
Image description
Raising the pay grade
Image description
GCISD and CISD breakdown
Outcry against high property taxes and recapture payments, along with a desire for quality education, were at the forefront of legislators’ minds this past session, elected officials say. Many lawmakers have expressed enthusiasm about the passage of House Bill 3, a massive school spending bill.

But local school administrators are a little more apprehensive about the bill, expressing some reservations about what these changes could mean for their budgets for fiscal year 2019-20 and beyond.

While both Grapevine-Colleyville ISD and Carroll ISD will see some net revenue gains that neither would have received under the old law, those added dollars are not enough to cover budget deficits, which are compounded by mandated pay raises for district staff.

GCISD, which had to approve its budget only two weeks after Gov. Greg Abbott signed the bill into law, expects to see $3.1 million in overall added revenue.

The $3.1 million will all go to compensation increases, said DaiAnn Mooney, chief financial officer for GCISD. This still leaves the district to grapple with a $6.6 million deficit—about the same amount as the previous year, according to budget documents.

“We’re very appreciative that the state did put money into the system,” Mooney said. “But I think there’s been some misconceptions about how much school districts are actually going to get when everything gets flushed out with House Bill 3.”

Unlike its neighbor, Carroll ISD is not expected to pass a budget until late August. But CISD faces a similar situation, anticipating about $1.8 million in new funds, while still working with a potential $3.8 million shortfall, said Scott Wrehe, CISD’s assistant superintendent for financial services. The district adopted a budget with a $2.4 million deficit in 2018, and this year, the school board has proposed a 4%-4.5% pay raise for fiscal year 2019-20 to comply with new compensation requirements and to retain talented educators.

Gaps in the budget can be covered through savings, Wrehe said.

“There’s still a lot unknown,” he said. “It’ll probably take through this next year [before] we’ll see exactly how this affected us.”

Financial considerations


HB 3 attacks school finance and public education issues on multiple fronts: limiting local property taxes, investing in students and providing for increased compensation for school staff.

“This is historic,” said state Rep. Giovanni Capriglione, R-Southlake. “I have never seen us work for this long and this hard on any one subject.”

One of the biggest accomplishments touted by lawmakers is that the bill lowered recapture payments across the state. This is money property-wealthy districts send back to the state with the intent to support property-poor districts.

Under HB 3, CISD’s recapture payment will be reduced by nearly $8.9 million, and GCISD’s payment will decrease by about $14 million, according to projections.

For comparison, Dallas ISD is set to save more than $170 million in recapture. Farther south, Round Rock ISD will have its recapture payment completely eliminated based on the Legislative Budget Board estimates.

GCISD and CISD will also see fewer dollars coming in from property taxes—the biggest revenue source for both school districts, according to budget documents.

HB 3 will require CISD and GCISD to compress their maintenance and operations tax rates by $0.07. The law does not affect the interest and sinking tax rate, which districts use to pay off debt. Tax rates are not adopted until later in September.

After this year, HB 3 essentially places a 2.5% cap on property tax revenue growth, limiting how much districts can collect in taxes without calling for an election.

Based on Tarrant Appraisal District’s reports, the compressed rate could potentially save average homeowners in the two school districts about $300-$532 more per year than if there was no change in the tax rate.

The idea is for the state to pick up more of the education costs, Mooney said. But its ability to do that depends on the Texas economy.

“In Texas, we do have a strong oil and gas market, and I think we’ll be fine. But if something happens and it crashes, how are they going to sustain [the system]?” she said. “I don’t want another 2011, which was when they cut funding significantly.”

Disparity in funding


HB 3 affects each school district differently because funding depends on multiple variables, including a district’s property values, attendance rates and student demographics.

GCISD anticipates about $6.9 million in state funds for FY 2019-20 while CISD expects about $5.4 million from the state, according to budget documents. For both districts, this is a decrease in state funding compared with what they received last year. State funds will make up about 8% of their revenues this coming year.

In contrast, DISD will see a 4% increase in state funding, which will make up 14% of its budget for FY 2019-20, according to DISD documents.

“It’s not equitable between districts,” Wrehe said.

Student enrollment drives up funding, said Steven Poole, executive director for the United Educators Association, a regional organization that advocates for public school employees. Districts also receive more money for certain student groups, such as those with limited English proficiency or special education needs.

Neither GCISD nor CISD is seeing much growth, officials said. The exception is iUniversity Prep, GCISD’s online school, which grew by more than 23% between the 2017-18 and 2018-19 school years, according to the Texas Education Agency student enrollment report.

Pay raises


The bill directs districts to spend at least 30% of revenue gains to increase employee compensation, particularly for librarians, nurses, counselors and teachers. Teachers with more than five years of experience are to be prioritized.

There were initial talks of giving $5,000 raises across the state, but many districts cannot afford that. Payroll makes up more than 80% of GCISD and CISD’s expenditures, officials said.

GCISD teachers, librarians, nurses and counselors will see at least a $2,000-$2,500 pay increase—more than required by law, Mooney said. All other employees will see higher wages, as well.

Although CISD has not approved its budget or raises, the school board is considering a 4%-4.5% pay raise—also more than required. But there is a concern about sustainability.

“The last time the state-initiated salary increases, that was right before districts had to start laying off a lot of staff because the funding went away [in 2011],” Wrehe said.

That year, the state cut about $5.3 billion from public education, and thousands of teachers were laid off.

Capriglione said he is encouraged by the changes brought by HB 3, but there is more work needed.

“I do not think of this as ‘done,’” he said. “Every single [session], we have to continue to prioritize this. This is the No. 1 issue in our area.”
By Renee Yan
Renee Yan graduated May 2017 from the University of Texas in Arlington with a degree in journalism, joining Community Impact Newspaper as a reporter in July.


MOST RECENT

Two hundred rail pieces were delivered east of Shiloh Road in Plano in late 2020, according to a Dec. 18 DART release. (Courtesy Dallas Area Rapid Transit)
DART to save millions on Silver Line project following approval of refinanced loan from U.S. Department of Transportation

The $908 million loan was approved by the U.S. Department of Transportation's Build America Bureau in 2018, according to a Feb. 25 news release.

At its peak of power loss, the city had roughly 50,000 homes with interrupted power, many of which had prolonged outages, Plano City Manager Mark Israelson said. (Liesbeth Powers/Community Impact Newspaper)
Plano faces long-term impacts from storm; Collin County vaccine hubs resume service and more DFW-area news

Read the top business and community news from this week from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Any Lab Test Now will be opening a new clinic in early March in Southlake. (Courtesy Any Lab Test Now)
Any Lab Test Now coming soon to Southlake

Any Lab Test Now will be opening a location in Southlake in March.

Construction notification signs next to Cheek-Sparger Road
Cheek-Sparger Road upgrades scheduled in Colleyville

A portion of Cheek-Sparger Road near Colleyville Boulevard will be open to westbound traffic only.

Snow covers I-45 in Houston during a winter storm that hit Texas the night of Feb. 14. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Legislators probe energy officials over power failures, lack of preparation heading into winter storm

The Texas Legislature held hearings Feb. 25 with energy companies including Oncor Electric Delivery and the Electric Reliability Council of Texas in response to last week’s historic winter storm, which left millions of Texans without electricity for days.

The city of Grapevine will be waiving certain fees related to damage caused by Winter Storm Uri. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Grapevine waives fees, provides other assistance for residents affected by winter storm

Grapevine residents will not see February in their average sanitary sewer rates to reflect accurate water usage during the winter storm.

The coffee and wine bar offers signature drinks, such as the Honey Bear Latte, made with honey and cinnamon, as well as food options, such as breakfast tacos, charcuterie boards, baked goods and snack boxes. (Courtesy Golden Boy Coffee Co.)
Golden Boy Coffee Co. opens in Plano; Black Rock Coffee Bar coming to Southlake and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Black Rock Coffee Bar will be opening in Southlake in the spring. (Courtesy of Black Rock Coffee Bar)
Oregon boutique coffee shop Black Rock Coffee Bar plans Southlake location

Black Rock Coffee is set to open two new locations in the Dallas-Fort Worth area, including one in Southlake.

As many as 31 stores across nine states will be shuttered as Fry's Electronics shuts down due to market changes and the pandemic. (Courtesy Qygen, Wikimedia Commons)
Fry's Electronics calls it quits after nearly 36 years in business

As many as 31 stores across nine states will be shuttered as Fry's Electronics shuts down due to market changes and the pandemic.

A lone runner jogs on a snow-covered road in Austin. Transportation projects across the city were briefly paused due to Winter Storm Uri. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
ERCOT: Texas power system was less than 5 minutes from collapse during winter storm

ERCOT's CEO offered details into what led to the massive blackouts that left millions of Texans in the cold last week.

Next Bistro was opened in 2011 by husband and wife Tom and Ying Aiken. Chef Ying left her career as an accountant to pursue cooking. (Photos courtesy Next Bistro)
Upscale eatery Next Bistro in Colleyville continues to innovate

The owners of Next Bistro in Colleyville have made a major investment in their restaurant every year since opening it in 2011.

Saint Bernard has leased more than 10,000 square feet at the Shops of Southlake and is expected to open this spring. (Courtesy Pexels)
Saint Bernard coming soon to Shops of Southlake

Saint Bernard has leased more than 10,000 square feet at the Shops of Southlake and is expected to open this spring.