Q&A: Austin ISD District 5 candidates address COVID-19, school closures and equity



AUSTIN ISD


Three District 5 candidates—Lynn Boswell, Jennifer Littlefield and Piper Stege Nelson—face off this November for a place on the Austin ISD board of trustees and to represent parts of Central and South Austin. The following responses were submitted by each candidate.

BOARD OF TRUSTEES DISTRICT 5










Lynn Boswell



Candidate bio: Boswell is the mom of a 2017 AISD graduate and a LASA senior. She has a law degree from UT and makes documentary films. She said her volunteer service in AISD began with the Casis PTA and includes several district-wide advisory bodies. She is also a past-president of the Austin Council of PTAs, and has served on Austin’s Juvenile Justice Workgroup, the Travis County Census 2020 Complete Count Committee and Just Fund It TX.




What are the biggest challenges facing District 5 right now, and how do those relate to what AISD faces as a whole?



LB: The impact of COVID is the most immediate challenge. Students everywhere are losing learning, facing mental health challenges, and missing important opportunities that school provides. That’s true in District 5, as well – especially for students with economic disadvantage (22% of D5 students), and special education needs (10.8%). Funding to retain strong teachers, support excellent academics, ensure extracurricular options and provide student support is another challenge – in District 5 and district-wide. AISD must increase funds through advocacy and by retaining students who are leaving AISD.



How would you grade the district’s COVID-19 response so far and what, if anything, would you have done differently if on the board?



LB: I applaud AISD for moving online last spring and acting quickly to provide meals and WiFi. However, AISD could and should have done more. I would have started with clear, frequent, empathetic communication, even about unknowns – from every campus and the district. AISD also should have mobilized a more ambitious civic response to this big civic problem, with science, creativity and collaboration. And I would have advocated strongly with the state – to protect funding, waive high-stakes testing and ensure local control over decision-making.



Austin ISD voted to close four schools last fall as part of its school changes plan, with an assumption that another proposal for changes would be coming in 2020. How do you feel about the original plan, and what would you like to see going forward?



LB: School closures were a mistake – made despite strong opposition, unmet promises and a failure to engage the community in truly collaborative ways. Future closures must be paused until we have data about the impact on affected students and on whether promised savings have been realized. We must also look at schools that remain on the potential closure list, supporting community-led efforts to find solutions created by the community, not imposed on the community.



The district opened an equity office last year. How would you like to see the office used going forward?



LB: We must begin with an honest, comprehensive equity assessment. A shared understanding of facts provides a foundation for working together on identifying problems and creating solutions. People in District 5 want and need to be part of that conversation – one that I have engaged with for years as a leader of the Austin Council of PTAs. The equity office must support a shift in AISD’s culture – to see every student’s potential and work to ensure all have what they need to succeed.



How can the district better retain its students as charter schools and other options continue to get established in AISD?



LB: AISD must take an honest look at why families choose charters, then work with families to address unmet needs. Community schools with wraparound services and on-site childcare are essential. So is a focus on valuing principals who build relationships and ensure that students, teachers, and families are valued. We must also welcome all families into our schools, starting with programs that serve new parents like read-alouds in school libraries. All families must know they belong.









Jennifer Littlefield



Candidate bio: Littlefield is the parent of two children who attend District 5 schools, and she herself is a graduate of Austin High School. She said she has been an active volunteer at Patton Elementary School, Small Middle School, and Austin High. Littlefield served on the 2017 bond committee, and said she is committed to serving District 5 and AISD with a focus on strategic planning and community-led decision making. She is also an experienced attorney with a legislative and policy background.




What are the biggest challenges facing District 5 right now, and how do those relate to what AISD faces as a whole?



JL: My top priorities are reopening safely, improving strategic planning, and addressing equity issues that will be exacerbated by remote learning. I believe strong community engagement is the core building block of public trust. It is an essential element of success in tackling equity issues and other challenges. I will focus on strategic planning to ensure we are spending every dollar wisely. I will prioritize competitive salaries for teachers, as well as strengthening academic and extracurricular programming that attracts families to AISD. I will also advocate for improving AISD’s special education and dyslexia intervention services.



How would you grade the district’s COVID-19 response so far and what, if anything, would you have done differently if on the board?



JL: AISD has struggled to effectively communicate its reopening plans with parents, teachers, and principals. Providing clear and timely information about reopening is critical to ensuring that families continue to choose AISD schools. AISD’s reopening plans should protect teachers, students, and staff by using public health expertise to guide reopening decisions. Until all students are able to safely be back in the classroom together, AISD should prioritize in-person learning for students with highest academic need while providing all students the opportunity for meaningful interaction with peers and teachers.



Austin ISD voted to close four schools last fall as part of its school changes plan, with an assumption that another proposal for changes would be coming in 2020. How do you feel about the original plan, and what would you like to see going forward?



JL: People support solutions they help create. Moving forward, AISD must improve its track record of including parents, teachers, and community stakeholders in the district’s decision making process. Any future school closure decisions must use a transparent criteria and community led decision-making. Further, the district’s top priority now should be focusing on supporting teachers and students with safe reopening plans and continued improvements to remote learning.



The district opened an equity office last year. How would you like to see the office used going forward?



JL: The equity office should be an integral part of district operations. The AISD Equity Officer should work with the Board and Superintendent to inform policy decisions. My experience as an Austin High graduate and now parent gives me the unique insight of what has improved in our schools over the last 25 years and what work remains to be done. Then and now, not all students in AISD benefit from the same educational opportunities. We must ensure that every student is set up for success in AISD.



How can the district better retain its students as charter schools and other options continue to get established in AISD?



JL: AISD faces competition from charters, private schools, and neighboring school districts. Our goal must be to provide strong academics, fine arts, athletics, and an inclusive and nurturing environment on every campus. We accomplish this by investing in competitive teacher salaries, continued bond investments to improve aging facilities, and programs that attract families to AISD, such as dual language, STEM programs, and Early College High School.









Piper Stege Nelson



Candidate bio: A native of Austin and a Bryker Woods alum, Stege Nelson is the mother of two AISD elementary school students and is the daughter of two teachers. She said she is a former middle school teacher and now serves as the Chief Public Strategies Officer at The SAFE Alliance. She has experience working with nonprofits and political action committees, and said over the past five years has served on the Austin Commission for Immigrant Affairs, the Lee Elementary PTA Executive Board, as the Board Chair of AIDS Services of Austin, and ACPTA.




What are the biggest challenges facing District 5 right now, and how do those relate to what AISD faces as a whole?



PSN: The biggest issues facing District 5 right now include safety (and primarily the pandemic and the AISD response), the hugely flawed communications from AISD, and the vast inequities facing all of AISD. Each of these issues is wreaking havoc on District 5 families, students, staff and teachers; we are seeing families leave the district to charters, private schools, pods, online learning and more. But these are all issues that have a huge impact on the AISD community as a whole.



How would you grade the district’s COVID-19 response so far and what, if anything, would you have done differently if on the board?



PSN: I give the district’s COVID-19 response a C. AISD’s roll out of devices and hotspots and meals was phenomenal. But the district should have planned for our fall reentry plans in the spring. AISD needs to push back on TEA on the forced return to face-to-face learning and on STAAR testing. Everyone that is able to learn remotely should, and for those students that cannot (kids with Special Education needs, without internet/device literacy, families with no childcare, etc.), we must find safe spaces for them to learn, and we must compensate the teachers and staff that can teach in person.



Austin ISD voted to close four schools last fall as part of its school changes plan, with an assumption that another proposal for changes would be coming in 2020. How do you feel about the original plan, and what would you like to see going forward?



PSN: The community must play an important role in the decisions surrounding their school. The 2019 School Changes Plan was a prime example of AISD not engaging the impacted communities in thoughtful ways, thereby leading to a steep erosion of trust. There must now be a rebuilding of trust - and this is particularly true with those communities crushed by our system’s historic racism.



The district opened an equity office last year. How would you like to see the office used going forward?



PSN: The Chief Equity Officer can help the district to find a good external entity to conduct an equity audit of the district, which will provide the Equity Office with the additional support and authority they need to prove what changes must be made. In addition, the district leadership (starting with trustees) must receive additional and intensive antiracism and inclusion training. And the Equity Office can also take the lead on disaggregating district data, creating regular dashboards that show district data on student performance, teacher promotion/retention, disciplinary actions, school communications, and more - all disaggregated by race, by school, and more.



How can the district better retain its students as charter schools and other options continue to get established in AISD?



PSN: First and foremost, if true public schools received the funding they deserved, all schools would have appropriate staffing and resources to meet the needs of their communities. The key is making sure that every family in AISD feels welcomed and supported at their public school so that we don’t have to worry about charters. AISD schools, supports, and systems need to fit the needs of kids to prevent families from fleeing to the charter school system.


By Nicholas Cicale
Nick has been with Community Impact Newspaper since 2016, working with the Lake Travis-Westlake and Southwest Austin-Dripping Springs editions. He previously worked as a reporter in Minnesota and earned a degree from Florida State University.


MOST RECENT

Campuses in Austin ISD will be closes to in-person learning the week after Thanksgiving break. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
All Austin ISD classes to be held online through Dec. 4

The district will also be providing free COVID-19 tests to staff and families Dec. 2-4.

Bicycles for public use are docked at a MetroBike station on Lake Austin Boulevard. Austin's $460 million Proposition B will include funding for additional bicycle lanes through the city. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Breaking down Austin's $460 million bond for bike lanes, trails, sidewalks and more

The bond will fun a bridge over Pleasant Valley Road connecting two ends of the Ann and Roy Butler Hike and Bike trail, among other improvements.

Local health leaders are urging caution ahead of Thanksgiving. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Ahead of Thanksgiving, Travis County health officials urge caution

Austin Public Health leaders say gatherings with people outside one's household held indoors and without masks pose the greatest risk.

Harini Logan, 10, won the 66th annual Express-News Spelling Bee at the University of Texas at San Antonio downtown campus on March 17, 2019. For 2021, the event is slated to be held in March at the Brauntex Performing Arts Theatre in New Braunfels. (Photo by Jerry Lara, courtesy the San Antonio Express News)
New Braunfels to host regional spelling bee and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from Central Texas.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announced a COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan for the state Nov. 23 for a vaccine he said could be available as soon as December. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott announces COVID-19 vaccine distribution plan

The vaccine could start being distributed "as early as next month," according to a Nov. 23 news release.

ACC’s Pinnacle Campus has been closed since 2018. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin Community College: There’s 'excitement' for a new Pinnacle campus

The Southwest Austin campus has been closed since 2018 due to poor facility conditions.

A new pedestrian path was build along Sawyer Ranch Road this fall. (Courtesy Hays County)
Sawyer Ranch Road shared-use path completed in Dripping Springs

The project is one of the first completed through Hays County's 2016 bond.

P. Terry’s Burger Stand is expected to open its long-awaited Pflugerville location this January. (Courtesy P. Terry's Burger Stand)
P. Terry's to open in Pflugerville in January and more Central Texas news

Read the latest Central Texas business and community news.

The Bridge at Turtle Creek apartment complex will provide more than 300 affordable units upon completion in 2022. (Rendering courtesy Journeyman Group)
Austin development updates: Apartments could replace two Rainey Street bars, 307 affordable housing units coming to South First Street area

A 569-foot apartment complex could replace Javelina and Craft Bar. Meanwhile, development continues in the St. Elmo area.

Trail of Lights (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
Holiday markets, strolls, tree lightings and Trail of Lights: 18 events in the Austin area in November and December

The Trail of Lights has gone drive-thru this year, while the Blue Genie Art Bazaar is taking free, ticketed reservations to adhere to social distancing requirements.

Austin voters approved a $7.1 billion public transit expansion Nov. 3 that will add bus and rail in Austin. (Design by Miranda Baker/Community Impact Newspaper)
After historic public transportation vote, here is what's next for Project Connect in Austin

Shovels won't be hitting the ground on the light rail and downtown tunnel for years, but work is getting started now after Austinites approved the $7.1 billion plan Nov. 3.

Laura Colangelo
Q&A: Laura Colangelo discusses challenges facing private schools during pandemic

Colangelo said private schools have adapted to remote learning and other obstacles in 2020 despite less revenue and a 9% decline in enrollment statewide.