Comal ISD joins neighboring districts to advocate for school finance reform


After receiving an $8 million bill from the state for recaptured taxes last year, Comal ISD Superintendent Andrew Kim is championing school finance reform in the 86th Texas legislative session.

“We need to address both school finance and rising property taxes statewide,” Kim said. “Fortunately, homeowners in Comal ISD receive the benefit of an additional 20 percent homestead exemption offered by the district, which lowers their valuation and ultimately their tax bill.”

Recapture, also known as “Robin Hood,” redistributes tax dollars rom property-wealthy school districts to those that are considered property-poor.

“The problem is that the current system of recapture, or Robin Hood, penalizes growing districts like Comal ISD who are doing a good job at running efficiently while also achieving high academic progress,” Kim said. “We need a school finance system that supports what we are doing and allows us to keep our locally generated revenue to sustain our growth.”

State Rep. Kyle Biedermann, R-Fredericksburg, filed House Bill 729 on Jan. 10 that aims to “stop excessive Robin Hood theft,” according to a news release from Biedermann’s office.

If passed, the bill will decrease the amount of recaptured taxes paid by Texas school districts by allowing them to keep—at minimum—the state average of funding per student.

“Most people are surprised that Robin Hood schools are often unfairly penalized and end up with less than the state average of funding per student after recapture. This inequity hurts many districts throughout the state,” the news release states.

The proposed bill is the result of discussions by a working group composed of representatives from Comal, Boerne and Fredericksburg ISDs.

“It is important to bring more equity and fairness to public school finance,” Biedermann said in a statement. “We must focus on solutions that keeps more local dollars in the district that they originate from, while also sharing with districts that have less taxable value. I’ve been working tirelessly with school districts in my community, and I’m proud to have so many of them supporting this legislation. Their ideas created this bill, and I want to congratulate them on their hard work.”

Share this story
1 comment
  1. I recently sent a letter to dr. Kim addressing the issue of pay raises the support services in Comal ISD – transportation, nutrition, maintenance, custodial workers. He seems sincerely to be working towards this. Last year inflation average 2% in the nation. We only received a 1.5% raise. Next year’s projected inflation is also at around 2%. Many of us and support services are at the lower end of the middle-class Spectrum and this makes it more difficult for us to keep up with our basic necessities. So in reality this Robinhood tax is also stealing from the poor, as it affects pay raises in the district. Somehow these salaries need to be addressed so as to take care of the little people that keep CISD rolling.

Leave A Reply

Rachel Nelson
Rachel Nelson is editor of the New Braunfels edition of Community Impact Newspaper. She covers local business, new development, city and county government, health care, education and transportation. Rachel relocated to Central Texas from Amarillo in 2009 and is a graduate of Texas State University's School of Journalism and Mass Communication.
Back to top