What the first election for City Council since 10-1’s introduction means for Austin

Austin City Council meets at City Hall in Central Austin.

Austin City Council meets at City Hall in Central Austin.

Two years after Austin voters elected 10 council members from newly drawn geographical districts, voters are faced with the possibility of replacing nearly half of the expanded City Council.

On Nov. 8, the five council members who randomly drew two-year terms will have to be re-elected to build on the work they achieved since being elected. Prior to 10-1, six council members and a mayor were elected at-large, or citywide.

So how well has the council served Austin residents in the past two years?

Peck Young, one of the chief architects of Austin’s district-based political system, said it will take time for Austin City Council to find its footing—just as it did when San Antonio made a similar switch a few decades ago.

“I think this council is not unlike the council [was] in San Antonio and is still in the process of learning,” Young said.

Outgoing City Manager Marc Ott—who is serving in an advisory role until Oct. 31—said the council is indeed experiencing a learning curve, but it is not just the council that is adjusting.

“Going to a district-based change in election, I think the impact is pervasive across many things in our community,” Ott said. “I think it’s just going to take time to be able to see more clearly what those impacts are.”

A consensus seemed to emerge among Austin constituents interviewed for this story by Community Impact Newspaper: Moving to geographical representation was necessary for the city, but the system is not yet functioning at optimal levels.

With only one council member, Mayor Pro Tem Kathie Tovo, having prior council experience, most expected a period of transition—including Austin Neighborhood Council President Mary Ingle.

“We knew that was going to happen, but I didn’t know it was going to be this rough,” Ingle said.

New 10-1 council faces first re-electionCommittee system


An ongoing concern is that council business is not always conducted efficiently. Meetings tend to begin about 19 minutes after the scheduled 10 a.m. start time, and the median time City Council has adjourned its meetings is 7:20 p.m., according to meeting transcripts.

City code calls for adjourning meetings no later than 10 p.m. The council has to vote to extend time, which it has done 20 times in the 10-1 system.

In April the council adopted legislation limiting the amount of public comment time that could be spent on an agenda item—with some exceptions—to 90 minutes. One rationale behind that measure was council members and staff were often hearing the same testimony when they convened in committee meetings.

The committee structure stems from the first meeting of the new 10-1 council in January 2015 when council approved Mayor Steve Adler’s resolution establishing committees broken into policy areas.

Committees would discuss items to minimize time spent on those items during regular meetings. With 10 council committees, each council member sits on at least four committees, leads one and is vice chairperson for another.

Although well-intentioned, the council committees have not produced the desired result, said Ward Tisdale, Real Estate Council of Austin president.

“It has really created more meetings without better results,” he said.

Dewitt Peart, president and CEO of the Downtown Austin Alliance, said although the aspiration to be transparent is admirable having so many commissions and committees “drags out the process.”

“I think that’s been somewhat of a frustrating point, particularly for the business community where our voice seems to get washed,” he said.

New 10-1 council faces first re-election‘Downtown City Council’ no more


At an Oct. 6 meeting, the subject of coyotes inspired an exchange of words among council members about geographical representation.

As council discussed whether to keep the status quo on its animal-control policy with respect to coyotes, which some residents in Northwest Austin say pose a public safety threat, District 6 Council Member Don Zimmerman said the policy ought to be revisited because the last time it was set by council was in November 2014, two months before the 10-1 council was sworn in.

Zimmerman called the at-large elected body the “downtown City Council.”

“The people of this city rejected the old way of doing business, which is the downtown City Council,” he said. “Everybody was elected very close to downtown; the people revolted against that, so they said, ‘We want suburban representation.’”

Brad Parsons, a Northwest Austin sector representative for the Austin Neighborhood Council, said the 10-1 council is falling short of expectations, primarily because it is not skeptical of staff and lobbyists. In the past, he said Northwest Austin residents were disproportionately represented, but now the opposite is true.

“The average in person in West Austin is maybe getting less reception down at City Hall now,” Parsons said.

 
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

The Microtel Inn and Suites is located in Southeast Austin, only a 4.5-mile drive from the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport. (Courtesy Google Maps)
Zoning concern prevents Austin from moving forward with second conversion of hotel to homeless shelter

Officials have already indicated they are eyeing other hotels and motels for purchase and conversion into homeless shelters.

This is the Estancia property that was purchased by Texas Children's on Dec. 10. (Courtesy Texas Children's Hospital)
Texas Children’s Hospital eyes further expansion in Austin with purchases of land

Houston-based Texas Children's Hospital has closed on the purchase of two plots of land in the Austin area.

Williamson County Commissioners Court established the primary early voting locations Dec. 10. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Most early voting polling locations finalized for March 2020 primaries

Court establishes primary early voting locations ahead of March 2020 elections.

AMC Dine-In Tech Ridge 10 will open Dec. 12. (Courtesy AMC Theatres)
AMC Theatres to open Dec. 12 in Tech Ridge center in North Austin

AMC Theatres opens new 10-screen location in North Austin's Tech Ridge center

The Texas Department of Transportation is widening RM 2222 at RM 620 to provide traffic congestion relief in the Four Points area. (Courtesy TxDOT)
TxDOT plans groundbreaking for Dec. 11 on RM 620 bypass project

TxDOT breaks ground on RM 620 bypass project to provide traffic congestion relief in Four Points area.

Common winter allergies in Texas are caused by pollen from the Ashe juniper—also known as a mountain cedar. The tree is native to the area. (Nicholas Cicale/Community Impact Newspaper)
As pollen counts rise in Central Texas, learn about cedar fever and allergy prevention

As temperatures cool heading into the winter season in Central Texas, pollen counts from Ashe juniper trees begin to climb, causing seasonal allergies referred to locally by residents as “cedar fever.”

Primary Election Day is March 3, 2020. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Here is your list of local, state and national 2020 primary candidates for Northwest Austin

Read the list of candidates who filed for the March 3, 2020 primary election in Northwest Austin.

The dealership will be located on RM 620 just west of Parmer Lane in Northwest Austin. (Rendering courtesy Park Place Dealerships)
Jaguar, Land Rover dealership under construction on RM 620 in Northwest Austin

Construction is underway on the first Austin-area Park Place Dealership, which will sell Jaguars and Land Rovers.

Austin Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza, at the lectern, speaks at a November 2017 press conference. Garza filed her candidacy for Travis County attorney on Dec. 9.
Delia Garza files for Travis County attorney race, will finish term as Austin Mayor Pro Tem

Austin Mayor Pro Tem Delia Garza filed her candidacy paperwork Dec. 9 to run for Travis County attorney as a Democrat.

The Hyatt Place hotel in the Four Points area should be complete by April, according to the owner. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Hyatt in Four Points area slightly delayed, expected to begin booking rooms by May

On Dec. 6, Karedia said that due to some normal delays in construction, the timeline has been stretched slightly.

Byron Smith, left, and Tim Manson are planning to break ground on their new storage business called XSpace in late January. (Brian Rash/Community Impact Newspaper)
Australian businessmen betting on success of innovative storage model in western Travis County

A primary difference between their model and more traditional storage models, they say, is the fact that their units are for sale and not for rent. But there are other differences.

Back to top