Why relocating the Columbus Crew might be Austin's best shot at Major League Soccer

The city of Austin conducted an online survey to learn more about residents' opinions regarding Major League Soccer coming to Austin.

The city of Austin conducted an online survey to learn more about residents' opinions regarding Major League Soccer coming to Austin.

The Greater Austin Chamber of Commerce issued a call to action to city leadership Friday: Act now, or the opportunity to bring Major League Soccer to Austin will go away.

Why the rush? If Precourt Sports Ventures—the MLS ownership firm that runs Columbus Crew SC but wants to move to Austin—decides to keep the team in Ohio, shouldn't the new momentum around professional soccer here prop the city up for an expansion bid? Not so fast.

Here's an explainer on Austin's chances at an MLS franchise:

MLS expansion


Once on the brink of folding, MLS has grown from 10 teams in 2004 to 23 in 2018. The league's 24th team, a David Beckham-owned club in Miami, will begin play in 2020.

MLS is in the final stages of a two-team expansion phase. The league awarded Nashville its 25th spot in December and is weighing bids from ownership groups in Cincinnati, Detroit and Sacramento for its 26th team. Failing to win an expansion bid would not necessarily preclude a group from again bidding when the 27th and 28th teams are selected.

So could a wealthy investor in Austin step up and offer the league upward of $150 million in expansion fees like the Nashville group is reported to have done—not to mention have a stadium site secured? Anything is possible, but past efforts from such organizations as the Austin Aztex have sputtered before getting anywhere close.

What's more, the current expansion candidates have all had success at the minor league level. FC Cincinnati draws more than 21,000 fans per game, Detroit City FC is a popular amateur club, and Sacramento Republic FC has built a strong fanbase the past six years. The Austin Aztex would draw a few thousand attendees to home games at House Park before going on hiatus in 2015 and later dissolving.

San Antonio, Austin's rival down the I-35 corridor, has it beat there. The city has consistently fielded a men's pro team since 2010. The San Antonio Spurs ownership group bought the club in 2016, and the city of San Antonio and Bexar County purchased its stadium with an eye toward eventually fielding an MLS franchise.

San Antonio made an expansion bid in 2017 but failed to make the final cut. If the Crew does not move to Austin, San Antonio FC could be in the running for the 27th or 28th MLS team.

There's also no guarantee that MLS will continue expanding beyond 28 teams, so the potential relocation of the Crew may be Austin's only shot at an MLS franchise.

Relocation within the league


Relocation of teams in MLS is rarer than, say, in the NFL, but it has happened before.

In 2005, the San Jose Earthquakes moved to Houston, drawn to the city for its potential to accommodate a soccer-specific stadium, which the San Jose franchise lacked. The San Jose club was revived two years later, and the Houston Dynamo were recognized as a new expansion franchise.

The Earthquakes now play in the built-for-soccer Avaya Stadium.

There was an earlier attempt to make Austin big-league-ready. But the late aughts version of the minor league Austin Aztex ended up moving to Orlando, securing a stadium deal, getting an MLS expansion slot, and the rest is history.

Columbus Crew's place in national soccer history


The Columbus Crew has its own soccer stadium. In fact, the club was the first in the league to build one back in 1999.

The nearly 20,000-seating-capacity facility holds a special place in U.S. Soccer lore. The stadium became an unofficial home turf for the U.S. Men's National Team. In 2001, it hosted the first of many 2-0 victories against Mexico, the team's biggest rival, on the road to World Cup qualification.

The following years saw an era of regional dominance for the U.S., which seemed unbeatable at the Ohio stadium—until falling 2-1 to the Mexicans in the most recent World Cup qualification campaign. The U.S. ultimately failed to qualify for that tournament, set to take place in Russia this summer.

By today's standards, the Columbus Crew's Mapfre Stadium was built on a modest budget—$29.5 million, according to one site, or about $44.3 million in today's money. Compare that to the $350 million Los Angeles FC is spending to build its soccer-first stadium.

The Crew has a passionate fanbase and a winning history in MLS, but the league says it is underperforming in critical business metrics.

A soccer stadium in the urban core


Precourt Sports Ventures CEO Anthony Precourt has said the desire to build a new, urban stadium was at the heart of the club's decision to explore relocation.

MLS conducted market research on Austin, notably with a survey sent out to many fans of the sport living in the city. Respondents were asked where they thought a soccer stadium should be built. The league has in recent years favored downtown stadiums, in walkable range from bars and restaurants, over suburban sites.

 

But PSV has an uphill battle if it wants a stadium in the traditional urban core. The firm took Butler Shores, 200 S. Lamar Blvd., Austin, off its shortlist after mounting pressure from the public rejecting the parkland's use for private enterprise.

Now Austin residents are rallying behind an effort to protect another piece of parkland on PSV's list: Roy G. Guerrero Colorado River Park, 400 Grove Blvd., Austin.

The other public property PSV is considering is 10414 McKalla Place, a vacant city-owned site near The Domain off Braker Lane and Burnet Road.

The city of Austin has an indefinite timetable for studying the feasibility of the city-owned properties.

According to the Austin Chamber's resolution, PSV aims to move the Crew to Austin in time for the 2019 season, which is slated to begin in March 2019.
By


MOST RECENT

The monthslong search for Austin's new police chief is expected to wrap up before the end of August. (Ben Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Search for Austin's next top cop narrows to 7 finalists; new chief to be named by end of August

Seven finalists from across the country remain in the search for Austin's next police chief, the city announced July 26.

Austin ISD will offer virtual learning options to students in kindergarten through sixth grade for the 2021-22 school year, according to a July 26 news release from the district. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Austin ISD plans to offer virtual learning for some students in 2021-22 school year

The district changed course on virtual learning after rising case counts led the local health authority to revert to Stage 4 guidelines, including wearing masks.

Chick-fil-A will open a location in downtown Austin on July 29. (Courtesy Chick-fil-A)
Chick-fil-A coming to downtown Austin; Dutch Bros Coffee opens in Round Rock and more Central Texas news

Located at 600 Congress Ave., Ste. C150, the newest outpost for the fast-food fried chicken giant is locally owned by Luke Steigmeyer.

The Oaks at Slaughter development will have several new businesses opening by the end of 2021. (Deeda Lovett/Community Impact Newspaper)
New 18-acre shopping center in South Austin to open on Congress Ave. this fall

A new shopping center in South Austin will bring more than 10 new businesses this fall.

State Rep. Vikki Goodwin, D-Austin sent a letter July 23 urging Gov. Greg Abbott to allow schools to require masks. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Texas state reps. call on Abbott to permit school mask mandates amid rising COVID-19 cases

The letter, spearheaded by Rep. Vikki Goodwin, called upon Gov. Greg Abbott and Texas Education Agency Commissioner Mike Morath to permit school districts to enact mask mandates and provide virtual learning options.

The new 35-story building overlooks Lady Bird Lake and Shoal Creek. (Trent Thompson/Community Impact Newspaper)
Workers celebrate topping out of Austin 'sailboat building' concrete structure

Workers who contribute to the construction of the Block 185 building celebrated topping off the structure, a big milestone for the development project that began in 2019.

A system to identify at-risk Austin Police Department employees has not been effective. (Maggie Quinlan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Audit finds Austin police system to flag at-risk officers is failing

Austin's city auditor and police chief agree the police department's computer program to identify at-risk officers is not fulfilling its mission.

A rise in COVID-19 cases has Travis County back in stage 4. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
Austin reverts to Stage 4 guidelines with rising delta variant cases

As delta variant COVID -19 cases are sending more young people to local ICUs, The Austin-Travis County Health Authority has moved the area back to guidelines that require masks indoors.

Opening day at Q2 Stadium
US men’s soccer team to visit Q2 Stadium this fall

The U.S. men's national team will host Jamaica for a FIFA World Cup qualifier game on Oct. 7.

Capital Metro is hosting a series of virtual meetings to hear feedback from the community on the latest Project Connect designs. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Capital Metro seeks community input on latest Project Connect design

Want to have your voice heard about Project Connect? Tune in to the upcoming virtual meetings.

Leander Marketplace PUD would be located at the northeast corner of Hero Way and US 183. (Screenshot courtesy city of Leander)
Leander eyes development with restaurants, retail; Bin Drop opens in New Braunfels and more top Central Texas news

Read the top business and community news from the past week from the Central Texas area.