Mila Haruni, daughter of Al Lala, said their family comes from a long line of New York bagel shop owners.

“My grandfather was a baker, and so we were inspired by my grandfather,”Haruni said. “Growing up, we always had bagels. My uncles owned bagel shops and pizzerias. So dough has always been our specialty.”

After owning several bagel and pizza businesses in New York, Arizona and Texas, the family opened Classic NY Bagels in Magnolia last May to share their family bagel recipe.

A family affair

Originally from Albania in Southeastern Europe, Lala moved to the U.S. at the age of 17 where he lived above the pizzeria he worked at.


Forty-six years later, Lala opened several bagel shops and pizzerias, including Brothers Pizza and passed along his perfected dough recipe and businesses to his family. Destined to be in the bagel business, the family has several members with bagel shops across the country.
Classic NY Bagels bakes 500-600 bagels daily. (Courtesy Classic NY Bagels)
Classic NY Bagels bakes 500-600 bagels daily. (Courtesy Classic NY Bagels)
“We all have the same recipe. So all my cousins have bagel shops. So it's kind of like everybody went to school, they got a degree, they did what they did, and then they ended up right back to owning bagel shops,” Haruni said.

On the menu

Classic NY Bagels prides itself on its freshly baked bagels made daily from scratch with no preservatives. The bagel shop bakes 500-600 bagels daily with special ingredients imported from New Jersey. Any leftovers are donated to local nonprofits.

“We take each bagel from the dough in the tray and just plop it in to boil for a few seconds, then we throw them on our bagel boards to bake, and that's what makes them so crisp on the top but soft in the middle, which a true New York bagel always has,” Haruni said.
Classic NY Bagels has a dozen different types of bagels. (Courtesy Classic NY Bagels)
Classic NY Bagels has a dozen different types of bagels. (Courtesy Classic NY Bagels)
Lala said a plain bagel only contains 150 calories, making their bagels a healthier choice compared to a bagel with preservatives. With 12 types of bagels to choose from, Classic NY Bagels is known for its everything bagel and gluten-free bagels.


To support its community, the local bagel shop offers first responder, student and teacher discounts, and holds community events throughout the year.