Which stay-at-home orders apply to North Texans? It depends on how strict governments are, legal expert says.

The stringency of various government orders amid the coronavirus pandemic determines which restrictions apply to North Texas residents. (Courtesy Fotolia)
The stringency of various government orders amid the coronavirus pandemic determines which restrictions apply to North Texas residents. (Courtesy Fotolia)

The stringency of various government orders amid the coronavirus pandemic determines which restrictions apply to North Texas residents. (Courtesy Fotolia)

North Texas governments are tightening restrictions on where people can gather as the rate of new coronavirus cases show no sign of slowing.

Meanwhile, stay-at-home orders issued by local governments are causing widespread business and restaurant closures.

Some may wonder how governments are supposed to enforce their orders when some cities lie in multiple counties. The same applies to residents who live and work in separate counties.

Attorney David Coale with Dallas-based Lynn Pinker Cox & Hurst said disaster declarations among city, county and state governments are meant to be in lockstep with one another.

"Counties and cities are very closely tied together," Coale said. "A city that has an emergency management plan in place really can't just pop up and say 'I'm gonna do my own thing separate.' They're constrained by laws they have already adopted that make them behave in a certain way during a catastrophe like this."


When orders vary between counties, it makes it difficult for county officials to ensure compliance, especially if a resident is mobile, he said.

"It's a real problem. ...The local entity has the power under emergency management plan to treat violations of its plan as ... basically a Class B misdemeanor," Coale said, adding that law enforcement officers are not always strict on issuing citations.

County orders will generally supersede a city's if the city order is less restrictive, according to the Texas Association of Counties.

"The state may issue more restrictive orders than the feds; the counties may issue more restrictive orders than the state ... A city may issue orders that are more restrictive than the county," a Texas Association of Counties spokesperson said in an email.

As of March 24, Dallas, Denton, Tarrant and Collin counties had issued stay-at-home orders. Those orders generally ban any gathering of people outside of one's place of residence but allow for certain essential business and government operations to continue. But some county orders are less strict on what qualifies as an essential business.

Collin County Judge Chris Hill, for example, said at a March 24 press conference that all businesses, jobs and workers are essential to the financial health and well-being of the local economy,

“Persons who are employed need to stay employed,” Hill said. “Persons who lack employment need to gain employment. Businesses that are able to remain open need to remain open.”

Alternatively, Dallas County has limited the scope of essential services to include things like sanitation, utilities, health care facilities, pharmacies and anything in the food supply chain.

Both Collin and Dallas Counties orders expire around the same date. But Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins said his order will most likely be extended beyond its April 3 expiration, as health conditions are expected to worsen.

“The estimate from the medical community is not two weeks, it’s months unfortunately,” Jenkins said at a March 23 news conference. “I hope that turns out to be wrong.”

Coale stressed that the Texas Government Code may not easily provide for coordination between counties amid a disaster.

"If there's a hurricane and it hurts Corpus Christi, they should be able to act and not bother Dallas," Coale said. "But if you have two counties next to each other doing separate things—that's just a problem, and it's a consequence of having something as decentralized as our government code is."
By Gavin Pugh
Gavin has reported for Community Impact Newspaper since June 2017. His beat has included Dallas Area Rapid Transit, public and higher education, school and municipal governments and more. He now serves as the editor of the Grapevine, Colleyville, Southlake edition.


MOST RECENT

bus
DART board considers more options for bus network redesign

This hybrid option was created after committee members expressed interest in a middle ground among ridership options.

Dr. Sam Rolon is a physician for Baylor St. Luke's Medical Group Creekside Family Medicine in The Woodlands. (Courtesy St. Luke's Health)
Q&A: St. Luke's physician shares advice on flu season, vaccine and prevention

The influenza vaccine is recommended for nearly all patients of all ages ahead of this year's flu season, Dr. Sam Rolon said.

Gov. Greg Abbott said Sept. 17 that data from Texas' 22 hospital regions will dictate when certain businesses can reopen at 75% capacity. (Screenshot of Sept. 17 press conference)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott: Retail stores, restaurants, office buildings, gyms can reopen at 75% capacity as early as Sept. 21

Nursing home and long-term care facilities will also be allowed to reopen for visitation as early as Sept. 24.

Almost Home Animal Rescue's Heather Weeks, left, and Amy Desler pick up North Texas Giving Day yard signs. (Courtesy Kim Leeson/Communities Foundation of Texas)
North Texas Giving Day to aid more than 3,300 nonprofits

The 18-hour online event organized by Communities Foundation of Texas allows people to support local nonprofits and causes.

One in five children and adults have a learning disability, according to statistics from the National Center for Learning Disabilities. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Q&A: National Center for Learning Disabilities expert discusses challenges of special education, remote learning during pandemic

The NCLD's director of policy and advocacy spoke about the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on special education students and their development in and out of the classroom.

Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts Glenn Hegar shared details on the state's financial situation ahead of the 2021 legislative session during a Transportation Advocacy Group virtual event. (Screenshot via Transportation Advocacy Group)
Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar discusses state budget, economic planning

Hegar shared his outlook on the state's finances and economic outlook in a September TAG Houston livestream.

Luby's announced Sept. 8 in a press release it plans to liquidate and dissolve the company and to sell its 60 locations across the state. The Texas-based restaurant chain remains open for dine-in and takeout service. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Luby's to dissolve company, sell restaurants; locations remain open for now

The family restaurant chain has 60 locations in Texas and first opened in 1947.

Dallas Area Rapid Transit’s bus and light rail services will operate on regular Sunday schedules on Labor Day. (Courtesy Dallas Area Rapid Transit)
DART to run on its holiday schedule for Labor Day in North Texas

Dallas Area Rapid Transit’s bus and light rail services will operate on regular Sunday schedules on Labor Day, Sept. 7.

Q&A: JJ Rocha of Texas Municipal League discusses long-term effect of COVID-19 on city budgets

The Texas Municipal League has spoken with cities and municipalities about how they are preparing budgets in the age of the coronavirus.

Volunteers for Covid Check-In have assembled more than 900 packages for seniors. (Courtesy Covid Check-In)
Students from UT Dallas send more than 900 care packages to North Texas seniors

COVID Check-In is a program that distributes care packages to seniors isolated by the coronavirus pandemic.

Downtown Lake Charles, Louisiana, had extensive damage to power lines and businesses in the wake of Hurricane Laura. (Courtesy KPLC-TV)
Donate emergency supplies for Hurricane Laura relief in Frisco on Sept. 5

The Southland Conference, an NCAA Division I athletic conference, is hosting the hurricane relief donation center on Sept. 5 at Toyota Stadium in Frisco.

Texans are preparing to cast votes in a slew of local, state and federal races Nov. 3. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Voting FAQ: Everything Texans need to know about voter registration, early voting, Election Day

Early voting in Texas begins Oct. 13 and ends Oct. 30. Election Day is Nov. 3.