Texas House votes to largely prohibit mandatory vaccines for children put in temporary Child Protective Services care

In what was expected to be a discussion of a largely bipartisan-supported bill that proposes improvements for the state's Child Protective Services agency, the merits of vaccines were hotly debated Wednesday afternoon.

One of the solutions proposed in the bill, authored by state Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston, would require the Department of Family and Protective Services to administer a medical and mental examination for children in CPS custody for more than three days. These children would have likely been taken out of the custody of parents for safety concerns.

The guidelines for these examinations would be set by the Health and Human Services Commission and medical practitioners, should the bill be passed.

But other lawmakers wanted to give their input as well.

State Rep. Bill Zedler, R-Arlington, proposed an amendment that would preclude physicians from administering vaccines in these examinations. Supporters of this amendment argued that when a child is in temporary custody, there are plenty of unknowns, including what the parent's choice would be and the child's medical history.

State Rep. Sarah Davis, R-West University Place, attempted to negate Zedler's amendment by adding some key changes. One change featured language that would permit vaccines as long as those vaccines prevented cancer.

She argued this would empower doctors to make the right decisions for the child's health care, leading to a skirmish with state Rep. Jeff Leach, R-Plano. Leach argued the act of empowering one "disempowers" another.

"It is my belief that your amendment would rip that decision from the parents and give it to the doctors," Leach said.

Davis said allowing doctors to vaccinate children simply allowed them to practice medicine. She said it would be immoral for the state House to vote against allowing vaccines that could prevent cancer.

"I want to know who in this body does not believe in the science of vaccines," Davis said.

The amendment was defeated in a 74-64 vote, showing Davis who among her fellow legislators would be supportive of vaccinations.

Notably, state Rep. Tom Oliverson, R-Cypress, and state Rep. Greg Bonnen, R-Friendswood, both doctors, were among those voting against the amendment to allow vaccinations.

Wu, in an attempt to neutralize Zedler's amendment, worked to draft more friendly language that wouldn't derail his bill.

The new amendment would allow vaccinations in the case of tetanus and if CPS has been named the managing conservator of a child, a situation that Wu said often occurs after 14 days of state-led care.

Zedler's amendment, as changed by Wu, was eventually tacked onto the CPS bill in a 74-58 vote.

Another physician, state Rep. J.D. Sheffield, R-Gatesville, spoke out against the amendment before it passed, asking to have the vaccine debate on a different day.

"This discussion about vaccinations should be a separate, standalone bill, on a separate, different day," Sheffield said.

The overall bill tentatively passed the House in a 120-15 vote. The final vote will likely be taken Thursday.
SHARE THIS STORY


MOST RECENT

IDEA Hardy
2 IDEA Public Schools campuses to break ground Nov. 12

The charter school will host a groundbreaking ceremony for the campuses from 10-11 a.m. at the IDEA Hardy location at 1930 Little York Road, Houston.

Clear Creek ISD sign, CCISD stock image (Jake Magee/Community Impact Newspaper)
Clear Creek ISD board examines committee work, community input regarding school start times

The Clear Creek ISD board of trustees next week is expected to make a decision that would potentially adjust school start times, prompting at least two board members to wonder if there has been enough time to examine the issue.

1. Courtesy Conroe ISD Communications
Recent highlights: A school dedication, Pride festival and other events and awards in The Woodlands area this fall

In September, educators were honored at a Conroe ISD elementary school dedication and local events include The Woodlands Pride festival.

The store offers crafts, gifts, home decor items and sports memorabilia. (Courtesy Spring Trading Post)
Spring Trading Post to close following two final markets Dec. 14, 21

The store offers crafts, gifts, home decor items and sports memorabilia.

Snow fell at the Tomball Museum Center in early December 2017 (Anna Lotz/Community Impact Newspaper)
Greater Houston area to experience cold front Nov. 11-13; temperature could reach freezing point

The front is not expected to affect travel because the ground is too warm for precipitation to stick.

Courtesy Interfaith of The Woodlands
Your 2019 Volunteer Guide: Community organizations in south Montgomery County that need a helping hand

Help out The Woodlands area in a number of ways throughout the year by volunteering with local nonprofit groups.

New Internet sales tax rules take effect in Texas

On Oct. 1, two new sets of rules regarding sales tax collection in Texas took effect

Grand Pines Drive construction is scheduled to be complete in April 2020, according to Montgomery County Precinct 2 Commissioner Charlie Riley. (Kara McIntyre/Community Impact Newspaper)
GALLERY: Take a look at Grand Pines Drive construction in the Magnolia area

Construction on Grand Pines Drive—a two-lane road connecting Nichols Sawmill to Sanders Cemetery roads—is ongoing in the Magnolia area.

(Rendering Courtesy AMTEX)
AMTEX to break ground on affordable housing development Green Oaks Apartments on Nov. 14

The three-story, 177-unit apartment complex is slated for completion by May 2021 and will feature a pool, a courtyard and a clubhouse.

pencils and notebooks
Pearland ISD holds town hall on vaping, campus safety

Pearland ISD held a town hall at Dawson High School on Oct. 17 to discuss vaping as well as school safety and security.

(Courtesy Bowlero)
Bowlero to celebrate grand opening of Willowbrook bowling alley Nov. 23

Bowlero will celebrate the grand opening of its Willowbrook location Nov. 23.

City officials, community leaders and local veterans gathered to break ground on the Missouri City Veterans Memorial on Nov. 11. (Beth Marshall/Community Impact Newspaper)
Missouri City breaks ground on long-awaited Veterans Memorial

The memorial, designed by Lloyd Lentz, was first proposed in 2011. The city hopes to begin construction in March.

Back to top