Frisco officials look for compromise on tax caps

Property tax reform was among the top priorities laid out by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott for the 86th Texas Legislature.

Property tax reform was among the top priorities laid out by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott for the 86th Texas Legislature.

Image description
FRS-2019-03_28-03
Image description
FRS-2019-03_28-02
Image description
FRS-2019-03_28-01
The city of Frisco is working with Texas legislators on potential changes to a proposed property tax revenue cap to accommodate fast-growth cities.

The proposal, spelled out in two identical bills filed in the state House and Senate earlier this year, would cap the increase in property tax revenues for cities, counties and school districts at 2.5 percent. It would also require local taxing entities to obtain voter approval if they wanted to collect more than that percentage.

The proposal has drawn criticism from many local governments concerned about providing basic services. It has also attracted strong support from those looking to get a better handle on soaring tax bills. Debate over the proposal is ongoing, and changes are likely as it works its way through both legislative chambers.

Frisco leaders said rather than opposing the bill outright, they want to incorporate language to make it more feasible for growing cities. That is crucial in the case of Frisco, which has been growing steadily for years. In just the past two years, the city has added more than 20,000 residents.

“When you’re growing at 6 percent, absorbing that many people every year, you need to make sure your budget can grow appropriately with all the infrastructure that is needed,” Frisco Mayor Pro Tem Shona Huffman said.

Rep. Jared Patterson, R-Frisco, said his No. 1 priority since being elected in November is to provide property tax reform.

“We’re not limiting the sales tax revenue, and we’re not limiting other sources of revenue that cities receive,” Patterson said. “I’m proud to have a seat at the table to be discussing this bill to make sure we get a meaningful reform but also [that it] doesn’t impact core city services or county services.”

A similar bill was filed in 2017 by the Texas Legislature during a special session, but it failed. That bill proposed a 4 percent cap on property tax revenues.

“We think that 2.5 percent cap is too low; we don’t want any revenue caps,” said Chris Wallace, president and CEO of the North Texas Commission, an organization that advocates for the Dallas-Fort Worth area. “We don’t think that tying the hands of our cities, counties or community college districts into providing the core services that their citizens depend on is the way to go.”

Patterson filed HB 1221, which could expand what cities can spend their sales tax revenue on other than for economic development purposes, such as public safety and infrastructure.

“This would provide [cities] with more flexibility on their funding sources as a result of House Bill 2,” he said.

At a Jan. 31 news conference, Gov. Greg Abbott called the effort to cap the rollback tax rate at 2.5 percent “a testament to the voters of this state. The voters demanded this, and this demonstrates that the Texas Legislature is responsive to the needs of our voters.”

Revenue cap


The law currently allows taxing entities, such as cities and counties, to collect up to 8 percent in additional tax revenue year-over-year without voter approval. If a taxing entity wants to exceed 8 percent, it must get voters’ approval through a rollback election. If voters reject the increase, the entity would have to lower its tax rate so that the revenue collected is capped at what is allowed by state law.

Because property tax revenues are based on appraised values, a city or county could reach the threshold without changing its tax rate if property values are increasing significantly.

In Frisco, the average residential property has increased in value by more than $100,000 over the past five years.

Because of the way school finance is calculated, school districts are currently not limited by the 8 percent increase in property tax revenue. Instead, they have a cap on their tax rate. The maximum tax rate allowed is $1.67 per $100 valuation. Other factors go into calculating the rollback rate for school districts.

“School finance is so complicated, and because a school finance bill hasn’t been filed, we just don’t know what the overall impact would be,” said Dax Gonzales, division director of governmental relations with the Texas Association of School Boards. “But we do know if there are no other measures in place to help school districts, these bills would reduce a district’s ability to generate revenue.”

Gonzales said the bills could also be problematic for school districts because they may force them to spend money on elections every time they want permission to exceed the revenue cap.

Local impact


For Frisco, if the bills were to pass as they are, the city would need to cut its budget in order to make up for the revenue it would not receive from property tax growth, Huffman said. The largest expense in the city’s budget is personnel salaries, which would be the first place to cut, she said.

“You go to the biggest portions of the budget and see where to make cuts,” she said. “I want to make it clear that Frisco will continue to be the incredible community and city that it is, but budget cuts mean budget cuts.”

Huffman also said if the bills were to pass without any changes, the city would have difficulty continuing to offer a homestead exemption.

The city currently offers a homestead exemption of 10 percent, which gives a break to homeowners while allowing the city to collect the full amount of taxes from commercial properties.

Collin County is among the few government entities in Texas to pass a resolution that publicly supports the statewide proposal, according to the Texas Association of Counties. Collin County Judge Chris Hill said during a Feb. 4 commissioners court meeting that with good financial planning, cities and counties can have good services and a low
tax rate.

Denton County has not taken a public position on the bills.

The bills would also affect community college districts. Collin College already has one of the lowest tax rates among community college districts in the state.

“The affordability of a community college education is one of the most powerful economic engines driving the growth we’re experiencing in Texas, and no one wants to put that at risk,” District President Neil Matkin said in an email. “As community colleges are typically a very small part of the overall tax burden, including less than five percent in Collin County, it would not be unreasonable to exempt community colleges from the cap.”

Frisco ISD Chief Financial Officer Kimberly Smith said she does not know what the implications are for the district.

“We’re going to have to see the school finance bill before we can really begin to assess what impact the property tax bills are going to have directly on us,” she said.

The school district shares services with the city of Frisco. If the city’s ability to raise revenue is affected, it could indirectly have an impact on some of those shared services, such as school resource officers, Smith said.

Officials on both sides of the issue agree that state legislators need to first look at the school finance system in order to have meaningful property tax reform.

“If they are able to get some real reform in public school finance, that is where you are going to see the biggest relief in property taxes,”
Huffman said.
By


MOST RECENT

Restaurants, bars and some other businesses in North Texas will face a familiar slate of heightened restrictions after the region exceeded the Gov. Greg Abbott’s threshold for COVID-19 hospitalizations. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Bar closures, tighter business restrictions triggered in North Texas by COVID-19 hospitalizations

Restaurants, bars and many other businesses will face heightened restrictions after North Texas exceeded the governor’s threshold for COVID-19 hospitalizations.

Voters can cast ballots in person until Dec. 4 for early voting or vote on election day, Dec. 8. (Liesbeth Powers/Community Impact Newspaper)
Dec. 4 is last day for Frisco voters to cast early ballots in City Council runoff

Dec. 4 is the last day for Frisco voters to join the 2,000-plus people who have voted in the Dec. 8 City Council runoff since the beginning of early voting.

The number of homes listed for sale decreased in Frisco in October as compared to the same period in 2019. (Community Impact staff)
DATA: Here are the latest real estate trends in Frisco

The number of homes listed for sale decreased in Frisco in October as compared to the same period in 2019.

This shows the conceptual alignments for US 380 in Denton County. (Courtesy Texas Department of Transportation)
TxDOT releases 5 potential alignment options for US 380 in Denton County

TxDOT is studying five conceptual alignments for the project. The study area includes the area north of US 380; it includes the cities of Denton, Providence Village, Frisco, Little Elm, Aubrey, Krugerville and Celina and the towns of Prosper and Cross Roads.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced Dec. 2 that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has allotted 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines to the state of Texas. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
First allotment of COVID-19 vaccinations expected to arrive in Texas in mid-December

About 1.4 million doses of the COVID-19 vaccines have been allotted to the state of Texas and will arrive the week of Dec. 14.

Meadowcreek is Frisco's featured neighborhood for December. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
Meadowcreek is this month's featured neighborhood in Frisco

Meadowcreek, a 189-home community, is located north of Main Street and just to the east of FM 423.

The portion of Hall Office Park to be redeveloped is at the corner of Warren and Gaylord parkways. (Courtesy city of Frisco)
Frisco approves tax reinvestment zone to help fund parking garage, park as Hall Office Park redevelops

Frisco will participate in improvements planned as part of a Hall Office Park project that could more than triple the property’s value to nearly $2.2 billion over the next 20-30 years.

The new Children's Advocacy Center of Collin County facility is expected to open in fall 2020. (Courtesy Children's Advocacy Center of Collin County)
Children's Advocacy Center of Collin County to open new facility in McKinney

The need for the 40,000-square-foot facility comes from the projection that the number of children in the county will triple over the next 25 years.

Located at the south end of Teel Parkway, the 1135 Hike & Bike Trail will now be part of Iron Horse Trail. (William C. Wadsack/Community Impact Newspaper)
Frisco approves names for 3 neighborhood parks, 2 connected trails

Frisco City Council approved names for three neighborhood parks and two city trails during its Dec. 1 meeting.

The Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board has launched a campaign to address declining college enrollment numbers across the state since the pandemic started. (Courtesy Pexels)
Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board launches campaign to boost college enrollment

The decline in college enrollment across the state of Texas has prompted several agencies to partner up and create online resources for students and counselors.

Frisco ISD is slated to spend roughly $822,000 on blue strobe lights to enhance security systems. (Elizabeth Ucles/Community Impact Newspaper)
Frisco ISD to install blue strobe lights as security enhancement

Upon the request of campus administrators, Frisco ISD is planning to spend approximately $822,000 to install blue strobe lights on each district campus to visually alert students and faculty in lockdown situations.

As of Nov. 30, patients confirmed to have COVID-19 filled 16.1% of hospital beds in Trauma Service Area E, which includes Collin, Denton, Tarrant and Dallas counties among others. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
North Texas hovers above key COVID-19 hospitalization threshold as further restrictions loom

North Texas businesses could face additional restrictions—including the closure of some bars—if area hospitals do not see a reversal in the number of COVID-19 patients within a matter of days.