In Austin City Council’s District 4, candidates discuss addressing homelessness and mental health

From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)
From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)

From left: Incumbent Greg Casar is facing off against Louis C. Herrin III and Ramesses Setepenre for the District 4 Austin City Council seat. (Courtesy ATXN)

Prior to the pandemic, homelessness topped Austin City Council’s priority list on issues to address. The problems associated with people living on the streets grew as the city became swallowed by the coronavirus public health crisis.

By most accounts, the pandemic is not going away soon. Homelessness is still likely to be a top issue in a post-pandemic world, and City Council will have to continue prioritizing solutions. The three candidates running for Austin City Council’s northeast District 4 seat this November laid out their position on how to address homelessness Sept. 23 during a candidate panel hosted by the nonpartisan League of Women Voters.

Incumbent Greg Casar is seeking his second consecutive four-year term on City Council after initially winning a two-year term in 2014 as part of the inaugural 10-1 council dais. Louis C. Herrin III an environmental engineer who has lived in the district for 30 years, and Ramesses II Setepenre, a former contract security guard at Austin City Hall who said he has experienced homelessness, have stepped in to challenge Casar’s re-election bid.

In addressing the mental health needs of the homeless population, none of the candidates believe the city has done enough. Casar and Herrin blamed a lack of resources and limited help from the state and federal government. Setepenre said the city has not addressed the root causes of homelessness and pointed to a lack of social capital and access to quality health care.

However, Casar pointed to his work on City Council during the recent budget session, during which council pulled money from the police department to fund mental health response and create a new 911 dispatch option for mental health crises. With the libraries closed during the pandemic, a place people experiencing homelessness often go for services, Casar said the city needed to ramp up its mental health response.

Herrin criticized the state for failing to help, saying state officials have been “dumping a lot of the mental health problems on the city.” He said the city needs to work on lobbying the state for more help and more funding and set up a “better system” for managing the homelessness situation.

Setepenre said as the only candidate who has experienced homelessness, his perspective on the issue was not “armchair anthropologist.” He said the issue was more complex than mental health and that the city needed to attack homelessness at its foundation and address drug use and lack of family support. The city needs to move beyond a “one-size-fits-all” response, Setepenre said, and bring more experts and professionals to the table.

City Council’s decision to lift the ban on public camping in 2019, opening the ability for those experiencing homelessness to set up camp in more visible spaces, polarized the city in ways elected officials said they had not previously seen. The issue has yet to settle. Encampments have become more visible throughout the city. Between 2019 and 2020, the number of unsheltered homeless individuals grew by 45%. Residents have continued to voice concerns over the city’s handling of what officials one year ago called a “homelessness crisis.”

Herrin said he strongly opposes City Council’s decision to lift the camping ban. He said he believes that the city needs to do a better job of actively engaging the homeless population and trying to get them housed and into workforce development programs that will help them get on their feet.

Setepenre said he understood the concerns around the growing visibility of homeless encampments but that complaining about it is not the way toward progress. He claimed he has personally opened up his one-bedroom apartment for homeless individuals to stay. Setepenre said allowing people to camp might be “mercy” but that it was not going to solve the issue.

Casar, who helped lead City Council action on lifting the camping ban, said he believes the city can effectively end homelessness in the city without violating “anyone’s human or civil rights in order to get there.” He called American homelessness a relatively new problem that worsened after the federal and state governments began pulling money out of mental health and social safety net programs in the 1980s. Casar said the city needed to “make up for lost time” and supported the efforts to pump money into housing services and purchasing hotels to convert into housing-focused homeless shelters.

Election Day is Nov. 3. Early voting runs from Oct. 13-30. Check back with Community Impact Newspaper for more updates on Austin City Council races.
By Christopher Neely
Christopher Neely is Community Impact's Austin City Hall reporter. A New Jersey native, Christopher moved to Austin in 2016 following years of community reporting along the Jersey Shore. His bylines have appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Baltimore Sun, USA Today and several other local outlets along the east coast.


The Queen Beak (left, $9) is available all day and is made with a fried chicken breast, cayenne black pepper honey and bacon-infused chipotle mayo. The firebird ($10, dinner-only) is a hot chicken sandwich with goat cheese and dil aioli, spicy sweet pickles and cilantro. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
After nearly getting into the smoothie business, Bird Bird Biscuit owners have found a niche with comfort food

Co-owners Brian Batch and Ryan McElroy met when Batch was working at Thunderbird Coffee, which McElroy owns. Next year, Bird Bird will open a location on Koenig Lane.

The Central Texas Mobility Authority's board of directors paused a scheduled 5-cent increase per segment on the MoPac Express toll lanes. (Community Impact staff)
Tolls on Central Texas roads will increase Jan. 1; MoPac base rate will stay the same

The Central Texas Mobility Authority's board of directors paused a scheduled 5-cent increase per segment on the MoPac Express toll lanes.

Moody's Kitchen + Bar is now open along The Drag in Austin. (Courtesy Cassandra Klepac Photography)
Now open in downtown Austin and The Drag: Moody's Kitchen + Bar, three new coffee shops and more

Mahmud "Moody" Ugur changed over his MezzeMe Turkish Kitchen location on The Drag to a bar and restaurant with weekday and UT football gameday happy hour specials.

The Austin School of Fashion Design, or ASFD, relocated from North Austin to Georgetown in October. (Courtesy The Austin School of Fashion Design)
Austin School of Fashion Design moves to Georgetown and more Central Texas news

Read the latest business and community news from the Austin area.

Ahead of Election Day, Nov. 3, four Austin City Council members have asked Austin Police Chief Brian Manley for more information on the police department's plans to respond to possible protests. (John Cox/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin City Council members ask police to detail response to possible Election Day protests

The four council members said protests from the spring represented "a failure to keep people safe" and asked Chief Brian Manley for more information to how police would respond to potential protests around Nov. 3.

After a significant drop soon after the onset of COVID-19, home sales nationally have risen in the past few months. Austin has followed the same trend, but in a more pronounced manner. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Austin's economy is crawling slowly back to recovery. So why is the housing market booming?

Low interest rates, constricted supply and continued population growth have accelerated the sellers' market in Central Texas, leaving 26% fewer homes on the market this September than there were at the same time last year.

Local violinist Shawn LeSure
HAAM gets funding boost from Central Health to enroll musicians of color in health coverage

Days ahead of open enrollment beginning in the health care marketplace, Travis County’s health care district and the Health Alliance for Austin Musicians struck a deal to secure increased health care coverage for the city’s musicians of color.

Less than a week ahead of the Nov. 3 Election Day, Cihan Varol, an associate professor with Sam Houston State University's Cyber Forensics Intelligence Center, shared insight on foreign election hacking and what it means for voters. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Q&A: Sam Houston State University cyber forensics intelligence expert talks foreign election hacking ahead of Nov. 3

"There is a very slim chance that the hackers can change vote count, but they can definitely influence people to believe that they did manipulate it," Cihan Varol said. "If election fraud is going to happen, it'll be because of disinformation."

Face coverings are not required for those entering polling places in Texas during the general election. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
UPDATED: U.S. appeals court pauses decision voiding face covering exemption at polling places

The court temporarily stayed a district judge's decision to void an exemption to Gov. Greg Abbott's statewide face covering order concerning polling places.

The Texas Book Festiva will take place virtually this year.l (Courtesy Bob Daemmrich Photography)
Fall events in Central Austin: Texas Book Festival goes virtual, paddle-up trick-or-treating on the lake and more

The October and November calendar include the Halloween paddle on Lady Bird Lake and a new event from the organizers of Babes Fest.

Travis County Clerk Dana DeBeauvoir speaks to reporters Oct. 28 at the Millennium Youth Entertainment Complex in East Austin. (Jack Flagler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Travis County breaking voting records; clerk expects turnout to climb as high as 80%

More than 480,000 ballots have been cast in Travis County, surpassing the total from the 2016 presidential election.

Photo of new construction in process
South Austin developer sues city in ongoing saga to improve permitting process

An Austin developer alleged the city circumvented a state law that requires permitting to take place within 30 days.