Texas Education Agency's A-F accountability ratings reveal link to poverty

Image description
TEA accountability ratings reveal link to poverty
Texas school districts and campuses received state accountability ratings this fall from the Texas Education Agency, and campuses in Tomball and Magnolia ISDs appear to be in line with a statewide trend that some educators say is cause for concern.

More affluent campuses within Tomball and Magnolia ISDs fared better than those with high levels of economic disadvantage in 2017-18, according to a Community Impact Newspaper analysis of the districts’ campuses. Although all campuses within the two districts earned the Met Standard label, schools where less than 20 percent of students were economically disadvantaged averaged a 93 rating, and those with more than 50 percent economically disadvantaged populations averaged a 78.



Across Texas, 58.7 percent of students are considered economically disadvantaged, meaning they qualify for reduced-price or free lunches or other public assistance. In TISD, 21.8 percent of students fall into this category.

In MISD, 44.2 percent of students are economically disadvantaged.

Under the TEA’s new A-F accountability rating system that was implemented for districts in 2017-18, TISD received an overall A rating, while MISD received an overall B rating.

“It’s been shown for years that ... standardized tests favor students that are from more affluent families,” said Anita Hebert, MISD assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction. “That’s one of the problems [with] trying to rate a school just on standardized tests. I think that [trend is] going to continue to play out.”

Rating districts


A-F scores are calculated based on the evaluation of three areas—Student Achievement, School Progress and Closing the Gaps. Seventy percent of the score is made up of either its Student Achievement or School Progress score—whichever is higher—and 30 percent of the score consists of its Closing the Gap score, which measures progress among economically disadvantaged students, according to the TEA.

Student Achievement reflects performance on state assessments, and School Progress measures improvement from year to year.

A similar system is used to identify scores for campuses, although letter ratings will not be implemented for campuses until next year.

Children at Risk, a Houston-based research organization focused on children’s issues in Texas, has found a relationship between raw achievement scores and economic disadvantage but has not determined whether it believes the TEA system is unfair, said David McClendon, co-director of the organization’s Research Center for Social Measurement and Evaluation.

Five of six MISD campuses with more than 50 percent economic disadvantage scored less than 80, TEA data shows.

TEA officials have defended the new system, which is designed to communicate a district’s annual progress in straightforward language more easily understood than the previous ratings, said Lauren Callahan, TEA media relations and social media manager.

“We know that while there may be a moderate factor between a child’s economically disadvantaged status and results, we here at the agency know there is not a strong relationship between the two,” she said.

High-performing schools


Despite the trend for economically disadvantaged schools receiving lower ratings, there are exceptions. Although MISD’s Smith Elementary exceeded the state’s average for economic disadvantage, the campus earned a 92 rating, according to TEA data. Additionally, while Williams Elementary had the highest economic disadvantage rate in MISD, the campus did not receive the lowest accountability rating.

“We do believe that schools can outperform the curve with high-quality instruction, that we can teach students from poverty to be educationally competent. And that’s what we put as our work every day,” Hebert said.

Hebert said quality leadership and high expectations are to credit for MISD schools outperforming the curve.

“It’s not about test prep. It’s about kids achieving,” she said. “We really focus on the individual and helping him [or her] to continue moving forward.”

In TISD, Decker Prairie Elementary School earned a 92 rating despite 41 percent economic disadvantage.

TISD was one of just 153 districts and charter schools to earn an overall A for 2017-18, according to the TEA. However, of all TISD campuses, just Tomball Elementary School had more than 50 percent economic disadvantage.

“With rapid growth and ever-increasing expectations, we have really tried to keep ourselves focused and trained...to do the job right the first time, and if we don’t get the results we intended, to immediately respond to those needs,” TISD Executive Director of Academics Mark White said.

District officials said they believe new aspects of the A-F system—such as relative performance and college readiness—will help score schools more equitably in future years, regardless of affluence. Hebert said considering college, career and military readiness factors as part of student achievement—in addition to test scores—boosts scores for high schools under the new system.

“Relative performance holds districts and campuses accountable for how well their lower income students perform compared directly to the average performance of other campuses and districts with the same percentage of low-income students,” White said.
SHARE THIS STORY
By Anna Lotz

Anna joined Community Impact Newspaper as a reporter in May 2016 after graduating with a degree in journalism from Cedarville University in Cedarville, Ohio. In July 2017, she transitioned to editor. Anna covers education, local government, transportation, business, real estate development and nonprofits in the Tomball and Magnolia communities. Prior to CI, Anna served as editor-in-chief of Cedars, interned with the National Journalism Center in Washington, D.C., and spent time writing for the Springfield News-Sun and Xenia Daily Gazette.


MOST RECENT

raveneaux country club
Official: Raveneaux Country Club deal expected to close in late January without further Commissioners Court action

According to the HCFCD, the action taken by Harris County Commissioners Court earlier this month both authorized and approved the acquisition, meaning the deal is expected to close by Jan. 30 without another vote.

leo's shelf lone star college university park food pantry
Lone Star College-University Park launches Leo’s Shelf, an on-site food pantry

The food pantry is designed to serve campus community members with free grab-and-go meals, snacks, nonperishable pantry items and personal hygiene products.

Road work is still ongoing on the widening of FM 2978 in the Magnolia area. (Courtesy Fotolia)
FM 2978 widening still ongoing in Magnolia

Construction on the widening of FM 2978 in the Magnolia area is still ongoing.

Construction to widen Spring Cypress Road from Hwy. 249 to Hufsmith-Kohrville Road is scheduled to be complete in February. (Kara McIntyre/Community Impact Newspaper)
Spring Cypress Road widening to be complete in February

Construction on Spring Cypress Road between Hwy. 249 and Hufsmith-Kohrville Road is scheduled to be complete in February.

cbd american shaman eye dropper
CBD American Shaman now open at Hwy. 249, Louetta Road

The retailer sells CBD, or cannabidiol, products, such as oils, topicals, edibles, gummies, teas, infused water and capsules.

U.S. Rep. Kevin Brady, R-The Woodlands, speaks to students at Covenant Christian School. (Andy Li/Community Impact Newspaper)
U.S. Rep. Kevin Brady and others celebrate Covenant Christian School's FEMA grant

The event saw representatives from the city of Conroe, Montgomery County, the Texas Legislature and more.

Texas Central claims the $12 billion construction process would be privately funded, and the train would transport 6 million annual riders by 2029. (Courtesy Texas Central Partners/Community Impact Newspaper)
High-speed rail could break ground in 2020; opposition has doubts

Texas Central claims the $12 billion construction process would be privately funded, and the train would transport 6 million annual riders by 2029.

Feral hogs, seen here in neighboring Harris County, have been reported as a nuisance in parts of Montgomery County along Spring Creek, including The Woodlands. (Kelly Schafler/Community Impact Newspaper)
Commissioner: Feral hog trapping program to begin in Montgomery County Precinct 3 immediately

Montgomery County Precinct 3 Commissioner James Noack announced Jan. 17 he has contracted with a professional wildlife removal company to trap feral hogs in several areas on Spring Creek.

A portion of FM 1488 in Magnolia is scheduled to be closed this weekend. (Courtesy Adobe Stock)
FM 1488 lanes closed Jan. 18-19 in Magnolia

East- and westbound lanes of a portion of FM 1488 in Magnolia will be closed daily from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. Jan. 18-19.

Raveneaux Country Club was one of hundreds of properties that flooded during Hurricane Harvey in 2017. (Courtesy Harris County Flood Control District)
Cagle: Goal of Raveneaux acquisition is not to put an ‘ugly hole in the ground’

“The goal is to create something more along the lines of Kickerillo [Mischer Preserve] with beautiful park amenities—little fishing piers, boat launches and walking trails that go around it,” Cagle said.

Back to top