Approval of air-quality permit for Comal County's Vulcan Quarry reversed in district court

Vulcan Materials operates a quarry located in San Antonio. (Courtesy Google Earth)
Vulcan Materials operates a quarry located in San Antonio. (Courtesy Google Earth)

Vulcan Materials operates a quarry located in San Antonio. (Courtesy Google Earth)

A judge in the 459th District Court in Travis County has ruled in favor of concerned citizen groups more than one year after filing a lawsuit opposing a proposed quarry owned by Vulcan Construction Materials LLC.

The lawsuit, filed Feb. 14, 2020, by Friends of Dry Comal Creek and Stop 3009 Vulcan Quarry against the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, aimed to reverse the TCEQ’s November 2019 approval of air-quality permits submitted by Vulcan for its proposed rock-crushing facility.

Plaintiffs raised concerns that the new facility could increase area air pollution, pose a threat to the Edwards Aquifer or lead to decreased property values in nearby neighborhoods, according to a press release from Stop 3009 Vulcan Quarry.

Judge Maya Guerra Gamble heard the case on Dec. 8 before ruling in favor of the plaintiffs March 5, calling for the TCEQ’s approval of the air permit to be reversed and vacated.

According to the ruling, the TCEQ’s determination that the proposed plant’s crystalline silica emissions would not negatively impact human health was not supported by substantial evidence.


Additionally, the judge ruled that Vulcan's air-dispersion modeling did not adequately account for cumulative impacts or road emissions.

Attorneys for the plaintiffs are now responsible for drafting a final order, according to a press release from Stop 3009 Vulcan Quarry, which will be presented to the defendants. A hearing has been set for April 2 should the parties disagree on the final order, and the TCEQ and Vulcan will have the option to appeal the decision to the 3rd Court of Appeals.

In addition to the air-quality permit, the quarry must also receive approval from the TCEQ for a water pollution abatement permit in order to begin operations.
By Lauren Canterberry

Reporter, New Braunfels

Lauren joined Community Impact Newspaper as a reporter in October 2019. After graduating with a degree in journalism from the University of Georgia in Athens, Georgia, Lauren was a freelance journalist and worked as a college English teacher in China. At CI, Lauren covers education, local government, transportation, business, real estate development and nonprofits in New Braunfels.



MOST RECENT

Drive under the holiday lights through Jan. 2 at Santa's Ranch in New Braunfels. (Courtesy Santa's Ranch)
12 things to do in and around New Braunfels this holiday season

Here are just a few events in and around New Braunfels, places to meet with Santa and more this December.

Both proposed maps would reallocate portions of District 2 into District 6 to better balance the population. (Courtesy City of New Braunfels)
City of New Braunfels releases potential redistricting maps ahead of committee recommendation

Both proposed maps would reallocate portions of District 2 into District 6 to better balance the population.

The closures are related to NBUs Castell Avenue 24-Inch Water Line Project. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
New Braunfels Utilities announces December road closures

The closures are slated to conclude buy the end of December.

Consuelo Mendez Middle School has consistently received poor ratings from the Texas Education Agency. (Community Impact Newspaper)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: State could take over AISD school board if poorly-rated campus does not improve; new furniture store to open in McKinney and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 3.

Derrick Chubbs is leaving Austin for a food bank in Florida. (Courtsey Central Texas Food Bank)
Central Texas Food Bank CEO Derrick Chubbs steps down

Derrick Chubbs is leaving Austin for a food bank in Florida.

Eden Hill offers independent and assisted-living, memory care and nursing home/care. (Courtesy Eden Hill Communities)
Many options based on needs are available in our 2021 senior living guide for New Braunfels

These are just some of the senior living options available in the New Braunfels area.

The district has taken the first steps to complete projects approved by voters during the November bond election. (Lauren Canterberry/Community Impact Newspaper)
Comal ISD begins work on approved 2021 bond projects

The district has taken the first steps to complete projects approved by voters during the November bond election.

The school board will consider whether to call a special election to fill the vacancy or make an appointment. (Zara Flores/Community Impact Newspaper)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Hays CISD to hold special meeting on resignation of board member; Montgomery approves plan for downtown and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 2.

New Braunfels Utilities is unrolling several ways to help customers navigate complications from the last winter storm and prepare for the possibility of another. (Community Impact Newspaper Staff)
NBU outlines preparation for another severe winter storm

The utility outlined several initiatives for better readiness.

Abby Popp is a chiropractor at The Wellness Way in New Braunfels. (Courtesy The Wellness Way)
The Wellness Way now open in New Braunfels

The new clinic offers comprehensive testing and personalized treatment plans.

Tomball City Council approved a development agreement with Lovett Industrial for 240 acres at Hwy. 249, Rocky Road Nov. 29. (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
CI TEXAS ROUNDUP: Tomball City Council approves development of 240 acres at Hwy. 249, Rocky Road; JLB Eatery coming soon to Katy and more top news

Take a look at the top five trending stories across Community Impact Newspaper’s coverage areas in Texas as of Dec. 1.