Nearly 30 residents spoke at Manvel City Council’s Nov. 16 meeting in opposition to a proposed group home for people with disabilities located in the Newport Lake Estates subdivision.
The motion to approve the specific use permit, or SUP, failed in a 0-6 vote, with council member Jason Albert absent.
Some context
An applicant representing BAC Restoration Care Home requested an SUP to operate a group home for the disabled without nursing care at a property located in the Newport Lake Estates subdivision, which is currently zoned as a single-family residential district, city documents show.
The applicant currently lives at the property and said the four-bedroom home would remain a single-family residence, with three bedrooms available for residents and the possibility of using another for respite stays, documents show.
The applicant also stated the home could potentially participate in the Veterans Affairs foster program, but could also operate independently as a for-profit business.
Also of note
The Planning, Development and Zoning Commission previously voted 1-6 against recommending approval of the request at its Nov. 9 meeting, with conditions including limiting the number of residents to two per bedroom, requiring one vehicle per bedroom and establishing a minimum 60-day tenancy, documents show.
Respite stays, boarding house operations and short-term transitional arrangements wouldn’t be allowed under the proposed conditions. City staff also noted that compatibility with the neighborhood would depend on factors such as the number of residents, vehicles and length of tenancy, documents show.
In their own words
Resident Jackie Bridges cited concerns about increased traffic, parking, safety, privacy and the overall character of the neighborhood.
“If the expectations and protections of a residential community can continue to be changed, then what assurance do homeowners have that the community they invested in will remain what they purchased?” Bridges said.
Several council members also expressed concerns about the proposed use, including council member Carmyn Robey-Robinson, who questioned whether a for-profit care home was appropriate for a gated, single-family community.
“There are legitimate questions whether this proposed use meets the legal and regulatory requirements and I’m not convinced that these questions have been addressed,” Robey-Robinson said.