One year later: How Round Rock, Pflugerville and Hutto have adapted to Senate Bill 6

Image description
One year later: How your city has adapted to Senate Bill 6
Image description
One year later: How your city has adapted to Senate Bill 6
Image description
One year later: How your city has adapted to Senate Bill 6
Image description
One year later: How your city has adapted to Senate Bill 6
Image description
Senate Bill 6 Before and After
Proponents of Senate Bill 6 say the law guarantees some Texas residents autonomy from cities and provides relief from climbing property tax bills.

Critics of the law, however, express concern that it is just one more constraint in a line of recent state-level decisions to undermine the control of city governments.

And for regions like Central Texas where cities such as Round Rock, Pflugerville and Hutto continue to bolster their populations at extraordinary paces, the mandate has put a vise on planning, according to some local officials.

“You have to be very strategic in how you do [annexation]. Can you get there? Yes. Does it cost more? It does,” said Helen Ramirez, assistant city manager for the city of Hutto.

THE BILL


SB 6 restricts how much annexation authority municipalities now hold. Prior to the passage of the law, cities could annex land within their extraterritorial jurisdictions, or ETJs, into their city limits through voluntary and involuntary annexations and development agreements.

In cases of involuntary annexations, in which landowners do not readily consent to incorporation, a city would hold public hearings on the issue before sending the annexation to a vote before city council.

Now residents in ETJs retain more control in the decision-making process.

The bill was signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott on Aug. 15, 2017, after a contentious journey through the Legislature. State Rep. Donna Campbell, R-New Braunfels, authored the bill.

“This is an historic victory for local liberty and the rights of Texas citizens over power-grabbing cities,” Campbell said in an Aug. 14 press release.

State reps. Celia Israel, D-Austin, and Larry Gonzalez, R-Round Rock, both voted in favor of SB 6. State Rep. Dawnna Dukes, D-Austin, was absent for the vote.

If a city now wants to annex land in its ETJ that contains less than 200 residents, more than 50 percent of those landowners must approve annexation through a petition. That decision ultimately moves to a vote by city council.

In counties with more than 500,000 residents—Travis and Williamson counties both surpass that threshold—municipalities must first petition for annexations and then hold elections.

Only residents living in the affected area proposed for annexation may vote on the measure, and the electoral process has added an air of uncertainty to municipal long-range planning efforts.

Elections can be costly—Travis County Clerk Dana DeBeauvoir estimated the March primaries to cost about $1.14 million—and a failed annexation attempt could throw a wrench in imminent development plans.

Ramirez points to an industrial corridor on the western edge of Hutto’s ETJ where the city would like to provide infrastructure in order to spur economic development. However, several residential neighborhoods are adjacent to the properties, and the city would possibly have to pass the annexation by popular vote.

“Where we would want to serve and improve some areas, we may not be able to, or it would be more difficult,” Ramirez said.

In the time since SB 6 was signed into law, Round Rock has annexed two tracts of land—one voluntarily and one in a development agreement—according to city documents. In 2017, Round Rock annexed 150 acres of land in two tracts using involuntary annexation proceedings, the first involuntary annexations the city completed since 2006.

“While it has not impacted any immediate annexation plans for the City it certainly could have an impact on future decisions," said Will Hampton, Communications and Marketing director for the city of Round Rock, in a statement provided to Community Impact Newspaper.

‘SWISS CHEESE’ EFFECT


“This is the kind of bill that’s going to take decades to feel the full impact,” said Bennett Sandlin, executive director of the Texas Municipal League.

More than 1,000 Texas cities are members of the TML, according to the group, and Sandlin said some member cities have already stated they have cut back on voluntary services in their ETJs. Round Rock, Pflugerville and Hutto are all members of the lobbying organization.

According to Pflugerville officials, the new annexation procedures can result in confusing and inefficient city planning.

For example, the city of Pflugerville in June finished annexation development agreement proceedings on a 6.97-acre plot of land off Pflugerville Parkway. The historic Pfluger House is located on the property, and the property owners requested annexation into the city. However, an unoccupied house sits within the property boundaries, and because that land is owned by another title holder, the city could not legally annex the property without a petition.

As a result, that plot of land—0.29 acres total in size—is technically still in Pflugerville’s ETJ. Pflugerville officials refer to this as the “Swiss cheese” effect.

“These little [properties] get further and further isolated. It’s unfortunate,” Pflugerville interim City Manager Trey Fletcher said.

That property, completely enclosed in Pflugerville city limits, is not eligible for city services, according to Fletcher. If the house at some point becomes occupied and its resident calls in an emergency, then it is in the Travis County Sheriff’s Office’s jurisdiction.

“It makes no sense, and it’s a fairly common occurrence,” said Pflugerville Mayor Pro Tem Omar Peña.

PLANNING FOR BUILD-OUT


Two-thirds of Pflugerville’s land area is unincorporated and subject to annexation, according to Fletcher. The expanse of ETJ land is 40.39 square miles total.

Most of that land is currently agricultural, and as landowners sell to developers the city will have to stay in front of the growth to provide essential infrastructure and city services such as water, wastewater and emergency services. Pena said if the economy slows down, and therefore development, the city will have more time to acquire annexed land.

“But at the current rate of pace, I wouldn’t be surprised to see that entire area at least plotted out in the next 10 years and built out within the next 15 to 20,” Peña said. “It could be faster.”

Pflugerville officials maintain that there is currently no “compelling reason” to annex the vast majority of that space. But as land starts flipping, they expect developers to come to the city for voluntary annexation.

Under SB 6, Pflugerville and Hutto will lean on voluntary annexations and development agreements to sufficiently plan growth. Ramirez contends that Hutto has to look solely at voluntary annexations or routes that may not involve residential land annexation whatsoever.

“We don’t want to be a sprawled-out community. We want a mix in our tax base to be able to lower the tax rate in the future,” Ramirez said.

Hutto’s future planning, per Ramirez, includes high-density apartment communities, master-planned subdivisions and business parks.

With less than one year of SB 6 officially on the books, local city planners are still learning “the rules of the game,” Fletcher said. City officials expect the issue to be revisited at next summer’s legislative session, though there is concern that annexation rules could be expanded—not relaxed.

“I don’t think overturning SB 6 in the short term is politically feasible right now,” Sandlin said.

Local officials referred to the Texas state Supreme Court’s June 22 decision to overturn city-imposed plastic bag bans as a troublesome instance of expanding state control.

“There is a concern [legislation] is not going to stop at [SB 6],” Ramirez said.
By Iain Oldman
Iain Oldman joined Community Impact Newspaper in 2017 after spending two years in Pittsburgh, Pa., where he covered Pittsburgh City Council. His byline has appeared in PublicSource, WESA-FM and Scranton-Times Tribune. Iain worked as the reporter for Community Impact Newspaper's flagship Round Rock/Pflugerville/Hutto edition and is now working as the editor for the Northwest Austin edition.


MOST RECENT

COVID-19 hospitalizations also increased to 97 in the Austin metro. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
88 new coronavirus cases in Travis County on June 1 set single-day high

COVID-19 hospitalizations also increased to 97 in the Austin metro.

Richard Rhodes, the president and CEO of Austin Community College, said June 1 that the district is prioritizing the hiring of a new chief equity, diversity and inclusion officer. (Courtesy Austin Community College)
Austin Community College prioritizing hiring equity officer despite ongoing hiring freeze

The district brought up the hiring during a discussion about protests and demonstrations that have taken place over the past weekend.

Businesses shuttering their doors due to coronavirus restrictions lowered the sales tax revenue collected by cities in May compared to May 2019. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas comptroller reports 13.2% year-over-year state sales tax revenue drop in May

Tax collection revenue fell significantly in several sectors from May 2019 to May 2020, according to the comptroller's office.

A handmade banner is displayed outside a Round Rock home, referencing some of the final words of George Floyd. Floyd, an unarmed black man, was killed in Minneapolis by then-Officer Derek Chauvin on May 25. (Taylor Jackson Buchanan/Community Impact Newspaper)
‘Our diversity is a strength’: Round Rock, Pflugerville leaders urge unity, justice for George Floyd

In the week since George Floyd's death, protests have erupted across the country—as well as locally in downtown Austin—with participants condemning police brutality and targeted police violence toward black residents.

Williamson County reported 34 additional cases between May 30 and June 1. (Screenshot courtesy Williamson County)
OVER THE WEEKEND: 34 new cases of coronavirus, additional death reported in Williamson County

Currently, 10 patients are hospitalized, and four are in intensive care, per the report.

Demonstrators gathered at the Texas Capitol on May 31 to protest police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Texas officials respond to demonstrations, unrest in wake of George Floyd killing

Gov. Greg Abbott issued a state of disaster in Texas on May 31, while various city officials and law enforcment responded to protests and violence over the weekend.

A group of 16 mayors from municipalities within Travis County have signed a letter to County Judge Sam Biscoe requesting a per capita approach to the issue of COVID-19 relief funding. (Screenshot courtesy Kara King)
Group of 16 Travis County mayors signs letter requesting $23M in county COVID-19 relief funds

City leaders in Travis County, from Bee Cave to manor, have signed a letter to County Judge Sam Biscoe requesting more than $23 million in federal coronavirus relief funds be released to 21 municipalities as soon as possible.

Demonstrators gathered in front of the Texas Capitol on Sunday, May 31, to protest police brutality. (Christopher Neely/Community Impact Newspaper)
Williamson County Judge Bill Gravell speaks on George Floyd, Austin protests

“I think like everyone else, I was horrified [by Floyd’s] death," Williamson County Judge Bill Gravell said.

There have been 1,168 coronavirus recoveries in the county since mid-March, and active cases in Travis County are estimate at 2,011. (Community Impact Newspaper staff)
Weekend update: Austin metro coronavirus hospitalizations drop to lowest level since April 28

There have been 1,168 coronavirus recoveries in the county since mid-March, and active cases in Travis County are estimate at 2,011.

Candidates in the Senate District 14 special election responded to Community Impact Newspaper's questions about their campaigns to fill the vacant seat in the Texas Senate. (Design by Shelby Savage/Community Impact Newspaper)
Q&A: Senate District 14 candidates discuss the issues ahead of July 14 election

There are six candidates running in the special election to fill the seat of former Sen. Kirk Watson through 2022.

Travis County judge pushes back against attorney general's reprimand of stay-at-home order

Travis County Judge Sam Biscoe responded to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton's warning that county coronavirus orders conflicted with the state's.