McKinney postpones Confederate statue decision for a second time

McKinney City Council voted Feb. 2 to postpone any decision regarding the Throckmorton statue. (Miranda Jaimes/Community Impact Newspaper)

McKinney City Council voted Feb. 2 to postpone any decision regarding the Throckmorton statue. (Miranda Jaimes/Community Impact Newspaper)

Following months of research, a petition with over 1,900 signatures, three advisory board meetings and two City Council meeting discussions, McKinney’s City Council voted for a second time to postpone any decision concerning the Throckmorton statue.

The Feb. 2 vote pushes the decision until at least May.

James W. Throckmorton was a controversial yet notable person in North Texas history for his roles as a Confederate Army captain, one-year governor of Texas and slave owner. According to Guy Giersch, the city’s long-time historic preservation officer who is retiring, Throckmorton’s contributions helped pave the way for McKinney’s current economic prosperity.

The Throckmorton statue is located downtown in front of the McKinney Performing Arts Center, which served as the Collin County courthouse until 1979. Last summer, the city began researching the historical context, appropriateness and relevance of the statue in McKinney’s downtown after a number of residents asked for the statue's removal.

The ad hoc advisory board—comprised of community members, not city staff—was put together to oversee the research. The board met three times in August and September to discuss the research and what the statue might symbolize for different McKinney residents.

A survey was sent out to the community to receive feedback on what should be done with the statue. Options included leaving the statue in place, adding additional signage, adding additional statues of other important figures, removing and placing it in storage, removing and installing somewhere else, and removing and selling the statue—potentially to a museum.

The public input survey, which was conducted from Sept. 10-27, garnered 2,094 total responses. Of this, 1,781 respondents said they resided in a McKinney ZIP code.

The majority of McKinney residents who responded to the survey were in favor of leaving the statue in place, city staff said. Similarly, the majority of nonresidents who responded to the survey were also in favor of leaving the statue in place.

But some community members and leaders are fervently opposed to keeping it, arguing that it is a “physical reminder every day” of a time when Black residents of McKinney were not equal to their white counterparts.

Chris Thornton, who was appointed to McKinney City Council in December but was unable to serve because his residence is 10 feet outside the city’s District 1, said the statue has its finger pointing toward the east side of McKinney, which has historically been lower income and populated by more Black and Latino residents than the other side of Highway 5.

“I'm reminded of all ... the racial epithets that [were] hurled at us as children ... [in] the movie theater, reminding us that once [the movie] was over, we need to return back to where we belong,” Thornton said.

“And so I think it's time now, it's time for it [the statue] to go.”

The council did not reach a decision concerning the statue at its October meeting. Nor did council members reach consensus on how to move forward at their Feb. 2 meeting.

Four council members—Frederick Frazier, Rainey Rogers, Rick Franklin and Charlie Philips—voted to postpone a decision on how to proceed. The other three council members, Angela Richardson-Woods, Scott Elliott and Mayor George Fuller, voted against tabling the decision.

“How many more meetings do we have to have?” asked Richardson-Woods. “I don't know how much more information we need to have to make a decision. So, I don't agree with kicking it down the road.”

Frazier said it’s been difficult, after listening to both sides, to reach a decision.

“If we take a few more months, or however long we take to get to the end of that road, that's not going to make a big difference,” Frazier said. “But we can get to the end of the road together. And that's the thing that's going to make the difference.”

By Francesca D' Annunzio
Francesca D'Annunzio covers K-12 and higher education, development, planning and zoning, and transportation in Frisco and McKinney. She attended college at the University of Texas at Austin, where she reported for the Daily Texan and interned for the Austin Chronicle. When she's not reporting, she enjoys spending time outdoors and experimenting in the kitchen.


Frisco ISD has plans to launch a new virtual learning school for the 2021-22 school year. (Courtesy Canva)
Frisco ISD to launch virtual school for 2021-22

The Virtual School will be offered to families with students in grades 3-12 who wish to have their students continue to learn virtually.

(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Local air conditioning company looks to relocate to new facility in McKinney

The company will be able to expand its operations in the new facility, documents stated.

Empty Bowls has connected people and artists over the past nine years. (Courtesy Empty Bowls McKinney)
Empty Bowls event marks 10 years of fighting hunger in McKinney

The event has become so successful over the years that it now covers a large portion of Community Lifeline Center’s annual food costs.

Romeo's Pizza is looking to open in Frisco. (Courtesy Romeo's Pizza)
Romeo's Pizza coming to Frisco; steak, seafood lounge returning to Plano and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

As part of President Joe Biden’s plan to reopen schools safely nationwide, the department’s National School Lunch Program Seamless Summer Option is being expanded beyond the summertime. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
USDA extends free school meals provision through 2021-22 school year

Schools nationwide will be able to serve nutritious meals to all students free of charge regardless of eligibility through June 30, 2022, officials announced.

McKinney City Council approved zoning for an apartment complex in McKinney. (Courtesy city of McKinney)
McKinney City Council amends zoning for future apartment development

The complex will be located on about 9 acres south of the intersection at Heritage Drive and Pearson Avenue.

The company also has plans for another location in Northeast Fort Worth. (Courtesy Starbucks)
Starbucks coming to Fort Worth; Makers Gym opens in Frisco and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Continued growth at Legacy West in Plano is helping to boost the local economy, according to the county’s 2020 comprehensive annual financial report. (Courtesy Legacy West)
Collin County finances healthy despite pandemic, report shows

Considering challenges officials faced last year, Collin County’s bottom line is “extremely healthy,” an independent auditor told county commissioners at their April 19 meeting.

vaccine vial
Looking to get a COVID-19 vaccine? Collin County has thousands of openings this week

Thousands of doses of COVID-19 vaccines are sitting in Collin County freezers waiting to be claimed.

Independent Financial is expanding its McKinney headquarters. (Courtesy Independent Financial)
Independent Financial sets up future expansion with 17-acre buy in McKinney

The purchase brings Independent Financial’s corporate campus to nearly 30 acres, tripling the business’s original footprint.

The restaurant's menu focuses on chicken wings and sandwiches. (Courtesy Hoots Wings)
Hooters offshoot to open in Fort Worth; Oishii Sushi coming to Plano and more DFW-area news

Read the latest business and community news from the Dallas-Fort Worth area.

Early voting for the May 1 election runs April 19-27. (Community Impact staff)
Early voting opens for local races on May 1 ballot in McKinney

Contested races on the ballot include McKinney mayor, three McKinney City Council races, four McKinney ISD board of trustees race, four McKinney ISD propositions and three Collin College board of trustees races.