Open Meetings Act case against Carroll ISD to return to trial court, according to ruling

A group of people attend a Carroll ISD school board meeting
Carroll ISD's temporary restraining order on work related to the Cultural Competence Action Plan has been lifted. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)

Carroll ISD's temporary restraining order on work related to the Cultural Competence Action Plan has been lifted. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)

Texas’ Second Court of Appeals has dismissed Carroll ISD’s appeal that attempted to toss out a civil suit brought by a Southlake parent alleging the district violated the Texas Open Meetings Act.

The dismissal of the appeal sends the case back to the 153rd District Court in Tarrant County for further proceedings. The Second Court of Appeals also ruled that the temporary restraining order in the case be lifted. Carroll ISD trustees now have the ability to discuss and work on the Cultural Competence Action Plan if they so choose.

A spokesperson for Carroll ISD declined to comment on Oct. 15 due to the ongoing litigation.

Attorney Dustin Fillmore is representing Carroll ISD parent and Southlake resident Kristin Garcia in the case against the district.

“The Court of Appeals got it right, and we are looking forward to being back in the trial court,” he said.


In an opinion dated Oct. 14, the appellate court dismissed Carroll ISD’s appeal. It stated that the district did not address Garcia's amended petition, which referenced school board votes on Aug. 3 and Sept. 14. Instead the district's complaint addressed the original petition that referenced only the Aug. 3 board vote. The court ruled the district's argument involving the original petition was moot.

The temporary restraining order was first signed in November 2020 by Tarrant County District Judge Josh Burgess, requiring all work on the plan—including clarification, revisions, publication or implementation—to cease. The order applied to the CISD board of trustees and any involved district subcommittees. The webpage on the school district's site about the District Diversity Council has also been removed.

The order by Burgess stated that by moving forward with revisions, the board “is attempting to deprive the plaintiff of the remedies available to her under” the Texas Open Meetings Act.

The appellate ruling is the latest development in Carroll ISD’s ongoing lawsuit for allegedly violating the Texas Open Meetings Act. The lawsuit was filed after the release of a series of text messages among five board members discussing how to approach the Cultural Competence Action Plan before the scheduled Aug. 3 board meeting.

As of February 2021, the district has spent more than $132,000 in legal fees related to the lawsuit.
By Sandra Sadek
Sandra Sadek covers the cities of Grapevine, Southlake and Roanoke as well as Carroll ISD for Community Impact. She graduated from Texas State University where she majored in journalism and international relations. She has experience working for several local papers including the University Star, the Katy Times, and the Fort Stockton Pioneer. When she's not on the ground reporting, she enjoys a good book and a hot drink. Follow her on social media @ssadek19.


MOST RECENT

street sign intersection
Amended Grapevine ordinance prohibits parking on portions of Franklin Street

As part of an amendment to Grapevine's ordinance, visitors will no longer be allowed to park on the north side of East Franklin Street.

Potential Earth and Roots CBD storefront
Colleyville City Council to consider special-use permit for CBD store

At its Dec. 7 meeting, the Colleyville City Council discussed whether to grant a special-use permit to a CBD store looking to open in Colleyville.

HTeaO opened a location just outside of Richardson on Oct. 15. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
HTeaO continues North Texas expansion with soon-to-open Southlake location

HTeaO is known for its variety of iced teas sold in a drive-thru store.

Tewbeleaux's Cajun Grill opened in Northwest Austin on Nov. 2. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Tewbeleaux's Cajun Grill opens first Central Texas location in Northwest Austin; House of Pies opens in Cypress and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 8.

Southlake Mayor John Huffman listens to a presentation on Carillon Parc from developer John Terrell on Dec. 7. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)
‘Legacy project’: Updated Carillon Parc plan given green light in Southlake, to break ground in 2022

After several delays and plan changes, Carillon Parc's slated groundbreaking is set for summer 2022.

Three women board TEXRail—a commuter train that runs between Dallas Fort Worth International Airport and Fort Worth—from the Grapevine Main Station on Nov. 9, 2021.  (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)
Grapevine, TEXRail transit plans set the stage for future growth

Despite reduced ridership over the last 18 months, officials remain optimistic about the commuter train’s ability to bounce back from the pandemic.

Classy Missy is now open across from Rainforest Cafe inside Grapevine Mills mall. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)
Women's ethnic wear store Classy Missy now open inside Grapevine Mills

Classy Missy sells varied selection of ethnic clothing and jewelry items, including bridal lehengas and sarees.

DotDotBang is now open inside Grapevine Mills. (Sandra Sadek/Community Impact Newspaper)
Pop culture, kawaii store DotDotBang now open inside Grapevine Mills

Frisco's DotDotBang opened a new location inside Grapevine Mills mall in November.

The Gringo's location in Katy is pictured. A new Conroe location is planned for late 2022. (Courtesy NewQuest Properties)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Gringo's restaurant confirmed for Conroe Waterfront Center; Austin’s longest-standing H-E-B to be rebuilt and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 7.

man at board meeting
Carroll ISD staff to receive one-time supplemental pay before end of year

Carroll ISD trustees are moving forward with an hourly-based one-time supplemental payment to address staff retention.

Bill Curci is a chief operating partner for Shuck Me, a seafood restaurant in Southlake. (Bailey Lewis/Community Impact Newspaper)
Despite unique name, Southlake seafood restaurant Shuck Me is fishing- and family-centric

Chief operating partner Bill Curci said what sets Shuck Me apart from other seafood restaurants is its authenticity.