New law negates McKinney’s architectural standards

Two laws are changing building material standards and the timeline in which cities have to respond to plans and plats.

Two laws are changing building material standards and the timeline in which cities have to respond to plans and plats.

Image description
MCK0919-Lead2-Jump1
Image description
MCK0919-Lead2-Jump2
McKinney is re-evaluating its development processes after two laws were approved in the most recent legislative session that could change the look of the city and play a role in providing more affordable homes.

One law prevents government entities from enforcing building material standards stricter than those set by the national model code.

Another sets time limits for cities to respond to submitted plats and civil engineering plans. If cities do not respond to plats or plans within the allotted time, the submittals are automatically approved, according to the new law.

Both laws went into effect Sept. 1.

“The intention [of the laws] is positive … but I do think that anytime you take this sort of action, there’s unintended consequences,” said James Craig, president of Craig International, a real estate, brokerage, development and consulting company whose founder developed McKinney’s Craig Ranch community.

Some officials, including McKinney legislative consultant Angela Hale, said these bills take away local control.

Former McKinney City Council Member and builder Don Day said he is in favor of the two laws and does not anticipate them having much effect on McKinney.

“My experience [has] been that when the state comes out with these kinds of ordinances and laws, the city immediately turns and looks at their legal staff to find ways around it,” Day said. “And so at the end of the day, I don’t expect [the laws] to have a lot of impact.”

Building standards


Signed into law June 14, HB 2439 nullifies the city of McKinney’s architecture code, including a portion requiring the exterior of all commercial buildings to have at least 50% masonry—brick or stone.

The new law means builders can use different and sometimes newer materials, said Phil Crone, executive officer of the Dallas Builders Association.

Home or building costs could also potentially be lowered by the new law, Crone said. If a homebuilder no longer has to use brick siding, that may create cost savings that the builder will hopefully pass on to the buyer, he said.

“House Bill 2439 is an important bill to ensure that local governments do not mandate vendor driven and product specific mandates in construction that are in the direct or indirect prohibition of other products approved by national codes and standards,” state Rep. Scott Sanford, R-McKinney, said in an email.

Sanford said there are numerous examples across the state of “excessive and unnecessary” mandates resulting in higher home values. At least 12 McKinney residents, developers and elected officials signed a petition asking Gov. Greg Abbott to reject this bill. As of June 2, the petition had 936 signatures.

Exempt from the new law are buildings designated as historically significant or located within a Historic Neighborhood Improvement Zone, which must still abide by the city’s architecture code. The zone includes downtown McKinney as well as properties east of US 75, west of Airport Drive, north of Wilson Creek Parkway and south of US 380.

Homeowner associations, such as the one in Craig Ranch, may continue to enforce their own building guidelines, said Jennifer Arnold, director of planning for the city.

“We can continue to hold ourselves to a higher standard and require those that develop within our development to that same standard,” Craig said. “If we didn’t, we’d be doing ourselves a disservice.”

Arnold said the law’s influence on affordability will be no surprise.

“Now, people are open to us using lesser-quality materials, which cuts down on their upfront costs, which means they can then promote a product at a lesser price,” she said. “And I can see, on the surface, that sounds great and wonderful, but longterm, those lesser-quality products—they don’t maintain as well over time.”

Shot clock bill


House Bill 3167, also referred to as the “shot clock bill,” gives cities 30 days to respond to submissions of plats and plans.

The 30 calendar days begin when the city deems a submittal “administratively complete,” meaning the applicant provided staff with all information necessary to complete the process, Arnold said.

City staff will then review the submittal and either approve it as is or approve it with conditions. If staff recommends disapproval, or if a variance or specific use permit is requested, the submittal will go before the Planning and Zoning Commission or City Council.

These entities will either approve, approve with conditions, or disapprove the submittal. If action does not come within 30 days, the plan or plat is automatically approved, according to the law.

If an item gets sent back to the applicant, they can re-submit documents to the city at any time. Once a response is received, the city has 15 days to grant final approval or disapprove it.

Planning and Zoning Chair Bill Cox said he supports HB 3167 but worries it may put a burden on city staff.

“I don’t think city staff intentionally stalls a project,” he said. “They have a lot they’re working on. And … in a fast-growth area, they have so much that is thrown at them. It’s hard to get everything through the chute in a reasonable amount of time.”

In 2018, the city received 580 planning submittals. Nearly 285 submittals have been sent to the city from January to July in 2019, according to the most recent city data available.

In response to the law, the city may have to hire additional staff to stay on top of these submittals and re-submittals, Arnold said.

“We just don’t know yet,” she said. “We’re going to be keeping a pretty close tab on the bandwidth and how things are going.”
SHARE THIS STORY
By Cassidy Ritter

Cassidy graduated from the University of Kansas in 2016 with a degree in Journalism and a double minor in business and global studies. She has worked as a reporter and editor for publications in Kansas, Colorado and Australia. She was hired as senior reporter for Community Impact Newspaper's Plano edition in August 2016. Less than a year later, she took the role of editor for the McKinney edition.


MOST RECENT

School of Rock
School of Rock holds grand reopening at new McKinney spot

School of Rock is having a grand reopening for its new McKinney location from 5-8 p.m. Feb. 21 at 3201 S. Hardin Blvd. Ste. 210.

adobe stock image copper wire
McKinney’s Encore Wire announces expansion plans

Encore Wire Corporation, one of McKinney’s largest employers, announced future expansion plans in its quarterly earnings report, released Feb. 18.

The McKinney ISD board of trustees approved purchasing 1,049 new seats for an amount not to exceed $429,502 at its Jan. 24 meeting. (courtesy McKinney ISD)
MISD to replace auditorium seats at high school

McKinney ISD plans to replace the seats at the McKinney North High School auditorium.

Camille Borg Law PLLC relocated its office from Plano to McKinney. (Courtesy Camille Borg Law PLLC)
Camille Borg Law PLLC relocates to McKinney

Camille Borg Law PLLC relocated its office from Plano to McKinney.

The Avenue will include an outdoor plaza that will serve as a central gathering space with a food hall, water features and a container park. (Courtesy Thakkar Developers)
New 80-acre mixed-use development The Avenue coming to Allen across from McKinney's Hub 121

A new 80-acre mixed-use development called The Avenue is coming to the corner of Alma Road and SH 121 in Allen, across from McKinney’s Hub 121.

People with outstanding warrants can voluntarily resolve their cases without threat of arrest, according to the city. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
McKinney participates in statewide roundup targeting those with outstanding warrants

The city of McKinney is encouraging anyone with an outstanding warrant to take care of it as soon as possible in an effort to avoid arrest.

The business sells and leases used cars of various makes. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Wells Auto Group now open in McKinney on US 75

The business sells and leases used cars of various makes.

CrossFit SBR opened in January. (Courtesy CrossFit SBR)
CrossFit now open in McKinney's Stonebridge Ranch

A CrossFit location opened Jan. 27 at 4900 W. Eldorado Parkway, Ste. 158, McKinney.

Liberty Music Academy is now open in McKinney, offering music and voice lessons at reduced cost to lower-income families. (Courtesy Liberty Music Academy)
17-year-old opens Liberty Music Academy in McKinney

Liberty Music Academy is now open in McKinney, offering music and voice lessons at reduced cost to lower-income families.

The apartments, located at 1703 Rockhill Road, are expected to open summer 2021. (renderings courtesy JPI)
New 354-unit multifamily development underway on Rockhill Road in McKinney

Jefferson Rockhill, a new 354-unit apartment complex at the corner of Rockhill Road and Graves Street, is under construction in McKinney.

Florence will be located at 4001 Custer Road, McKinney, between the Discovery at Rowlett Creek and Storybook Ranch. (renderings courtesy Humphreys)
New mixed-use development Florence coming to McKinney on Custer Road

Florence will be located at 4001 Custer Road, McKinney, between the Discovery at Rowlett Creek and Storybook Ranch.

Back to top