Texas House votes to largely prohibit mandatory vaccines for children put in temporary Child Protective Services care

In what was expected to be a discussion of a largely bipartisan-supported bill that proposes improvements for the state's Child Protective Services agency, the merits of vaccines were hotly debated Wednesday afternoon.

One of the solutions proposed in the bill, authored by state Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston, would require the Department of Family and Protective Services to administer a medical and mental examination for children in CPS custody for more than three days. These children would have likely been taken out of the custody of parents for safety concerns.

The guidelines for these examinations would be set by the Health and Human Services Commission and medical practitioners, should the bill be passed.

But other lawmakers wanted to give their input as well.

State Rep. Bill Zedler, R-Arlington, proposed an amendment that would preclude physicians from administering vaccines in these examinations. Supporters of this amendment argued that when a child is in temporary custody, there are plenty of unknowns, including what the parent's choice would be and the child's medical history.

State Rep. Sarah Davis, R-West University Place, attempted to negate Zedler's amendment by adding some key changes. One change featured language that would permit vaccines as long as those vaccines prevented cancer.

She argued this would empower doctors to make the right decisions for the child's health care, leading to a skirmish with state Rep. Jeff Leach, R-Plano. Leach argued the act of empowering one "disempowers" another.

"It is my belief that your amendment would rip that decision from the parents and give it to the doctors," Leach said.

Davis said allowing doctors to vaccinate children simply allowed them to practice medicine. She said it would be immoral for the state House to vote against allowing vaccines that could prevent cancer.

"I want to know who in this body does not believe in the science of vaccines," Davis said.

The amendment was defeated in a 74-64 vote, showing Davis who among her fellow legislators would be supportive of vaccinations.

Notably, state Rep. Tom Oliverson, R-Cypress, and state Rep. Greg Bonnen, R-Friendswood, both doctors, were among those voting against the amendment to allow vaccinations.

Wu, in an attempt to neutralize Zedler's amendment, worked to draft more friendly language that wouldn't derail his bill.

The new amendment would allow vaccinations in the case of tetanus and if CPS has been named the managing conservator of a child, a situation that Wu said often occurs after 14 days of state-led care.

Zedler's amendment, as changed by Wu, was eventually tacked onto the CPS bill in a 74-58 vote.

Another physician, state Rep. J.D. Sheffield, R-Gatesville, spoke out against the amendment before it passed, asking to have the vaccine debate on a different day.

"This discussion about vaccinations should be a separate, standalone bill, on a separate, different day," Sheffield said.

The overall bill tentatively passed the House in a 120-15 vote. The final vote will likely be taken Thursday.


MOST RECENT

An effort to widen White Oak Bayou is one of several flood mitigation projects that are moving forward in Jersey Village, according to a series of Nov. 30 announcements. (Shawn Arrajj/Community Impact Newspaper)
Contract approved for two flood-control projects in Jersey Village

Two flood-control projects in the city of Jersey Village are moving forward after city council members unanimously approved two contracts at a Feb. 22 meeting.

District officials shared storm damage photos at a Feb. 22 board meeting. (Courtesy Clear Creek ISD)
Clear Creek ISD updates: 88% of campuses sustained damage during winter storm, quarantine practices revised

District safety officials briefed trustees at a board meeting Feb. 22 about the extent of damages and gave other details related to CCISD’s storm responses. Of the 42 campuses, 37 sustained damages requiring immediate action, officials said.

The median price of homes sold also increased in all ZIP codes.(Courtesy Adobe Stock)
See how the Lake Houston-area real estate market fared in January

The median price of homes sold also increased in all ZIP codes.

key in door lock
Evictions continue in Houston as new measures aim to stem tide

Over 32,000 eviction cases were filed in Harris County courts in 2020.

Montgomery County Precinct 2 hosts a heavy-trash cleanup day for residents on March 13-14. (Courtesy Precinct 2)
Here's a list of things to do in Tomball, Magnolia this March

From spring break virtual events for kids to spring markets, a number of Tomball- and Magnolia-area organizations will be hosting events this March.

Houston City Hall in rainbow lighting
Greater Houston LGBT Chamber of Commerce celebrates five years of service

The organization is open to all and serves members throughout the Greater Houston area.

Krab Kingz Seafood will open in Humble March 17. (Courtesy Krab Kingz Seafood)
Krab Kingz Seafood to open Humble-area eatery in March

“It’s all about the quality of the food,” Wright said. “We care about the food, I think that’s our best quality.”

Montgomery County is set to receive its largest first-dose allocation during the week of March 1. (Ali Linan/Community Impact Newspaper)
Montgomery County set to receive largest vaccine allocation yet in first week of March

Nearly 20,000 vaccine doses were allocated to the county's two vaccine hubs and several additional providers for the week of March 1.

A coronavirus vaccine is given at Memorial Hermann's mass vaccine clinic Feb. 26. (Andrew Christman/Community Impact Newspaper)
Memorial Hermann closes out 2nd round of vaccines with 7,000 distributed among 2 clinics

The clinic will continue operations through 5:30 p.m. Feb. 27.

Reedy Chapel, one of more than a dozen historically Black churches in Galveston, is a stop on the tour. (Courtesy Clayton Kolavo/GICVB Marketing)
Galveston tourism app guides visitors through city’s historically Black institutions, monuments

The interactive app, offered by the Galveston Island Convention & Visitors Bureau, allows visitors to customize a tour itinerary based on interests and time allocation.