Grapevine rezoning case highlights lack of affordable housing

Shady Oaks
An apartment project would have displaced residents of the Shady Oaks Mobile Home Park in Grapevine. (Renee Yan/Community Impact Newspaper)

An apartment project would have displaced residents of the Shady Oaks Mobile Home Park in Grapevine. (Renee Yan/Community Impact Newspaper)

Image description
In Grapevine, the median rent as of June 2019 was $2,144. With the income distribution in Grapevine, many renters have limited housing options in terms of the types of housing they can afford. (Sources: National Low Income Housing Coalition Out Of Reach 2019 Study, Grapevine Housing Authority, 2017 American Community Survey, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development/Community Impact Newspaper)
Image description
Renters in Grapevine's lowest income brackets only have a handful of options to choose from, and may have to settle for a waitlist. (Sources: city of Grapevine permits, Grapevine Housing Authority/Community Impact Newspaper)
A failed attempt to replace Grapevine’s Shady Oaks Mobile Home Park with a new three- to four-story apartment complex has prompted residents there to question the stability of their living situation as well as their relocation options.

Grapevine City Council members voted against the rezoning Oct. 15 after both council and the Planning and Zoning Commission raised concerns about the traffic impact of the 362 proposed apartments.

The case brought attention to the lack of affordable housing options in Grapevine, according to Shonda Schaefer, CEO of Grapevine Relief and Community Exchange, or GRACE. The 72 trailer lots at Shady Oaks are mostly inhabited by one or more low- to very low-income families, she said in a letter to City Council. More than 82% of the families have at least one adult working full-time, while most hold multiple jobs, she stated.

“Low-cost housing has got to be on the agenda for City Council,” she said. “They’ve got to start looking at options. It’s a problem, and it’s a continuing problem. And we’re not the only ones facing it.”

Gabriela Gomez, who lives at the Shady Oaks Mobile Home Park, said she was glad the apartment project was denied, but now that she knows the land could be sold and her family could be forced to move, she is concerned, she said through a translator.


Root Policy Research, a community planning and housing research firm, conducts studies of communities and provides strategies for fair housing. Its managing director, Mollie Fitzpatrick, said cities benefit from having a variety of housing options available.

“There are a lot of good reasons to have a balanced housing stock—just for the economic health of a community for people to work in the same place as well as providing life-cycle communities that work with people in all different phases of life,” Fitzpatrick said.

Lacking availability


On Oct. 15, JPI Construction sought permission from the city to rezone the 15 acres at Scribner Street and Shady Oaks Drive in Grapevine. As part of its proposal, JPI partnered with GRACE to help relocate the mobile home park’s residents if the plan were approved. GRACE hired a case manager to work with residents and possibly to help them transition into new housing, according to city documents.

However, Schaefer said it became apparent that there were not many options that would be affordable for these people.

“The average cost of rentals is significantly higher in Grapevine, and of the limited trailer parks, vacancies are almost non-existent,” Schaefer wrote in a letter to City Council.

Grapevine Mayor William D. Tate abstained from the Oct. 15 council discussion because of a conflict of interest. However, he said in an email to Community Impact Newspaper that the city offers more affordable housing options than its neighbors. The city has several mobile home parks in addition to the public housing offered through the Grapevine Housing Authority, Tate said.

The Grapevine Housing Authority works closely with GRACE and was aware of the situation with the Shady Oaks residents, GHA Executive Director Jane Everett said.

But because so many people need public housing, the Grapevine Housing Authority opens its waitlist only once a year, Everett said. This year, it opened for three days in August; during that time, 1,269 people applied.

This increase is possibly due to more agencies tracking housing authorities and their waiting lists to let clients know when they open, Everett said.

“They’re watching when housing authorities open, and they are publishing out there when, which housing authority, and the date and time that they’re open,” Everett said.

“We have 98 units,” she continued. “And if there’s 1,000 people on the list, that’s a tough thing. We’ve never had that many people before.”

There are usually about 300 people on the waitlist each year, she said.

Scott C. Hudman, a public affairs specialist for the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, said many HUD partners, including the GHA, have waitlists that “are literally years long.”

Hudman said one way to increase the supply of affordable housing could be to call for developers or investors to build housing through the state’s Low Income Housing Tax Credit Program, he said. This program helps buy down rents to make housing units more affordable.

“The best way for people to assist is to advocate for more affordable housing options,” Hudman said in an email.

Issues with affordable housing


GRACE Chief Program Officer Stacy Pacholick said while a few apartment options in Grapevine are more affordable, it is difficult to find an available unit. And if a resident or family were to find an available unit, they could still be passed over by the owner for someone else, she said.

Many apartment complexes require tenants to earn two-and-a-half to three times a unit’s monthly rent, she said. Tenants also typically have to pass reviews of their credit history, income and background.

With so many people waiting for an opening, renting does not provide a realistic option for many low-income residents, GRACE Client Services Manager Marcela Melendez said.

“There’s just an endless supply of people with demand for that type of housing,” said Melendez, who is also the case manager for the Shady Oaks Mobile Home Park.

The Oct. 15 rezoning case helped GRACE realize how much the housing options in Tarrant County had changed in just the last few years, she said.

“If you don’t already have the resources to be a buyer, and you’re renting, you’re looking at a market that is very, very expensive because that’s just the cost for an apartment,” Melendez said. “Supply and demand is really what’s driving it.”

Melendez pointed out that mobile home parks offer more housing options for larger families compared to apartments.

“Some of the mobile homes could accommodate bigger families and had multiple rooms,” she said. “A three-bedroom unit in an apartment would be exorbitant.”

Pacholick credited the city of Grapevine for being forward-thinking and implementing TEXRail to help people from other areas travel to work in Grapevine. However, she questioned whether that was a realistic long-term option.

“When a city is only using labor and the person has to go live in a bedroom community outside, they’re starting to ask the questions: ‘Is it worth it for me to make the transportation to that place of work when I’m only getting paid ‘X’ amount of dollars?’” Pacholick said.

Tate said TEXRail was designed to help encourage people living in other cities to use the train to get to their jobs in Grapevine. But the commuter rail service has not been used to its full potential, he said.

Moving forward


Pacholick said she would like to get people from outside the city together to brainstorm affordable housing options and ideas for Grapevine.

“There are experts in the field of housing that we need to bring in to talk to us about what that’s going to look like and what options we have,” Pacholick said.

City Manager Bruno Rumbelow said there are no immediate plans for assembling such a task force. The city also has no current plans to further discuss low-income housing options, he said.

The city is not aware of any other plans to redevelop the mobile home park site, Rumbelow said. JPI does not own the land, according to Pacholick, and because the city denied the rezoning proposal, the original owner maintains possession, Pacholick said. Multiple calls to JPI by Community Impact Newspaper were not returned.

JPI has already paid for assistance from a GRACE case manager for six months, so Melendez said she will continue to work with concerned Shady Oaks residents until the spring.

“What they had thought was a stable investment isn’t stable anymore,” she said.

Both Schaefer and Pacholick said if another development did come along for this site or any other site that could displace residents, they want GRACE to be involved.

“We’re hoping that the way this played out will be a model for future opportunities,” Pacholick said, “because now everybody has been made aware of how this affects the people that are already living in those units.”
By Miranda Jaimes
Miranda has been in the North Texas area since she graduated from Oklahoma Christian University in 2014. She reported and did design for a daily newspaper in Grayson County before she transitioned to a managing editor role for three weekly newspapers in Collin County. She joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2017 covering Tarrant County news, and is now back in Collin County as the editor of the McKinney edition.


MOST RECENT

Here are the latest coronavirus updates for Grapevine, Colleyville and Southlake. (Community Impact staff)
DATA: Confirmed COVID-19 cases in Grapevine, Colleyville, Southlake as of May 28

Tarrant County Public Health reported that the county has seen an increase of 491 new COVID-19 cases since May 21.

Since Richardson ISD announced school closures in March, Network of Community Ministries has been providing weekend meal boxes to families in need. (Courtesy Network of Community Ministries)
Reliant Energy donates $100,000 to Richardson, Grapevine nonprofits on front lines of fight against COVID-19

Network of Community Ministries and GRACE are two of the four organizations receiving donations.

Normally crowded toll roads are experiencing a decline in the number of motorists, according to data from the North Texas Tollway Authority. (Liesbeth Powers/Community Impact Newspaper)
North Texas Tollway Authority develops plan to mitigate unprecedented loss of revenue

Money-saving tactics include an indefinite hiring freeze and the delay of some projects, according to a spokesperson.

Outdoor venues in all Texas counties will be permitted to operate at up to 25% capacity starting May 31. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Spectators to be welcomed back to Texas outdoor sporting events May 31 at 25% of venue capacity

Venue owners must operate under guidelines that facilitate appropriate social distancing.

Tuesday Morning plans to close 230 of its 687 stores in a phased approach. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Development news and other top stories from this week in DFW

Read the most popular stories so far this week from Community Impact Newspaper's Dallas-Fort Worth coverage.

Each eligible child will receive $285 in benefits. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Some Texas students eligible for one-time federal benefit to aid with food purchases

Texas received approval from the U.S. Department of Agriculture to provide more than $1 billion in pandemic food benefits.

(Courtesy Dallas Fort Worth International Airport)
Dallas Fort Worth airport sees 45% decline in passengers during March

The Dallas Fort Worth International Airport saw steep declines in the number of passengers passing through its doors each month.

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar spoke to members of the Clear Lake Area Chamber of Commerce on May 27 about what the state's post-pandemic economic turnaround might look like. (Screenshot of May 27 virtual luncheon)
Texas comptroller predicts slow, steady economic turnaround post-pandemic

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar said the state entered the era of the coronavirus in a healthy financial situation, which bodes well for the future as reopening continues, but that Texans are not out of the woods yet.

Nursing facilities across Texas will be able to apply for federal funds to purchase devices to connect residents to friends and family. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Gov. Greg Abbott announces $3.6 million project to connect nursing home residents to families

Gov. Greg Abbott announced May 27 that $3.6 million will be provided to nursing facilities to purchase tablets, webcams and headphones to connect residents with family members.

Voters are encouraged to bring their own equipment in order to prevent catching or spreading coronavirus.(Graphic by Matthew T. Mills /Community Impact Newspaper)
State of Texas releases voter health checklist for polling stations in June and July

Texas Secretary of State Ruth Hughs released a checklist May 26 for voters to follow to help prevent the spread of coronavirus at polls.

Tuesday Morning plans to close 230 of its 687 stores in a phased approach. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Tuesday Morning files for bankruptcy; 2 Richardson locations to close

The company plans to close 230 locations, including stores in Dallas, Richardson, Irving, Arlington and Murphy.

Cinnaholic closed in Southlake at the end of April. (Wendy Sturges/Community Impact Newspaper)
Cinnaholic closes bake shop in Southlake

Cinnaholic announced at the end of April that it closed its location at 2704 E. Southlake Blvd., Ste. 102, Southlake.